Sandra MillerSeeing your child struggle with math is tough. Tears over algebra homework and the panic of upcoming SATs create a unique kind of second-hand stress for parents.
You want to help, but “new math” often looks nothing like what we learned in school. Finding the right support shouldn’t add to your headache.
You need a partner who can translate confusion into confidence. I’ve analyzed the local scene to find options that support visual thinkers, test-takers, and students who need a confidence boost.
Here is my guide to the best math tutors in Indianapolis to get those grades back on track.
How much does a Math Tutor cost in Indianapolis?
Pricing for academic support varies, much like the difference between a quick oil change and a full engine overhaul. In Indianapolis, expect to spend anywhere from $20 to over $80 per hour.
For a standard session with a college student or a general tutor, you might pay around $21 to $25 per hour. However, rates climb if your high schooler needs highly specialized help for AP Calculus or intense SAT prep.
Some centers operate on a monthly tuition model rather than an hourly rate. This structure can be easier for budgeting but often requires a longer commitment.
1. Tutor Doctor Indianapolis
Website: https://www.tutordoctor.com/indianapolis/
Address: 12175 Visionary Way Suite 200, Fishers
Contact: +1 317-572-7228
Schedule:
- Mon – Fri: 8 AM – 8 PM
- Sat: 10 AM – 6 PM
- Sun: 12 PM – 6 PM
Tutor Doctor takes a smarter approach to tutoring by matching students based on personality and learning style, rather than just assigning instructors at random.
Their “Tutor Match Guarantee” is a huge confidence booster because it ensures your child actually connects with the person teaching them.
They also go deeper than just helping with homework. Instructors emphasize executive functioning skills, like organizing notes and managing time, which help students succeed long-term.
I also really like that families start with a free consultation to map out a customized plan before committing a dime. You can choose between in-home or online sessions, which are super flexible.
The only thing for parents who prefer a hands-on selection to note is the process. You can’t browse a directory and pick someone yourself; Tutor Doctor handles the matching for you.
But honestly, given their track record, it’s worth trusting their process.
Customer Reviews
We’ve been very happy with our experience with Tutor Doctor!
We’ve been very happy with our experience with Tutor Doctor! James was very communicative and helpful with getting everything set up. He matched us with Miss Carolyn and my son enjoys working with her! She’s very kind and easy for him to talk to. We all work together to make the best plan for my son’s growth and advancement. I’d definitely recommend Tutor Doctor!
- Love, Jerrilyn | Google Review
If your child needs support tutor doctor is the way to go!
My son has been with tutor doctor a couple of years and just graduated from Highschool with A’s and B’s. His tutor has been amazing. Not only did she make him comfortable with the whole process, she is genuinely interested in his interests and she also exposed him to college classes. It was an amazing experience and we will definitely be reaching out if he needs support during college. If your child needs support tutor doctor is the way to go!
- Kim McMillian | Google Review
2. Kumon Math and Reading Center of Southport
Website: https://www.kumon.com/southport/
Address: 8028 S Emerson Ave SUITE R AND SUITE S
Contact: +1 317-491-1818
Schedule:
- Mon – Thu: 11 AM – 7 PM
- Fri: 9 AM – 6:30 PM
Kumon is built around a self-learning approach that develops discipline, focus, and strong academic foundations. Through Kumon Connect, the program transfers its traditional paper worksheets to a tablet, making it possible for parents and instructors to monitor student progress in real time.
The structured, step-by-step system encourages learners to master each concept thoroughly, often helping them move ahead of their current grade level.
I recently visited a Kumon center to observe the tablet-based setup firsthand. The instant feedback keeps students motivated, while independent problem-solving builds confidence and self-reliance.
However, families should consider the ongoing monthly tuition per subject, along with registration and material fees, which may become costly when enrolling multiple children.
Customer Reviews
I’m particularly impressed with the level of attention and dedication
My kids have been going to this Kumon center for the past 6 years and we love it. I’m particularly impressed with the level of attention and dedication Ms. Oza gives to my kids. She understands each child’s needs and personally ensures she helps to overcome challenges.
- Ikeoluwa Fagbemiro | Google Review
Excellent staff, facility and program
Excellent staff, facility and program here at Kumon Southport. We thoroughly enjoyed being here. Mrs. Vandana Oza is an amazing mentor and understands each kid thoroughly and helps your student in every way possible. She was very accessible for any of the questions we had. She really cares for her students progress, learning and growth. We love her and will miss her. Kudos to her and her team !!
- Shalini Subramanyam | Google Review
3. Huntington Learning Center Indianapolis
Website: https://huntingtonhelps.com/locations/indianapolis-in/
Address: 2635 E 62nd St Suite 2020
Contact: +1 317-562-0550
Schedule:
- Mon – Thu: 3:30 PM – 8:30 PM
- Sat: 9 AM – 3 PM
Huntington Learning Center is recognized for its rigorous test preparation and specialized academic support.
