Lucas BrennanLife comes at you fast, and unfortunately, so do accidents. One minute you are driving down I-465 or walking through downtown Indy, and the next, your whole world turns upside down.
Dealing with injuries is painful enough without the added stress of aggressive insurance adjusters and confusing paperwork. When it comes to personal injury cases, you need someone in your corner who knows the local laws inside and out.
We understand how overwhelming this feels, which is why we dug into the local legal scene. We wanted to find the most reliable, compassionate, and tough advocates to help you get the compensation you deserve.
How much does a Personal Injury Lawyer cost in Indianapolis?
The good news is that hiring a top-tier injury attorney in Indianapolis usually doesn’t require a big upfront payment because many firms work on a contingency fee basis, meaning they only get paid if you recover compensation through a settlement or trial.
In that case, they typically take a percentage of the final amount, often around 33% to 40%, which can help align their incentive with your outcome.
Meaning for a $100,000 settlement, attorney fees usually range from $33,000 to $40,000.
They fight harder because their paycheck depends on it. If they don’t win your case, you generally don’t owe them a penny for their time.
1. Ward & Ward Personal Injury Lawyers
Website: https://wardlawfirm.com/
Address: 728 S Meridian St
Contact: +1 317-740-1900 / +1 317-639-9501 | [email protected]
Hours: Available 24 hours
Ward & Ward stands out for the sheer depth of their institutional knowledge. With Donald Ward, the founding attorney, bringing over 70 years of experience to the table, this family-run firm offers a level of insight difficult to find elsewhere.
They understand Indiana law and how it has evolved over time, and they’re genuinely accessible. Instead of treating you like a case number, Ward & Ward gives clients their attorneys’ personal cell phone numbers.
I tested their response time to see if the 24/7 access claim held water, and being able to bypass a call center to speak with a real legal professional was incredibly reassuring. It makes a huge difference when you are panic-stricken at odd hours.
However, their traditional structure does have one drawback. They are a smaller, locally focused team, so they might lack the high-tech, automated client portals that younger, tech-savvy clients often expect from modern service providers.
Customer Reviews
We have been with Charlie for 8 years now
We have been with Charlie for 8 years now. He is kind, understanding, truthful, and gives amazing legal guidance. He is very communicative and responsive. He has provided a wide range of services for which we are grateful. He is personable and down to earth. Appreciate all you do Charlie! We couldn’t ask for a better attorney to be by our side!
- Barbara Reed | Google Review
They are the best in the business
I am not related to Charlie, but we definitely got treated like family. Working with him and his team was a great experience. They are the best in the business. He recently helped my wife and I with our estate planning. Would definitely use them again for future planning needs.
- Job Ward | Google Review
2. Hensley Legal Group, PC
Website: https://hensleylegal.com/indianapolis-personal-injury-lawyers/
Address: 117 E Washington, St #301
Contact: +1 317-526-1440 / 866-841-5355 / +1 317-707-4305
Hours: Available 24 hours
When getting to a law office isn’t possible, Hensley Legal Group meets clients where they are, at home or in the hospital. Their massive statewide footprint includes nine offices, meaning they are never too far away.
Hensley Legal Group emphasizes personal attention and follows a “no fee unless we win” approach.
But one thing I also find notable is their Hensley Cares initiative, which focuses on volunteering and supporting local charitable efforts across Indiana, also shows a commitment to giving back beyond the courtroom.
On top of that, they make it simple to get in touch through text or web chat, even outside of normal business hours. That kind of accessibility can be especially reassuring when you have time-sensitive questions or just want a quick update without playing phone tag.
The downside to this convenience is the big firm feel. Because they handle such a high volume of cases across the state, you are more likely to spend your time talking to case managers and support staff rather than the lead attorney, which can feel impersonal.
Customer Reviews
Very easy to get ahold of
Hired Hensley after my son was struck by an Uber driver while crossing the street. It was a very easy, stress free process. Very easy to get ahold of and walked me through everything. Probably the easiest process I’ve ever been involved in. As a single mom who works full time, I can’t tell you how thankful I am that I barely had to do anything. Thank you again for helping my son get what he deserves.
- Amber Elaine | Google Review
I feel more confident knowing that I am in great legal care!
I was very weary when I contact attorney Hensley legal group! I spoke with the legal Secretary, Nicki Who was very kind And patients with me. She explained everything to me, she processed my intake information. I feel more confident knowing that I am in great legal care!
