Andre TaylorLanding at the airport or planning a local road trip requires reliable transportation to navigate the Circle City. So, finding the best car rentals in Indianapolis can drastically improve your travel itinerary, minimizing transit headaches.
Having your own vehicle offers unmatched freedom, especially if you’re navigating downtown traffic or you want to visit the famous speedway. And if you’re coming in after a tiring flight, you won’t have to line up in long counter lines.
To help ease your journey, I’ve explored local options to identify services prioritizing efficiency and vehicle quality. Read on for my reviews of top local providers who can help you hit the road quickly!
How much do car rentals cost in Indianapolis?
Daily rates for can rentals in Indianapolis vary based on size and demand, generally starting at $28 for small cars and reaching upwards of $47 for larger passenger options.
| Vehicle Class | Starting Daily Rate |
| Small/Economy Cars | $28 – $32 |
| Medium/Intermediate Cars | $31 – $34 |
| SUVs/Large Vehicles | $41 – $47 |
1. National Car Rental
Website: https://www.nationalcar.com/en/home.html
Address: 7801 Col H Weir Cook Mem Dr, Suite 151
Contact: +1 833-315-5898
Hours: Monday – Sunday: Available 24/7
National Car Rental stands out for their membership service. For instance, their members can completely bypass the traditional rental counter and pick any vehicle they want from a designated aisle while only paying the midsize rate.
Their unique loyalty approach saves significant time at the airport terminal, as you can simply walk directly to the parking lot and drive away.
Flexibility continues with their reward system, letting users choose between free rental days or airline miles. They also allow a second driver at no extra cost, making it highly practical for colleagues traveling together.
However, these impressive speed benefits strictly apply to registered members, meaning one-time renters will likely face standard counter wait times. You also need to provide advance notice if you want a guaranteed specific car class waiting for you.
Customer Reviews
I arrived at Indianapolis airport late at nite after a snowstorm. I was tired and travel weary. The garage personnel were extremely helpful and kind to me during this time. They got my car quickly; they gave me instructions for safe travel, and they helped me with my heavy luggage. In all, everything that was customer service excellence. I was extremely satisfied with the car I rented. It was well maintained and clean.
- Gilda Allegion | Google Review
Recent trip to Indianapolis, we rented a national car. – Audi A5. The pick up was very easy as well as drop off. All the employees were nice, helpful, and professional. We had a couple snowstorms while we were there in the car handled it really well. It was a great experience overall!
- Adrianne Rice | Google Review
2. Alamo Rent A Car
Address: 7801 Colonel H Weir Cook Memo
Contact: +1 833-315-5899
Hours: Monday – Sunday: 5:00 AM – 2:00 AM
Alamo Rent A Car is best for travelers looking to avoid human interaction. With their unique self-service touch-screen kiosks at the terminal, clients can secure their keys immediately.
You’ll have to enter your information ahead of time online, but it ensures you spend fewer minutes lingering in the lobby.
Their fleet variety is also a highlight. You’ll have your pick from compact cars perfect for tight city parking to full-size vans suited for group outings.
Overall, the process is seamless. After dropping your bags off at your hotel, you can easily drive to various local restaurants for a quick bite.
They even offer a straightforward discount program that is completely free to join.
Just note that renters under the age of 25 must pay a daily surcharge and are restricted from selecting luxury vehicles.
Customer Reviews
Fantastic experience with Alamo, especially with their “skip the counter” option. That really speeds up the experience after a long flight with kids. When returning the car, the guys were super nice and helpful. One gentleman even saw my family struggling a bit with a big load of stuff and brought over a cart. It absolutely made our day. Super helpful and couldn’t be happier with the service. Thank you!
- Khang Tran | Google Review
They are friendly and considerate. Every time I have rented the cars are clean. and in great shape. The one at the airport in Indy will allow you to choose your car if they are able. Unheard of right!! But true. I adore them
- S. H-M | Google Review
3. Enterprise Rent-A-Car
Website: https://www.enterprise.com/en/home.html
Address: 7801 Col H Weir Cook Mem Dr, Suite 151
Contact: +1 833-315-5897
Hours: Monday – Friday: 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM, Saturday: 9:00 AM – 12:00 PM, Sunday: 11:00 AM – 3:00 PM
With Enterprise Rent-A-Car, crriving passengers can walk straight from baggage claim into the Ground Transportation Center.
I recently used their digital kiosks to handle my transaction, and I loved how this option allowed me to skip the primary counter line completely. It’s incredibly convenient after a long flight.
