Rachel SmithLet’s be real for a second. Nobody has the time or the steady hands required to transport a fragile buttercream masterpiece across town in rush hour traffic.
Between juggling party prep and dropping by a flower shop for last-minute office celebrations, you’re already stretched thin. So getting a cake safely from point A to point B can feel like a challenge on its own.
That’s where a reliable cake delivery service comes in clutch. You need a bakery that brings the sugar rush straight to your doorstep without a single smudge on the frosting.
That’s exactly why our team went on a delicious mission to track down the top-rated options for the best cake delivery in Indianapolis. See who made our list below!
How much does cake delivery cost in Indianapolis?
Getting a delicious confection delivered right to your door in Indianapolis generally costs anywhere from $10 to $50 for standard celebration orders, while specialized wedding transportation typically starts at $100.
| Delivery Category | Estimated Cost |
| Local Bakery Flat Rates (within 5 miles) | $10.00 |
| Custom Celebration Cakes (15-mile radius) | Starts at $50.00 |
| Wedding Cakes | Starts at $100.00 |
| Third-Party Apps (DoorDash, Uber Eats) | $0.00 (plus service fees and driver tips) |
1. Sweet Escape Cake Company
Website: http://www.sweetescapecakecompany.com/
Address: 7745 S Meridian St
Phone: +1 317-840-1562
Hours: Mon 9:00 AM-4:00 PM, Tue-Fri 9:00 AM-6:00 PM, Sat 9:00 AM-2:00 PM, Sun Closed
Finding a baker who can translate a wild mood board into an edible reality is tough. Thankfully, we found Sweet Escape Cake Company.
They deliver highly personalized, custom-designed confections tailored to your aesthetic and flavor preferences.
I actually ordered an elaborate, space-themed birthday cake from them recently, and seeing it arrive flawlessly intact was a huge relief. Every single slice tasted incredibly fresh, so I could tell the ingredients were high-quality.
The team is responsive too. This takes the stress out of planning and makes the process really smooth.
Just note that they have limited weekend availability. This can make Saturday afternoon or Sunday events slightly tricky to coordinate.
If you’re planning on ordering or scheduling a delivery, do it early.
They did a wonderful job with my nieces sweet 16 cake! It’s was tasty and beautiful. They got every detail correct.
The e mail process became confusing. But I was still able to confirm my order with an associate at the store.
The photo doesn’t do it justice , you can’t see all the glitter ! It was perfect and my niece love it!
I would highly recommend this company for any event!
– Taylor May Fire, Google Review
We had a surprise 80th birthday house party and I ordered this cake kinda last minute. This cake was the talk of the night! I was nervous about confirming the design of the cake all via email, however it turned out prettier than I imagined and surprisingly close to the design inspiration. The taste and texture were also out of this world! The price point was extremely reasonable also. The only negative is that its all gone. Lol 10/10 you guys will be my #1 choice for special occasions cakes from here forward. Thanks!!
– Brandy Howard, Google Review
2. The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers
Website: http://www.thecakebakeshop.com/
Address: 6515 Carrollton Ave
Phone: +1 317-257-2253
Hours: Mon-Thu 11:00 AM-7:00 PM, Fri-Sat 10:00 AM-9:00 PM, Sun 10:00 AM-7:00 PM
Stepping into this renowned establishment feels like walking onto a glamorous movie set. Everything about it leans into a luxe, high-end dessert experience, with rich pastries and cakes that look just as good as they taste.
If you’re thinking about gifting, their beautifully packaged treats can make whoever’s on the receiving end feel spoiled. The portions are surprisingly massive too, so one of their signature slices can easily satisfy a serious sugar craving.
That said, while the stunning interiors and wide selection of savory options are big draws, this is one place where you’ll want to budget ahead. It’s very much a premium experience, both in-store and for delivery.
Even so, the sheer decadence of their towering creations makes the splurge entirely justifiable for a monumental celebration.
Adorable little jewel box of a cafe at which everyone is always having a birthday! The service is top notch and they will go above and beyond to make your day special. Surprisingly, we enjoyed the other offerings more than the cake itself – particularly the croissants. The drinks are also beautifully presented, both adult beverages and the special kids’ ones.
– Megan Real, Google Review
Very fanciful. 🙂 The food was exceptionally good (sandwiches & soup) and the desserts are amazing. Our server was patient as we looked over the menu and very helpful when we had questions. Can’t wait to visit Indianapolis again so that we can return to the Cake Bake Shop.
– Lynda Waddington, Google Review
3. Nothing Bundt Cakes
Website: https://www.nothingbundtcakes.com/
Address: 8505 Keystone Crossing
Phone: +1 317-559-2632
Hours: Mon-Sat 9:00 AM-7:00 PM, Sun 11:00 AM-5:00 PM
Sometimes you just need a reliable, crowd-pleasing classic without the fuss of elaborate fondant architecture. Nothing Bundt Cakes does that really well.
