Rachel SmithGetting proper rest starts with a solid foundation, but tracking down the best mattresses in Indianapolis often feels like navigating a frustrating maze.
Between pushy salespeople and overwhelming warehouse floors, making a confident choice is tough for both budget-conscious buyers and new homeowners outfitting an entire house.
I know how terrible it is to wake up with back pain simply because of a poorly researched purchase.
That is exactly why I put together this local guide to point you toward showrooms that prioritize your comfort and sleep health without the usual retail headache.
How much do mattresses cost in Indianapolis?
Mattress sets in Indianapolis span a wide spectrum, with budget options starting under $200 and premium local models exceeding $3,500. Most buyers, though, spend between $600 and $1,200 for dependable mid-range comfort.
| Category | Price Range |
| Budget & Discount | $169.95 – $695.00 |
| Mid-Range | $600.00 – $1,200.00 |
| Retail/Warehouse | $799.00 and under |
| Local Premium | $1,099.00 – $3,599.00+ |
1. Mattress Firm Cherry Tree Crossing
Website: https://www.mattressfirm.com/
Address: 9808 East Washington Street
Contact: (317) 869-4001
Hours:
- Monday-Saturday 10:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Sunday 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Mattress Firm Cherry Tree Crossing is a top place to shop for exclusive Restore hybrid mattresses with cooling features that you won’t find in regular furniture stores.
They back their inventory with a 120-night low-price guarantee. They also promise to beat competitor rates by 10 percent, so you always secure the greatest deal.
When I visited to replace my worn-out guest bed, I was really impressed by their knowledgeable staff. They really took the time to match my support needs with the right mattress.
Taking advantage of their 120-night happiness guarantee does come with a catch, though. Exchanging a bed is not free, as it usually involves mandatory restocking and delivery fees.
Plus, you might experience occasional communication delays with their third-party delivery teams.
Great experience at this store!
Shout out to Shanlyn — she was amazing. I came in needing a mattress, and she was very attentive and clearly knew her stuff. She walked me through different payment options and helped me find an affordable mattress that worked for me. I really appreciated her help! Go see Shanlyn!!!!!
- Javon Gordon | Google Review
They did everything perfectly.
Shanlyn answered all of our questions with no pressure sales. She explained everything perfectly and she was an absolute gem to work with. Delivery was on time, quick, professional, and friendly. Jared called me and left a VM asking about my experience. It’s nice to deal with people who really care about their business relations and how they present themselves. Oh, and we like the mattresses and adjustable bases, too. Thank you for a job well done!
- Joe Batta | Google Review
2. Best Value Mattress Warehouse
Website: https://www.bestvaluemattress.com/
Address: 5727 W. 85th Street
Contact: (317) 228-2337
Hours:
- Thursday-Saturday & Monday: 11:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Sunday: 12:00 PM – 4:00 PM
Best Value Mattress Warehouse operates on a unique weekend warehouse model that keeps overhead costs incredibly low. This allows them to pass along massive factory-direct savings to consumers.
They focus heavily on stocking high-end factory seconds from premium brands like Stearns & Foster. If you’re interested in these brands, you can secure minor comfort trials for a fraction of the original price here.
If you’re overhauling your property and utilizing dumpster rental services to clear out old bedroom furniture, checking out their inventory is a smart financial move.
Because they operate as a warehouse, their standard walk-in hours are restricted strictly to Thursdays through Mondays.
On top of that, the as-is nature of factory seconds means these specific premium items might not carry the standard full manufacturer warranty you would get at a traditional retailer.
100% recommend this store
Ken Miller was the person who helped us and he was wonderful, he went above and beyond! We ended up buying 3 mattresses, 1 king and 2 queens. Ken showed us all the different qualities and kind of mattresses, explaining all the honest facts and comparing prices.
100% recommend this store, Ken gave us a really great discount and even mattresses covers for free!
- Gerardo Sánchez | Google Review
Everything was perfect
I bought mattress #4 & 5 from today from Ken. We have always found great value and wonderful mattresses at this location. What stuck out to me today was his kindness, patience, and the explanation of the mattresses we were considering. The guys that delivered them were incredibly kind and went the extra mile helping to make sure everything was perfect when they left.
