Lucas BrennanChoosing the right flooring can feel like a massive puzzle. For homeowners finally ditching old shag carpet or landlords preparing a rental for new tenants, the options in Indy are extensive.
You likely want a high-end look that remains within your budget. Moreover, you need a team that respects your schedule.
We investigated the local scene to find the shops offering the best balance of quality, price, and reliable service.
How much does flooring cost in Indianapolis?
In Indianapolis, your final bill depends heavily on whether you choose budget-friendly vinyl or luxury hardwood.
Generally, you should set aside between $3.50 and $22 per square foot for the total installation.
Basic vinyl or laminate typically costs between $3.50 and $12.50 per square foot.
In contrast, premium stone or solid hardwood often starts at $12 and can exceed $30 per square foot.
In addition, remember to account for the costs of removing old floors ($1.50–$7) and leveling subfloors ($3–$10), as these expenses add up quickly during a renovation.
1. Floors To Your Home
Website: floorstoyourhome.com
Address: 8502 Brookville Rd
Contact: +1 317-956-5627
Hours: Mon – Sat: 10 AM – 6 PM
Looking for a way to upgrade your home or rental without breaking the bank? Floors To Your Home lets you skip the middleman by specializing in manufacturer overstocks, so you get top-tier materials at a fraction of the cost.
Since they own nearly all their massive inventory, you won’t be stuck waiting on factory shipments.
Plus, their huge Brookville Road warehouse is packed with ready-to-go options that usually ship by the next business day. This is perfect for tight renovation schedules, but there’s a catch you should know about.
Just be careful with “Second Quality” or cabin-grade items because they’re sold as-is with a strict no-returns policy. If you’re stuck with any defects or damage, there’s no room for recourse if the floor looks rough.
Customer Reviews:
Really amazing store.
Really amazing store. Jose Delgado helped us pick out the flooring. He was very informative. Super nice guy. We went to the avon store and they didn’t have much but this place is has everything you need. The pictures are the flooring we got.
- Max Wallace | Google Review
Customer service here alone will keep me coming back
We build houses and the customer service here alone will keep me coming back. They have dealt with a lot from us… From waiting late because they knew we were coming from five hours away, To helping us load impossible loads… And to helping Us hand load an order that couldn’t fit onto the trailer with a forklift. Their patience and willingness to work with their customers is equally as wonderful as the product they provide.
- Amy Meyerott | Google Review
2. Brothers Floor Coverin
Website: brothers-floorcovering.com
Address: 8550 Michigan Rd
Contact: +1 317-251-0350
Hours:
- Mon – Thu: 8 AM – 6 PM
- Fri: 8 AM – 5 PM
- Sat: 10 AM – 4 PM
Brothers Floor Covering has been a staple for Indy locals for over 70 years, so they definitely know their stuff.
What I like here is how they simplify the selection process for homeowners and developers by delivering a full showroom experience at their location. What’s more, this “Shop-at-Home” service lets you see how samples actually look under your own lights rather than harsh warehouse bulbs.
Their crew takes care of all the hands-on details, expertly managing everything from subfloor leveling to precise doorjamb trimming to ensure a clean, professional finish.
On top of that, they’ll even haul away your old carpet and move the heavy furniture for you.
The catch? Their top-tier installation is strictly limited to the immediate Indianapolis area and nearby suburbs. This small service radius is a real bummer if you’re a property investor or business owner with projects located just outside the city lines.
Customer Reviews:
Great people, outstanding service and excellent work.
Great family owned business. We picked out new flooring based on their expertise. The flooring came in sooner than expected and the installation was completed very quickly. The installers were excellent. Not only did they do an excellent job, they were all super nice and respectful. I highly recommend this business. Great people, outstanding service and excellent work. I will use them, again, in the future.
- Thomas Hale | Google Review
Brother’s Flooring did an amazing job for us at a competitive price!
Brother’s Flooring did an amazing job for us at a competitive price! We needed to replace a few different types of hardwood floors purchased over the years. Brother’s did a great job removing the old floors and leveling the subfloor before installing the new floors. There was certainly more involved in our job than I realized and am so glad we had their skills and experience on the job to ensure we had a great result. Their team was a pleasure to have in our home and communicated with us every step of the way!
- Mike Farley | Google Review
3. Refloor
Website: refloor.com
Address: 5140 W 79th St
Contact: +1 844-733-5667
Hours:
- Mon – Thu: 8 AM – 7 PM
- Fri – Sat: 8 AM – 6 PM
- Sun: 10 AM – 5 PM
Refloor provides extensive coverage through its “4-Part Lifetime Guarantee,” which protects customers against issues related to labor, gaps, and even accidental damage on up to five planks.
