Andre TaylorFinding a reliable mason in Indianapolis can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack of crumbled bricks. You need someone who understands the freeze-thaw cycles of our Midwest winters and treats your home with respect.
Historic chimney in Irvington or a modern patio in Carmel? The right contractor matters. I’ve taken the time to dig into the local scene and identify companies that consistently deliver high-quality, reliable craftsmanship.
These five businesses stood out for their craftsmanship, transparency, and ability to handle our specific structural needs. Each one has a proven track record of delivering dependable results without cutting corners.
How much does Masonry cost in Indianapolis?
Budgeting for masonry work here depends heavily on the materials you choose and the complexity of the job.
For standard brick installation, you should generally expect to pay between $15 and $30 per square foot.
If you are eyeing a manufactured stone wall, the price often sits between $25 and $65 per square foot. Natural stone is the premium option and can range from $30 up to $75 per square foot.
Smaller but technical jobs, like building a custom brick mailbox, usually land in the $1,000 to $1,500 range. Keep in mind that specialized repairs on historic homes may carry a higher premium due to the expertise required.
1. Smalling Masonry
Website: https://smallingmasonry.com/
Address: 2120 English Ave
Contact: +1 317-978-2482/+1 317-399-4388
Hours: Monday–Friday: 8 AM–4:30 PM
Smalling Masonry has carved out a strong reputation by focusing on the health of your chimney and outdoor living spaces.
One of the things that I really appreciate is their emphasis on moisture protection, which is critical for preventing spalling in our wet Indiana springs.
Their team positions themselves as true craftsmen who can handle delicate historic restoration just as well as modern installations. Customers often mention specific technicians like Caleb and Parker for their professionalism and ability to explain the work clearly.
The crew is also known for leaving the work area cleaner than they found it.
However, because they are so specialized and certified, their schedule fills up fast. You might face longer lead times during the fall rush.
Also, they have minimum service fees that might make them too expensive for very tiny repairs.
Customer Reviews
Sitting in front of our fireplaces is now our favorite thing to do!
Caleb was on time and did a wonderful job cleaning up our two old gas fireplaces. We just moved into our home 5 months ago and we did not like the fire places – the glass was dirty and you couldn’t see the logs. We weren’t even sure if our fireplaces were safe. Caleb was so patient with us answering all of our questions and helping us feel comfortable with using our fireplaces. Sitting in front of our fireplaces is now our favorite thing to do! Thanks Caleb!!
- Denise Burch | Google Review
I was so happy with their work!
I had my chimney rebuilt. The gentlemen doing my job was Storm and Logan. They arrived 15 min early every day. They were knowledgeable and experienced. They were very polite. I was so happy with their work!! I will definitely call Smalling back if I have any more problems.
- Lydia Oliver – Google Review
2. Shane C. Construction
Website: https://shanecconstruction.com/
Address: 7420 Shadeland Ave
Contact: +1 317-374-3100 / [email protected]
Hours:
- Monday–Thursday: 8 AM–6 PM
- Friday: 8 AM–5 PM
Shane C. Construction stands out because they bring a “family-owned” touch to both masonry and general construction. They are the experts you call when you need a chimney repaired and a new metal roof installed at the same time.
Their versatility is a huge advantage for homeowners who do not want to juggle multiple contractors. I actually spoke to a neighbor who used them for a roof and chimney combo, and they were amazed that the crew finished the metal work in just over a day.
Shane, the owner, is often seen on-site, helping to ensure everything meets his standards, and that kind of hands-on engagement isn’t commonly found.
The downside is that their popularity can lead to a backlog. Additionally, while they take credit cards, you should be aware of the interest fee for phone payments.
Customer Reviews
They completed the work in record time
Shane C. Construction Company did an incredibly impressive job on our new front porch. They completed the work in record time. They demonstrated service excellence through professional communication, a debris free area after the work was completed, and superior customer service. We are proud of our new front porch and happy we made the choice to go with Shane C. Construction Company.
- Cynthia Jackson | Google Review
Everyone was hard working and capable
Shane and his crew did an excellent job of repairing my fireplace chimney and the fireplace fire box.The work was done as scheduled and the brickwork matches great on the old chimney! Everyone was hard working and capable. I’m super pleased.
