Andre TaylorArriving in the Circle City usually calls for a certain level of sophistication. This is especially true if your plans involve high-profile client meetings or an unforgettable weekend celebration.
The right vehicle can really transform an ordinary trip into a smooth and elevated journey. Plus, finding best luxury car rentals in Indianapolis ensures that you can navigate the city with precision and style.
Whether you need a sleek executive sedan to impress your associates or an exotic sports car to stand out, the local market has some exceptional options.
You can let the quality of your ride speak for itself as you enjoy the luxury and performance that these elite fleets provide.
How much does a luxury car rental cost in Indianapolis?
In Indianapolis, luxury car rental prices vary based on the season and the model you choose. Standard luxury sedans typically start at around $100, while high-performance exotic cars can cost $300 or more.
| Vehicle Category | Daily Rate |
| Standard Luxury Sedans | $100 – $200 |
| High-End Exotic & Performance Vehicles | $300 – $1,000+ |
1. Elevate Luxury
Website: http://www.elevate-luxury.com/
Address: 1238 Deloss St
Contact: [email protected] | (317) 459-5318
Hours:
- Monday – Wednesday: 7:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Thursday: 6:00 AM – 10:00 PM
- Friday: 5:00 AM – 10:30 PM
- Saturday: 6:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Sunday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Elevate Luxury partners with Squeaky Detail for an integrated white-glove detailing program. This ensures every car receives meticulous hand-washing and interior conditioning before you turn the ignition.
I booked one of their luxury sedans last autumn for a week of driving to various upscale restaurants around town, and the pristine condition was immediately apparent.
They also offer a dual rental and chauffeur model, giving you the flexibility to drive yourself or hire a professional driver for the evening.
The main drawback is their strict daily minimum, which prevents hourly rentals if you only need a high-end car for a brief photo shoot.
You also have to handle rental extensions manually via text or phone call, bypassing the convenience of an automated online system.
Customer Reviews
My rental car was sexy and smooth
Omg Elevate Luxury is everything. Justin was so polite and respectful . Everything was great my rental car was sexy and smooth. This is the best rental luxury car rental place that you will ever come in contact with. You will never want to go anywhere else. Thanks Justin and staff.!!!!
- Sherese Butts | Google Review
Had an amazing experience
This was our first time renting a luxury vehicle and wasn’t sure who, where or how the process would work. Thankfully we found Elevate Luxury and had an amazing experience. We will definitely be using them for all our rental needs. From the rental process, the pricing, them delivering & picking up, and communication, everything was topnotch.
- Robert Grays | Google Review
2. Indy Black Car: Sprinter Van & Chauffeured Limousine
Website: http://indyblackcar.com/
Address: 12046 Pebblepointe Pass, Carmel
Contact: (317) 548-0382 | [email protected]
Hours: Available 24/7
Coordinating transportation for a large group or executive board requires more than just a standard sedan.
Specializing in a diverse high-capacity luxury fleet, Indy Black Car provides everything from executive SUVs to 14-passenger high-roof Sprinter vans for seamless group travel.
Every ride features a vetted, professional chauffeur trained in defensive driving to guarantee safety and discretion. Plus, expect personalized service with custom welcome signs and curated playlists tailored specifically to your event.
This level of service is ideal for arriving at prestigious galas or private screenings at local cinemas.
Keep in mind that this is exclusively a chauffeured service, meaning there’s no self-drive option if you prefer to be behind the wheel.
Their operations are also strictly confined within Indiana state lines, making them unsuitable for interstate luxury road trips.
Customer Reviews
The service was truly top-notch
Indy Black Car: Sprinter Van & Chauffeured Limousine exceeded our expectations. We traveled to Indianapolis for a conference and needed transportation for 16 people. Communication was excellent and consistent from start to finish, and the team was incredibly adaptable despite bad weather in the city. The vehicles were very clean and comfortable, and the service was truly top-notch. We will definitely book again the next time we’re in Indy.
- Daniel I. Nixon | Google Review
I am extremely pleased with Indy Black Car
I am extremely pleased with Indy Black Car. They are always prompt and communicative prior to and following the transportation. The drivers are consistently professional, pleasant, and respectful.
I sincerely appreciate how they track the flights and able to adjust pick up when there’s a flight delay.
There’s no way we would consider using anyone else— they’re truly exceptional!!