They also offer a flexible “Love-It or Leave-It” program, allowing customers to receive credit back if they choose to redecorate or change styles later.
Speed is another major advantage when you opt for them, as Refloor frequently completes next-day installations thanks to its locally stocked inventory. Many neighbors and past clients have praised the company’s white-glove approach, noting how smooth and stress-free the entire process felt from start to finish.
However, customers should be aware that attendance during the final walk-through is required, since missing this inspection will void the lifetime guarantee and its associated protections.
Customer Reviews:
Happy so far! Installation went well.
Julie was very good to work with. She explained things well but wasn’t high pressure and didn’t take our entire evening. Happy so far! Installation went well. Very friendly and efficient installers. Jake followed through the entire process communicating each step along the way. Beautiful! Very satisfied!
- Mark Abell | Google Review
The finished flooring looks amazing!
Coordinator Kristi and Installer Matt were simply awesome to work with. Excellent communication at all steps of the installation. The finished flooring looks amazing! Looking forward to working with them soon on the second stage of our installation.
- Mark Salisbury | Google Review
4. America’s Floor Source
Website: americasfloorsource.com
Address: 7676 Zionsville Rd
Contact: +1 317-356-3181
Hours:
- Mon – Fri: 7 AM – 6 PM
- Sat: 10 AM – 4 PM
Upgrading your home or flooring a commercial space can be a huge hassle, but America’s Floor Source simplifies things. Their “Mobile Floor Source” service rolls a massive selection and a pro consultant right to your front door for a private viewing.
This is a game-changer if you’re short on time and want to avoid the headache of navigating a physical retail location.
Beyond that, they offer everything from classic wood to heavy-duty rubber, with a handy online tool to help you estimate costs beforehand.
One downside is that they operate on an appointment-heavy schedule for most services. This makes things tricky for walk-in shoppers, as you can’t just pop in and get what you need without planning your whole day around them.
Customer Reviews:
Very detailed, well organized, and extremely helpful
Karen was amazing! Very detailed, well organized, extremely helpful, and followed our whole project from start to finish (measuring, bringing several samples, being a great listener with helping us select the perfect vinyl wood floor planks for our whole house)!! Pedro installed the flooring and he and his crew were top notch and expertly laid our vinyl wood floor planks!! I highly recommend Karen and Pedro, they both earned 5+ STARS!!!
- Sharon Way | Google Review
These folks want to make sure you are happy
Tony, and PJ had the challenge of replacing an outlet box at the very top of our fireplace. This was high up and was done in a marble stone. As you can see they did a fabulous job and also did a great job cleaning up and protecting our furniture as well. In addition Wendy that did the customer service is a real pro and is one of the best we have ever had the pleasure of dealing with. These folks want to make sure you are happy and it is clear they know how!
- Duane Jebbett | Google Review
5. Best Flooring
Website: bestflooring.com
Address: 6935 Lake Plaza Dr C
Contact: +1 317-288-8662
Hours:
- Mon – Fri: 9 AM – 6 PM
- Sat: 10 AM – 4 PM
Best Flooring provides specialized services such as hardwood refinishing and custom tile work.
What I love about them is how they use a transparent three-step process involving a consultation, quote, and installation, which helps eliminate surprise costs.
They are frequently selected for economical projects in basements or rental properties, where durability, affordability, and quick turnaround times are essential. Property owners and investors appreciate their ability to deliver cost-effective solutions that still hold up to heavy use, moisture, and frequent tenant turnover.
Notably, the staff takes an educational approach, offering care tips for specific wood types to protect your investment.
Meanwhile, their work crews are efficient, often completing smaller carpet jobs in under an hour.
While they are highly rated, their physical presence is centered on the Northeast side of Indy and Westfield, which may be less convenient for residents in the southern areas.
Customer Reviews:
Best money we spent on Best Flooring !!
Absolutely amazing company . We had no idea who to choose for our entire home renovation. From the moment we met Jayden we knew we’d found the place . They knocked it out of the park from start to finish !! Best money we spent on Best Flooring !! Thanks so much to all of you and your crew .
- Christina S | Google Review
I am so pleased I chose Best Flooring.
I worked with Jayden and chose Best Flooring to buy carpet. This was my first experience with Best Flooring. Jayden helped me evaluate various carpets, determined the timing and the binding. I wanted a plush area carpet piece for our bedroom and Jayden did a great job. He kept me well informed during the process and delivered the carpet and helped us lay it as well. The carpet looks great in the room. I am so pleased I chose Best Flooring. And a special thanks to Jayden.
- Ellen Krause | Google Review