While it operates under a national brand, the center is locally owned by a husband-and-wife team, which helps create a welcoming, community-oriented environment.
They offer focused programs for students with ADHD, supporting learners who may struggle in traditional classroom settings.
On top of that, the center uses a data-driven approach that is especially effective for high-stakes exams like the SAT and ACT by identifying specific areas where students lose points.
Huntington also accepts Education Scholarship Accounts, making services more accessible for eligible families.
One limitation is scheduling, as the center is closed on Fridays and Sundays, which can be difficult for busy high school students.
Customer Reviews
Wonderful staff, clean facility, and the program works
Wonderful staff, clean facility, and the program works. We tried other tutoring services before, but nothing has worked liked Huntington. In less than 3 months I can see significant progression. If you are on the fence just do it, you won’t regret it.
- Shay | Google Review
The Huntington staff went out of their way to fit our wacky schedule
My son went to Huntington Learning Center for one-on-one SAT prep. The Huntington staff went out of their way to fit our wacky schedule. His got the SAT score he needed (up 100 points from the practice test), and the math tutors helped him with calculus when he was on a tough unit. While he might have been able to do the SAT review on his own, it was well worth the money to keep his studying on track, and the calculus help was invaluable.
- Phyllis Mahoney | Google Review
4. Sylvan Learning of South Indianapolis
Website: https://www.sylvanlearning.com/locations/us/in/greenwood-tutoring/south-indianapolis/
Address: 862 S State Rd 135, Suite A
Contact: +1 317-215-7568
Schedule:
- Mon – Thu: 9 AM – 8 PM
- Fri & Sat: 9 AM – 1 PM
Sylvan Learning promises progress, with research showing students can achieve up to three times greater growth in math through its proprietary Sylvan Method.
Their program is delivered by an extensive network of certified, trained teachers, ensuring your child is guided by an experienced educator rather than a part-time college student.
Each student here begins with the Sylvan Insight Assessment, which identifies learning gaps and strengths. Based on these results, Sylvan designs a customized learning plan that aligns closely with your child’s curriculum at their Greenwood school.
One limitation to consider is scheduling: weekend availability is minimal, with the center closing at 1:00 PM on Saturdays and remaining closed on Sundays.
Customer Reviews
My son’s grades has improved
My son likes too go, I feel he is safe while he is there. There is a reward system for the children by points, which helps them learn also in many different ways. His grades has improved since he first started going to Sylvan South.
- Diana Cooksey (Denise) | Google Review
My youngest test better at the beginning of the school year
My youngest had regressed in reading over a summer and had worked all year to get caught back up to her peers. We sent her to Sylvan over last summer to keep her from going backwards again over the summer. Not only did she test better at the beginning of the school year, she is now one of the best in her class. She made honor roll 1st term this year.
- Amber Anderson | Google Review
5. Mathnasium
Website: https://www.mathnasium.com/math-centers/carmel
Address: 365 W 116th St #130, Carmel
Contact: +1 317-846-6284
Schedule: Mon – Thu: 10 AM – 3 PM
Last, but definitely not least, Mathnasium is dedicated solely to mathematics, using the proprietary “Mathnasium Method” to help students truly understand concepts.
This approach blends mental, verbal, and hands-on techniques so lessons are easier to grasp and retain.
The center maintains a low-pressure atmosphere, reinforced by a reward system that encourages children to finish their worksheets.
I spoke with a parent whose daughter attends regularly, and she’s so happy her child now eagerly asks to go because she wants to earn more prizes. That positive change in motivation is significant.
Mathnasium also allows drop-in sessions, offering helpful flexibility.
However, instructional hours are limited, with no classes on Fridays and relatively narrow afternoon time slots on weekdays.
Customer Reviews
The culture at the center is warm and loving
I cannot give enough praise to the Mathnasium curriculum and the staff. My children have been going to Mathnasium for almost a year and their confidence in Math has improved immensely and their grades have followed suit. Most importantly, the culture at the center is warm and loving. My kids are always greeted with big smiles and encouragement. My son actually says that Math is his favorite subject now!
- Mary Schwartz Gorden | Google Review
My daughter had a great experience!
My daughter had a great experience! She is young for her class and every year kept falling farther and farther behind in math. I tried to help, but I realized that we needed something more. Mathnasium was just what we needed! They helped her to enjoy math. They made it . She left with a prize practically every single time. We had to stop because she’s in sports, but she wants to go back as soon as the sports season is over. I am a teacher. Anytime one of my students falls behind in math, I confidently recommend Mathnasium!
- Mende Timmerman | Google Review