- Rose Mullen | Google Review
3. Exotic Car Collection by Enterprise
Website: https://www.enterprise.com/?mcid=iyp:24489700
Address: 4310 E 96th St
Contact: (317) 460-0038
Hours:
- Monday – Friday: 7:30 AM – 6:00 PM
- Saturday: 8:00 AM – 3:30 PM
- Sunday: 9:00 AM – 2:00 PM
Driving an exotic vehicle instantly elevates your road presence. Exotic Car Collection by Enterprise offers high-performance Ferraris and luxury Bentleys, putting you in the driver’s seat of automotive excellence.
Plus, you can feel confident in what you’re driving because every car goes through a strict certification process. This includes a full history report and a limited powertrain warranty for extra peace of mind.
I rented a Porsche 911 through their personalized service last spring. The staff was incredibly attentive and handled the entire handover with total professionalism. It really was an unforgettable way to take in the local scenery.
Just keep in mind that securing one of these elite cars requires meeting a few specific criteria. You must be at least 25 years old and provide proof of fully transferable insurance.
Also, be prepared for the security deposits. These are significantly higher than standard rental holds, and the exact amount will depend on the specific luxury model you choose.
Customer Reviews
The services provided supersedes my expectations
I’ve been fortunate to have the privilege of renting luxury vehicles, but the services provided by the Exotic Car Collection supersedes my expectations. Sheridan and Allison have been a pleasure to work with. If you’re someone who isn’t sure about the additional cost renting a luxury vehicle, the service from these women is worth the cost.
- Kurtis Condon | Google Review
Stellar customer service and great selection of vehicles
Allison and Sheridan from Enterprise Exotics made by rental experience a breeze. The Range Rover Sport that I chose was a stylish and luxury ride. I highly recommend the Exotic division for their stellar customer service and great selection of vehicles. Special thanks to Sheridan for her sweet personality and dedication to customer service. I highly recommend Enterprise Exotics!
- Jennifer Townsend | Google Review
4. National Car Rental
Website: https://www.nationalcar.com/en/home.html
Address: 7801 Col H Weir Cook Mem Dr, Suite 151
Contact: (833) 315-5898
Hours: Available 24/7
For those on a tight schedule, National Car Rental’s Emerald Aisle program lets you skip the counter and head straight to the lot. Simply choose any available car from the designated section to get on the road quickly.
If you want an even better experience, you can also access a specialized premier selection. This allows for an immediate upgrade to a luxury vehicle right there on the tarmac.
Another great feature is the flexible reward structure. It gives you the choice between earning free rental days or frequent flyer miles, depending on your preference.
To enjoy these benefits and skip the check-in line, you do need to have an active Emerald Club membership. Without it, you will have to use the traditional counter process, which is usually much slower.
Finally, keep in mind that the aisle selection changes every day. If you want to guarantee a high-end SUV, it’s a good idea to reserve that specific category in advance.
Customer Reviews
National at Indianapolis Airport is fantastic
National at Indianapolis Airport is fantastic. I travel there 15-20 times a year and each time is fantastic. Staff is always great as well as their vehicle selection especially for Executive Plus Emerald Club members.
- Nick Z | Google Review
I was off the lot in less than 15 minutes
The car I requested when making my reservation was not available when I arrived, so with no delay, the manager upgraded me to a luxury vehicle. I was off the lot in less than 15 minutes.
- Mark Whitney | Google Review
5. Alamo Rent A Car
Website: https://www.alamo.com/en/home.html
Address: 7801 Colonel H Weir Cook Memo
Contact: (833) 315-5899
Hours: Monday – Sunday: 12:00 AM – 2:00 AM & 5:00 AM – 11:59 PM
Streamlining the arrival process allows travelers to make the most of their time in the city. Alamo Ren A Car’s touchscreen kiosks offer a self-service bypass, letting you grab your keys and head straight to the premium lot.
They maintain a designated luxury fleet access tier featuring vehicles such as the Cadillac XTS, catering to discerning drivers.
Enrolling in their accelerated check-in system also speeds up the paperwork, while members automatically receive a guaranteed percentage discount on every reservation.
The major limitation of this system is that reservations secure a general luxury category rather than guaranteeing an exact vehicle model. Drivers under 25 face daily surcharges and are often restricted from renting high-end vehicles.
Customer Reviews
Return was amazing and hassle FREE
Rented a car mid size car thru costco .. when I got to the car rental at 1am they only had a nice luxury Dodge Van.. it was very nice and all Alamo employees from rental desk.. car pickup.. Return was amazing and hassle FREE
- Dharmesh Dan Patel | Google Review
Very happy with the service I received!
After a flight delay, I arrived after 2AM, wondering if the place would still be open, and if so, would there be any cars left. Not to worry, as there was still an agent on duty, who quickly got me the exact vehicle I had reserved. Very happy with the service I received!
- Jeff | Google Review
