Sandra MillerThere’s nothing quite like the panic of waking up to a silent furnace on a freezing Indiana morning. You definitely know it’s an immediate crisis when your heating system breaks down.
Indianapolis winters do not play around, and neither should you when it comes to picking a repair service. I’ve actually spent enough time shivering in my own living room to know which pros actually show up and who just leaves you on hold.
To help you stay warm, I reviewed trusted Indianapolis experts for furnace repairs, including legacy family shops and tech-heavy emergency teams.
How much do furnace repairs cost in Indianapolis?
When your furnace stops working, understanding the typical repair costs in Indianapolis can help you prepare before calling a technician.
| Service / Repair Type | Typical Cost in Indianapolis |
| Service Call / Diagnostic Fee | $95 – $190 |
| Average Furnace Repair Cost | Around $300 |
| Minor Repairs (e.g., flame sensor, ignitor) | $150 – $350 |
| Major Repairs (e.g., blower motor, heat exchanger) | $450 – $2,000+ |
1. Shortys HVAC Supplies
Website: http://www.shortyshvac.com/
Address: 7720 Mooresville Rd, West Newton
Contacts: +1 317-821-8770
Hours: Monday-Friday: 8 AM–5 PM
If you know exactly what’s wrong and just need the hardware, this is your place.
Shortys HVAC Supplies stands out as the nationwide OEM Parts Authority, making it a hidden gem for the DIY crowd. They carry a massive stock of genuine OEM parts, which is a big deal if you want to keep your warranty intact.
I once spent a whole afternoon looking for a specific control board, and their staff cross-referenced the part number in seconds. It is much more reliable than rolling the dice on a generic part from a random website.
Just keep in mind that they are strictly a supplier. They won’t come to your house to install the motor you just bought.
For a homeowner who isn’t handy with a multimeter, the lack of on-site service might be a dealbreaker. However, for quick shipping on high-quality components, they are a top-tier choice for high-quality components in the region.
These guys were so helpful
This was a great experience and these guys were so helpful. Same day part pick and convenient location. Also, they didn’t make me feel like I didn’t know what I was talking about just because I’m a girl and I so appreciate that. Thank you
- Shorty’s Tricia Parker | Google Review
Installed myself and works perfect!
Ordered a motor for my furnace that was quoted $1000-$10000 for the part or a new one. Found shortys online, emailed a question and ordered the part the same day. Installed myself and works perfect! Thank you for your business and will be coming back in the future.
- Jeffrey Flaig | Google Review
2. Armor Air
Website: https://www.armorair.com/
Address: 2461 Directors Row, Suite B
Contacts: +1 317-751-7794 / +1 317-648-5179
Hours: Available 24 hours
Armor Air offers Indy residents reliability and fixed pricing when it comes to furnace repair services. They’re the ones you call when you want a no-surprises experience.
Their technicians also earn high praise for being professional and thorough during evaluations.
A neighbor of mine actually signed up for their protection plan after a middle-of-the-night furnace failure. They were impressed that the tech arrived with space heaters to keep the family warm while a specific part was being sourced.
That kind of service is why they have such a loyal following.
The only real downside is that their premium membership approach can lead to higher quotes for simple one-off fixes.
They also tend to suggest preventative upgrades, which might feel like a bit much if you are on a tight budget. Still, for 24/7 reliability, they are a trusted choice.
Great overall experience
Eric came out right when he said he would and worked quickly and efficiently to figure out what was wrong with our system. When he found out what was wrong he gave us great details and gave us confidence. Great overall experience. Highly recommend.
- Brian Boudouris | Google Review
They were great!
Tyler from Armor Air just got done here and I wanted to share how amazing he was! Explained everything so it was easy to understand. Got things working again and clearly laid out all our options. My wife and I typically have used a different company in the past but we’ll be using Tyler and Armor Air moving forward. They were great!
- Cole Dunbar | Google Review
3. Appel Heating & Air Conditioning
Website: https://appelheat.com/
Address: 530 S Rangeline Rd, Carmel
Contacts: +1 317-846-0434 / [email protected]
Hours: Available 24 hours
For many homeowners, finding a heating company that combines experience with a personal touch can make all the difference.