- Sarah Blankenship | Google Review
3. Tempur-Pedic Flagship Store
Website: https://www.tempurpedic.com/
Address: 4110 E 82nd St D2
Contact: (317) 829-5928
Hours:
- Monday-Friday: 9:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Saturday-Sunday: 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Testing a bed on a crowded sales floor is often awkward. That’s why I really love that Tempur-Pedic Flagship Store’s showroom features semi-private bed pods with adjustable lighting for a significantly more relaxing evaluation.
Buying directly from this location guarantees you receive their official 90-night sleep trial alongside exclusive access to advanced technology like ActiveBreeze smart beds.
I also spoke with a manager who walked me through their pillow selection. It’s tailored to help customers find the right support based on individual sleeping habits, which I really appreciate.
That said, you cannot compare their proprietary beds side-by-side with competing brands in the same building.
You also need to be fully aware of the strict return policy. Sending a bed back during the trial period incurs a steep, non-refundable shipping fee.
Overall, a great shopping experience!
Ben, the Indianapolis store manager, was extremely knowledgeable and helpful during my store visit. He was able to make recommendations from a large selection of products based on my preferences and answered all of my questions with ease. Overall, a great shopping experience!
- Heidi Morris | Google Review
Purchasing process was smooth
Ben and Jordyn were very wonderful to work with, providing my friend and I with a good trying experience with mattresses and help with financing the final purchase. We got to test mattresses and pillows to find what we liked, and the purchasing process was smooth.
- Daniel Bugarin | Google Review
4. Snooze Mattress + Wellness
Website: https://indy.snoozemattresscompany.com/
Address: 3949 E 82nd St.
Contact: (317) 779-3919
Hours:
- Monday-Saturday: 10:00 AM – 7:00 PM
- Tuesday: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
- Sunday: 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Snooze Mattress + Wellness makes finding the perfect setup feel effortless. Using proprietary Dream Mapping technology, they analyze your individual pressure points in under five minutes to recommend the ideal mattress or sleep system.
Their diagnostic system even features a syncing mode that simultaneously evaluates couples to find a bed balancing both partners’ unique support requirements.
Adding a biohacked sleep system completes any master bedroom renovation perfectly, especially if you just finished installing fresh flooring and matching room decor.
The center also offers an impressive 365-night sleep trial, giving plenty of time to make sure your investment is right for you.
That said, the premium nature of their specialized diagnostic technology also means high investment.
On top of that, while walk-ins are welcome, the staff highly encourages booking an appointment in advance to undergo the full mapping consultation.
My visit to Snooze Mattress was exceptional
My visit to Snooze Mattress was exceptional. Gloria ran a dream map on me and thoughtfully answered all of my questions. After a recent surgery, it was extremely important to find the right mattress. The Holiday PJ event was so cozy, too.
- Polly Mortagh | Google Review
Great experience
Great experience with Snooze Mattress. The team was friendly and knowledgeable, and the mattress itself felt incredibly comfortable and supportive right away. High-quality product and a brand I’d definitely recommend if you’re looking to improve your sleep.
- Emily Velez | Google Review
5. Bob’s Discount Furniture and Mattress Store
Website: https://www.mybobs.com/store/indiana/greenwood
Address: 7565 US 31 S
Contact: (317) 759-2011
Hours:
- Monday-Saturday: 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Sunday: 11:00 AM – 7:00 PM
For a budget-conscious buyer, I highly recommend trying the Bob-O-Pedic line. They provide advanced pressure relief and cooling technology at a significantly lower price point than major luxury competitors.
The strict no-haggle pricing policy keeps costs consistent year-round, removing the stress of chasing seasonal sales or discounts.
Testing their inventory is also surprisingly enjoyable, especially with the on-site café offering complimentary gourmet coffee and snacks for the whole family.
However, this warehouse focuses almost exclusively on its own value-tier models, so you will not find high-end luxury names on the showroom floor.
Shoppers have also noted occasional firmness consistency issues, where the delivered unit feels slightly different than the floor model.
Super friendly and helpful!
Husband and I went in to check out what we’d like for our space and everyone was super friendly and helpful! Not pushy but was around if we had questions. We ended up just looking and purchasing online later, but picked up at the store today. Super easy pickup with help getting it on our truck. Pickup orders are packed with extreme care which was awesome to see, assembly was super easy as well.
- keivind | Google Review
Extremely helpful and kind
Went in and automatically was greeted by Greg. He was extremely helpful and kind. He gave us our space to look around but once we came to a final decision he made the check-out process run extremely smooth. We will definitely have Greg as our salesman moving forward!
- Noelia Santillano | Google Review