- Donna Paul | Google Review
3. Hoosier Masonry Solutions
Website: https://hoosiermasonrysolutions.com/
Address: 5327 E 27th St
Contact:+1 844-871-1872 /+1 317-483-0556
Hours: Monday–Friday: 9 AM–5 PM
Hoosier Masonry Solutions distinguishes itself by focusing on the root causes of failure rather than just the symptoms. They are the team to call if you are worried about moisture intrusion or thermal expansion cracking your bricks.
Their ability to analyze why a wall failed ensures that their repairs actually last. I like their specialized process for custom mortar matching, which is a lifesaver for anyone with an older home that needs seamless repairs.
Clients frequently praise this company for their exceptional communication throughout the project. On top of that, they also make complex structural issues easy to understand.
On the downside, they focus strictly on masonry, so you’ll need a separate contractor if you need other things done alongside, such as wood framing or softscape work.
Their weekday-only availability can also make scheduling an initial consult difficult for people who work standard hours.
Customer Reviews
The team was professional
We had additional brick installed in window wells and they matched the bricks perfectly and cut everything to fit. The work was completed within one day and we are so pleased with the end result. The team was professional and I would 100% recommend this company and will hire them again for any future work.
- Melissa Martin | Google Review
Did an excellent job with our old chimney and back patio
Did an excellent job with our old chimney and back patio. A few days before they started work on the chimney/patio job we had an issue with the roof in another part of our house that was an active leak. Before their competitors were even able to come out to give us a quote, Hoosier Masonry had already addressed the roof issue for us. Would definitely recommend and will use again.
- M.R. Amarante | Google Review
4. Warren Masonry and Roofing
Website: https://www.warrenmasonry.com/
Address: 1602 S East St
Contact: +1 317-956-0092
Hours: Monday–Saturday: 8 AM–6 PM
Warren Masonry and Roofing has been part of the Indianapolis scene since 1978, and that kind of long track record is hard not to trust.
They come across as the kind of high-integrity pros who can tackle everything from delicate historic restorations to full-on roofing services.
Their standout feature is the “No Payment Until Complete” policy, which offers incredible peace of mind. I have heard from friends who hired them solely because of that zero-money-down promise, and it completely removed their stress of upfront costs.
The team is also known for responding to inquiries within hours, which is refreshing in this industry. They are efficient and often start work the very next day.
They mostly focus on residential and smaller commercial jobs, so a large-scale industrial project may be beyond their sweet spot. They’re also closed on Sundays, which can limit scheduling flexibility.
Customer Reviews
The contractors were great!
The contractors today (5/2024) were great! They were detailed, nice, and thorough. We appreciated how they expertly matched the grapevine mortar joint with the rest of mortar. I will be using them again in the near future.
- Sarah Schilling | Google Review
Warren Masonry did a wonderful job on my chimney repair
Warren Masonry did a wonderful job on my chimney repair. We had a leak in our chimney and they tore it down and fixed the leak and repaired the shingles. They have great customer service, are friendly snd efficient! I highly recommend them!
- Joni Koontz | Google Review
5. McGinley’s Masonry Repair LLC
Website: https://mcginleysmasonryrepair.com/
Address: 5443 Julian Ave
Contact: +1 317-413-3815 / +1 317-721-8245
Hours: Monday–Friday: 8 AM–4 PM
McGinley’s Masonry Repair operates as a boutique service that is perfect for homeowners who need precise and technical repairs, since they are not a volume outfit chasing every new build.
Their boutique nature means you get a very personal level of service. Instead, they focus on high-quality tuckpointing and historic brick restoration.
I love that they source reclaimed brick to match 100-year-old homes in places like Irvington. It’s the kind of detail-oriented care bigger companies often skip.
They also keep their team small to protect quality, but that also means limited capacity and potentially longer lead times.
They’re not the best fit for massive commercial developments, which can be a drawback if you need a crew with the scale, staffing, and project management needed to handle big timelines, multiple trades, and complex logistics.
In that case, you’ll likely be better off with a contractor that routinely takes on large, multi-phase commercial builds.
Customer Reviews
They were great to work with
We bought a home with a brick fireplace that had been painted over. After being told it couldn’t be done, Charles and Audrey returned it to its former glory. They were great to work with and willing educate me on the process along the way. More still to do on the living room renovation but with the now exposed brick setting the tone, we’re off to a great start.
- Eric Sechrist Google Review
Great service, quote was quick and reasonable
Great service, quote was quick, reasonable, and they fit me in quickly despite Indiana weather Indiana-ing. Highly recommended!!! No more broken nails for my dog from sprinting in the back door and no more raccoons crawling under my porch 🙌 …
- Abby B Google Review