Many local residents appreciate working with technicians who take time to explain how their system works instead of simply completing a quick repair and leaving.
One first-time homebuyer shared how Appel Heating & Air Conditioning’s furnace inspection turned into a helpful learning experience. The technician fixed the issue and explained how the system works so the homeowner could maintain it properly.
This kind of patient and integrity-focused service is what many customers associate with them. Serving the north side since 1948, they are known for expert service and high-efficiency systems as a Carrier Factory Authorized Dealer.
Scheduling is typically during weekday office hours, so appointments can fill quickly during the first cold snap of the season.
They are great to work with!
We’ve been customers of Appel for many years. During this recent winter storm our old furnace went out. Appel responded quickly to get us a new, upgraded furnace set up and running. They are great to work with!
- George McCue | Google Review
Affordable and top notch service.
These folks had a very difficult job on a very old home gas/boiler system. The followup and work detail was on point! We’re definitely having them to do our AC this spring. Affordable and top notch service.
- Craig Campbell | Google Review
4. Broad Ripple Service Experts
Website:https://www.serviceexperts.com/locations/
Address: 8227 Northwest Blvd Suite 300
Contacts: +1 317-649-8983 / +1 866-963-7996
Hours: Available 24 hours
When your furnace stops working, a company with strong resources and fast response times can make a big difference. Many homeowners want technicians who can respond quickly and handle both minor repairs and complex heating issues.
Broad Ripple Service Experts is often known for providing that level of support thanks to its large team and nationwide backing.
Their fleet of service trucks allows them to respond quickly. This quick action is especially helpful for property managers or multi-unit buildings dealing with urgent heating problems.
They also offer programs designed to make system upgrades easier. In particular, their Advantage Program allows homeowners to install a new furnace with no upfront cost while covering repairs through a monthly payment plan.
However, pricing can feel higher than that of smaller local companies for quick fixes, but many customers appreciate the reliability, NATE-certified technicians, and their strong satisfaction guarantee.
We were thankful that he arrived quickly!
Derek came out on a Saturday afternoon to replace our sump pump and a seal on our toilet. We were thankful that he arrived quickly! He worked with his manager, Josh, to quote us parts that were very affordable. He was very professional and expertly answered all of our questions. We will definitely use him in the future for all of our plumbing needs! I highly recommend giving Broad Ripple Service Experts a call.
- Lydia Sturm | Google Review
Nice, professional, and patient
Service Technician Ron S. came out twice over a cold weekend – once to diagnose the issue and once to replace the part. We were excited to see him again because he was so nice, professional, and patient with all of our questions the first time. He was straight forward and honest, calming all of our anxieties. If the rest of the BR Service Expert team is like Ron, then I would highly recommend the whole lot!
- Grant Goshorn | Google Review
5. Northern Comfort Systems
Website: https://northerncomfortsystems.com/indianapolis/
Address: 2905 E 46th St
Contacts: +1 317-953-2748 / +1 317-927-8497
Hours: Available 24 hours
Northern Comfort Systems is known for standing behind the quality of their repairs. If a repair is not done properly, they will return to fix the problem at no additional cost, which helps give homeowners extra confidence in their service.
Another benefit is their true 24-hour availability, which helps when heating problems appear late at night or during severe cold. Many loyal customers also join the Northern Comfort Club because it includes a lifetime repair warranty that covers future fixes.
Their technicians often perform a complete system evaluation to ensure everything is operating properly. This thorough approach can sometimes uncover additional improvements that raise the overall bill.
Even so, they provide clear flat rate pricing before work begins, although the starting service fee can be slightly above the local market average.
I recommend them 1000%
Northern Comfort Systems is the best. Fast response, value priced, with friendly and knowledgeable service techs. Yesterday Tom came for my fall checkup and was efficient, caring, and made sure I knew all that he was doing. I recommend them 1000%
- Rich Darby | Google Review
Northern Comfort provides excellent service
Northern Comfort provides excellent service. Ricky was fast, efficient, and made sure to explain every single step he was working on to me. I felt respected and have peace of mind that my pipes won’t leak anymore. I’ll be recommending him and NCS to others in the Indy area.
- Connor Buhl | Google Review
