Rachel SmithFinding the Best Creative Agency in Indianapolis requires digging deeper than a flashy logo. You need a team that navigates the local landscape with precision, understanding everything from the tech boom in Fishers to the historic roots of Mass Ave.
Agencies here do not simply produce art, but they also drive revenue and solve complex business problems.
People who start up needing a brand from scratch will find strong allies here, while marketing managers at mid-market firms can discover partners ready to pivot.
I have spent time analyzing the local heavy hitters to see who actually delivers on their promises. These agencies stood out for their strategic depth and ability to make an impact.
Each brings a unique strength to the table, ensuring that no matter your industry, you can find a creative home that aligns with your goals.
How much does Creative Agency cost in Indianapolis?
Navigating agency fees in Indy usually depends on whether you are looking for a one-time spark or a long-term flame.
For ongoing digital support, most local businesses pay between $2,500 and $12,000 every month on a retainer basis.
If you are planning a single big move, like a brand identity overhaul or a total website redesign, expect project costs to land anywhere from $5,000 to over $50,000. For smaller, hourly tasks, you will generally find rates between $100 and $300 per hour.
Think of it this way: a basic brand refresh might cost as much as a used car, while a full-scale national campaign is more like buying a small house.
1. CCM Creative Agency
Website: https://ccmcreative.co/
Address: 5255 Winthrop Ave #110
Contact: +1 317-572-7677
Hours: Monday–Friday: 9 AM–5 PM
CCM Creative Agency shines as a full-service partner that prioritizes the relationship over the invoice. They position themselves as an extension of your team, which organizations with big visions but limited technical resources find invaluable.
I love their focus on cinematic storytelling, where they produce video content that captures authentic human moments and drives emotional engagement.
While visiting their space at The Speak Easy in Broad Ripple, I saw firsthand how they collaborate with local entrepreneurs in a way that feels like a genuine partnership rather than a transaction.
Notably, they also devote significant energy to non-profits and faith-based groups.
However, their specific industry focus might be a deterrent if you operate in a strictly industrial or dry corporate sector.
Customer Reviews
Honest, professional, creative and driven
Greg recently created a website for our new business, Indiana Critter Catchers. The site was live in less than a few weeks and all our needs and ideas addressed to the fullest. He is honest, professional, creative and driven. We couldn’t ask for a better marketing talent. We hope to watch our business grow with excellence behind it.
- Jackie Brewer | Google Review
Thank you Greg for your visit to our club
Greg gave a great presentation for our Greenfield Rotary Club this past week. The presentation was about business app’s available on the web – – mostly for free. Especially for social media and networking. Thank you Greg for your visit to our club. I am recommending your presentation to other Rotary Clubs.
- Dennis Hoover | Google Review
2. Pivot Brands
Website: https://pivot-brands.com/
Address: 1533 Lewis St Office 341
Contact: +1 317-536-0047
Hours: By appointment
Pivot Brands is the agency you call when your brand has hit a plateau and needs a serious gear shift. They are results-oriented and prioritize execution over endless abstract consulting.
Their Fractional Leadership model transforms operations for mid-market companies that need executive-level strategy without the $200k salary of a full-time CMO.
I was particularly impressed by how they look at the back end of a business, like supply chains and team structures, rather than focusing solely on aesthetics.
They’re selective about who they work with, which lets them deliver high-touch mentorship and strategy.
The trade-off is they’re not built for volume, so if you only need a few basic weekly social posts, they’ll likely feel like overkill and cost more than you want to spend.
Customer Reviews
I would recommend Pivot any time
Visit Bloomington hired Pivot for a rebrand a few years back and that decision is still paying off. We love our branding and hired them for more jobs after that because they were so effective and easy to work with. I would recommend Pivot any time.
- Mike McAfee Google Review
Pivot is fantastic!
You gave our rebrand a full team effort to make it the best it could be. It was thorough and thought-through. importantly, we felt like no stone was left unturned in making the decisions we did. Pivot is fantastic!
- Robert Johnson Google Review
3. Boldthink
Website: https://boldthinkcreative.com/
Address: 350 Massachusetts Ave #300
Contact: +1 317-731-2653
Hours: Monday–Friday: 9 AM–5 PM
Boldthink operates on the principle that your brand should be as smart as it is bold. They use a structured methodology called Brand GPS to make sure every dollar you spend on marketing is actually anchored to a business objective.
They are a strategic consultancy first and a creative vendor second, which is a breath of fresh air for businesses tired of fluff.
Having chatted with a local marketing director who went through their rebranding process, I heard that their ability to untangle chaos is their real superpower.
They even take the time to teach you the strategy so you can actually own your brand’s future. Instead of keeping everything behind a curtain, they explain the “why” so you can make confident decisions long after the project ends.
Their GPS process is thorough, but it takes time, so if you need a logo by Friday, you’ll need to look elsewhere. They’re also premium-priced, meaning it’s a bigger investment than hiring a freelancer if you only need minor graphics tasks done.
Customer Reviews
The Boldthink team were amazing to work
The Boldthink team were amazing to work with and really helped bring our projects to life. They have a very customer-centric design approach; they work diligently to learn about your needs and how you envision the end product, and bring a wealth of experience to bring it all to fruition. Please know your brand or project is in the best of hands with Boldthink!
- Ken Bretz Google Review
The BoldThink team was phenomenal to work with
The BoldThink team was phenomenal to work with! Developing a brand can be intimidating and they made it both easy and fun. Some of the homework was challenging, but I see the benefit of going through the process. What these ladies do isn’t easy, and somehow they bring calm to the chaos. We couldn’t be happier with the results! Highly recommended!!
- Ryan Babaz Google Review
4. Hirons
Website: https://hirons.com/
Address: 422 E New York St
Contact: +1 317-977-2206
Hours: Monday–Friday: 8 AM–5 PM
Hirons is a powerhouse in the Indianapolis scene with a legacy dating back to 1978.
Interestingly, they are an employee-owned firm, which means everyone working on your account has a literal stake in your success.
Government marketing and public affairs work remains their strongest suit, as they help organizations navigate the complexities of community outreach.
Their crisis communications team has earned a strong reputation for a reason. If something goes sideways, they can roll out a polished response strategy within hours, which is a huge peace-of-mind perk.
They’re a massive full-service team, but they’re built for large-scale infrastructure and statewide initiatives rather than smaller projects.
A small mom-and-pop shop might feel a bit lost in their data-heavy, research-intensive process. That said, they are the professionals you hire if you need help with the big stuff.
5. Young & Laramore
Website: https://yandl.com/
Address: 407 Fulton St
Contact: +1 317-264-8000
Hours: Monday–Friday: 8:30 AM–5:30 PM
Young & Laramore serves brands that want to stake a claim on a national stage. They are an independent firm based right here in Indy, but they have a history of handling massive global accounts.
Their core philosophy is about finding the fundamental truth of a brand and sticking to it across every single consumer touchpoint.
Notably, everything they do is handled in-house, from strategic planning to their own photography and video studio.
This ensures that the message never gets diluted as it moves from a brainstorming session to a billboard.
They are also incredibly reliable for multi-year brand transformations.
Unfortunately, their big agency results come with big agency prices. They are a disciplined, high-end firm, so they are not the best fit for someone looking for a quirky, artsy-first experiment without a heavy strategic backbone.