They specialize exclusively in handcrafted, consistently moist bundt cakes topped with their signature cream cheese frosting. A colleague recently sent a box of their bite-sized “bundtinis” to my office for a quick celebration, and the rich texture immediately won over the entire room.
Having an integrated shop for both delicious treats and curated party supplies also makes last-minute party prep incredibly efficient.
Their excellent walk-in availability means you’re rarely left empty-handed when a sudden craving hits.
The only downside is that their menu is strictly limited to bundt-style desserts, so you will need to look elsewhere if you want traditional tiered cakes.
I got the red velvet Bundt cake last time and have been craving them since. Stopped by today and picked up the limited edition flavours lemon raspberry and strawberry cheesecake. We inhaled the lemon raspberry and can’t wait to try the rest! 4 cakes plus a free cooler bag that’s super cute for $25ish? Yes please!
– Vic Wong, Google Review
Dangerously addictive! Been several times and loved every one. The bundtlets come in a closed container so they keep well for days. I endorse them not only for the good taste but they have been community supportive. Donating their cakes this last week to the Teachers Treasues Gala. One of their cakes earned the Gala close to $500.00! Thank you very much!!!
– David Barrabee, Google Review
4. Cretia Cakes Bake Shop
Website: http://www.cretiacakes.com/
Address: 4640 N Keystone Ave
Phone: +1 317-929-1560
Hours: Mon-Wed Closed, Thu-Fri 11:00 AM-5:00 PM, Sat 10:00 AM-2:00 PM, Sun Closed
Craving a dessert that tastes like it was lovingly whipped up in your grandmother’s kitchen requires a special touch that massive commercial chains simply cannot replicate. If you’re looking for that, Cretia Cakes Bake Shop might be right up your alley.
This cozy neighborhood gem provides artisanal, small-batch baked goods crafted with a comforting homestyle touch and deep roots in the local community.
Every bite bursts with authentic flavor profiles thanks to their use of fresh, locally conscious ingredients.
Their warm, personalized customer service makes coordinating custom orders feel like a natural conversation. Because they focus on small-batch quality over sheer volume, you get incredible flexibility for personalizing your dream dessert. You must carefully time your cravings, however, as their extremely limited operating hours mean they are only open three days a week.
I ordered the caramel cake when it was featured on HSN.
The cake arrived today &
WOW !!!
IT IS DELICIOUS !
How do you make it so moist & light
I am definately a new fan.
Glad it wss packaged so well.
Needed each & every piece of packing to keep
It in one piece.
Keep on baking!!!
– Linda Roberts, Google Review
I got my husband a strawberry crunch cake for his birthday and it was delicious! It was huge so I thought there was no way we could eat it all but it was so good that we ate every bit. I arranged for store pick-up but they had deliveries in my area so they delivered it free of charge. Great customer service and delicious cake. I will definitely be ordering from her again.
– S W, Google Review
5. Taylor’s Bakery
Website: https://taylorsbakeryindy.square.site/
Address: 6216 Allisonville Rd
Phone: +1 317-251-9575
Hours: Mon Closed, Tue-Sat 7:00 AM-5:00 PM, Sun Closed
Nostalgia is a powerful ingredient, especially when it’s baked into a recipe that has survived the test of time. For many locals, they get that nostalgia from Taylor’s Bakery.
Functioning as a historic family-run institution with over a century of experience, Taylor’s Bakery is an iconic cake shop in Indianapolis. It delivers classic, reliable pastries and traditional cakes for convenient takeout.
Locals constantly flock here for their quick, efficient counter service, trusting a reputation built over 100 years of continuous operation.
Their incredibly diverse menu ensures that everyone at your gathering will find a sweet treat to enjoy.
Just keep in mind that securing a weekend dessert requires picking it up by Saturday afternoon. They’re closed on both Sundays and Mondays, which restricts accessibility for events held later in the weekend.
Extremely pleased with my experience with Taylor’s Bakery. I was able to make arrangements with the bakery to have a cake delivered to a local restaurant with no issues. We ordered a red velvet cake with cream cheese icing and it was absolutely delicious!
– Alisha Miller, Google Review
I’ve used Taylors’s Bakery for years for all of our birthday cake needs and it’s always been the best. But this year in particular, I have to give a big thank you to Yo, who answered the phone after hours when I was in state of panic realizing I forgot to pick up my daughter’s birthday cake before close after a busy day. She was so sweet and we were able to find a solution. Customer service like this is hard to find these days. We are so appreciative of Taylor’s and Yo!
– Jule Sexson, Google Review