They also maintain an impressive selection of high-end exotic vehicles on-site for those wanting an upgraded driving experience. The company also waives the daily fee for a spouse or domestic partner.
With their smooth services, you seamlessly take your ride downtown to visit upscale shops or catch a film at nearby cinemas.
However, despite their famous slogan promising to pick you up, their specific airport location doesn’t offer that exterior pickup service. Also, drivers under 24 also face daily surcharges and inventory limitations.
Customer Reviews
We had a vehicle which we didnt like and it was too small for us, We also werent a fan of driving a Jeep Product, Our experience at a different enterprise location wasn’t smooth, however The customer service that the night manager Marcus has, was 100%!! We appreciate your flexibility and friendliness and will be back!! Till next time Marcus!! Best interaction in my enterprise renting experiences!!
- Vishrut Shukla | Google Review
I cannot say enough good things about this location, specifically Eric in management. I had been in 2 previous vehicle prior due to an accident, and Eric took the swap vehicle and got me in a vehicle in under 10 minutes, and even took the time to teach me how to work the car, as it was a little different than the Mazda I was in. He single handedly corrected another branches quality control issues and got me in a vehicle that was comfortable and met my needs. Thank you Eric!!!
- E C | Google Review
4. Go Rentals
Website: https://www.gorentals.com/
Address: 6390 Turner Drive
Contact: (463) 207-9000
Hours: Monday – Friday: 8:00 AM – 5:30 PM, Saturday – Sunday: 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Operating with elite hospitality standards, Go Rentals delivers vehicles directly to the tarmac or Fixed-Base Operator (FBO) so clients can step off a private plane and drive away.
A colleague who frequently travels for corporate events uses them exclusively for their reliability.
For starters, they guarantee the exact make and model reserved instead of assigning a vaguely similar vehicle. Each vehicle also undergoes a meticulous hand-washing process and a comprehensive inspection before handover.
They even assign a dedicated specialist to coordinate your itinerary. It’s also great that the necessary documentation is completed electronically before you even land, eliminating arrival paperwork.
Naturally, this level of white-glove personalization translates to premium pricing. In short, their focus on luxury travelers makes them impractical for budget-conscious tourists.
Customer Reviews
Great experience. Everyone was very polite and easy to work with. Picked up car at Uber pick up area and was able to just sign and drive away from there. Dropped off at departures and they had a person waiting to pick up the car.
- Scott Vargo | Google Review
We did delivery with this company they delivered to my husband and I at parking garage ! Will be using this company everytime when we come back to Indiana 🙏🏻 prices are reasonable. We found the car easily and thank you to the team and we had so much during the women’s NBA ALL STAR
- Nashay Smith | Google Review
5. Elevate Luxury
Website: http://www.elevate-luxury.com/
Address: 1238 Deloss Street
Contact: 317-459-5318
Hours: Monday – Wednesday: 7:00 AM – 9:00 PM, Thursday: 6:00 AM – 10:00 PM, Friday: 5:00 AM – 10:30 PM, Saturday: 6:00 AM – 9:00 PM, Sunday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Stepping away from traditional transactional models, Elevate Luxury implements a high-touch concierge approach to exceed standard travel expectations.
They specialize in extended daily, weekly, and monthly options specifically tailored for long-term luxury needs. Plus, the team provides around-the-clock support to resolve issues instantly, ensuring constant peace of mind during your journey.
They even extend specialized rate reductions to military personnel and first responders as a gesture of community appreciation.
If you prefer not to navigate unfamiliar roads themselves, you can even opt for their professional chauffeur services instead.
However, budgeting for these high-end rides requires some flexibility because the mandatory security deposit fluctuates based on the specific vehicle selected.
Furthermore, renters between the ages of 21 and 24 encounter restricted access to the most premium fleet categories.
Customer Reviews
Amazing experience with Justin at Elevate Luxury. Rented the BMW i8 for my husband for our 10th anniversary. Great fun for a few days and sad to have to give it back! Outstanding service all around and they detailed his car while we had the i8. Will definitely rent again!
- Emily Zarse | Google Review
The service was superb!! You can’t beat the vehicle being dropped off to your front door AND picked up!! Sam and Justin are amazing!! They are easy to contact and returned missed calls very quickly! They’re very easy to work with and the process is very smooth. I feel as though I have my own personal luxury car rental service! Give them a try I guarantee you won’t be dissatisfied!!
Michelle ~
- Michelle Winters | Google Review