- Valerie Hawkins | Google Review
3. Keller & Keller Injury Lawyers
Website: https://www.2keller.com/indiana/
Address: 2850 N Meridian St
Contact: (317) 926 1111
Hours: Available 24 hours
Keller & Keller emphasizes its Zero Fee Guarantee because it helps relieve the fear of financial ruin for victims already facing medical bills.
Operating since 1936, the firm brings an 80-year legacy that earns respect in the courtroom.
They stand out by embracing technology. Instead of relying only on paper and photos, they use drones to document accident scenes, capturing evidence that traditional methods can miss in complex crash cases
They also have a dedicated Social Security Disability department, which isn’t something most standard injury firms offer. However, their size and corporate structure present a trade-off.
With extensive TV marketing and a large roster, the experience can feel very corporate. You might find yourself working with a dedicated paralegal much more often than the partners you see in the advertisements.
Customer Reviews
Chenelle and Tim are awesome!
Chenelle and Tim are awesome!! The journey has been very long but Chenelle went above and beyond with her professionalism. She never let me get to low or to high. Her responses were neutral but encouraging. Tim held my hand for all of the hearings! Can not say enough about them.
- Robert Johns | Google Review
Choosing Keller and Keller was absolutely the right decision for me
Choosing Keller and Keller was absolutely the right decision for me. From start to finish, they handled every detail of my case, which made the process so much easier for me. I especially want to recognize Billy she went above and beyond to help me, kept me informed every step of the way, and was always responsive and supportive. I truly can’t thank her enough. She is an incredible asset to the firm!!
- Sara Neuse Google Review
4. Craig, Kelley and Faultless LLC
Website: https://www.ckflaw.com/indianapolis/
Address: 5845 Lawton Loop E Dr
Contact: +1 317-434-1719 / 888-253-5198
Hours: Available 24 hours
For injuries involving a semi-truck or a commercial vehicle, Craig, Kelley and Faultless is the heavy hitter you want.
Fun fact: one of their founding partners even wrote a book on truck accidents, rather than just dabbling in them.
David Craig authored the book “Semitruck Wreck: A Guide for Victims and Their Families” as a guide for victims, positioning the firm as a thought leader in this high-risk niche.
With a trial-first approach, they prepare every case as if it’s headed to court, pressuring insurers to offer stronger settlements to avoid a fight. They also deploy private investigators immediately to preserve black box data, which is critical in trucking cases.
Intense specialization has a downside, however. Because they focus on major commercial wrecks and dangerous litigation, a simple or minor slip-and-fall might feel too small for their high-powered scope.
Customer Reviews
I was incredibly thankful to have a team on my side
From the first meeting with the team at Craig, Kelley, and Faultless, through the entire follow-up process, I felt supported and heard. Due to some of my injury circumstances, the process took a while, but the team was very communicative all throughout. I was incredibly thankful to have a team on my side who I could trust handle all of the details with insurance and get me what I felt was the best end result.
- Tria Clancy | Google Review
Ms. LaFavour is a wonderful and caring attorney
Ms. LaFavour is a wonderful and caring attorney who worked very hard for my brother. I am writing this for him due to his disability. He is very grateful for all her help and persistence in a case that was challenging in many ways. When other attorneys didn’t want to get involved, she was willing. Today, he is able to focus on his recovery and not worry about how he will take care of his family. Thank you, Ms. LaFavour and the staff at Craig, Kelley and Faultless for your work and for all of your time and patience.
- Odalys Rojas | Google Review
5. Morgan & Morgan
Website: https://www.forthepeople.com/office-locations/indiana/indianapolis/
Address: 117 East Washington Street, Suite 201
Contact: +1 463-204-6800
Hours: Available 24 hours
Morgan & Morgan is a true legal giant, and their biggest advantage is scale backed by a nationwide footprint and a large team.
With substantial financial resources, they can fund complex investigations, bring in top experts, and keep steady pressure on insurance companies to pursue stronger outcomes.
That matters because defendants often try to drag cases out to strain a plaintiff’s finances, and Morgan & Morgan is positioned to keep fighting without being forced into a quick settlement.
On top of that, they’re able to bring in a deep bench of expert witnesses and investigators, which can strengthen the evidence and help build a more detailed case. Smaller firms often don’t have the budget to tap that level of support as consistently.
Plus, their mobile app makes signing documents and tracking your case surprisingly easy for such a large operation. It brings a level of modern convenience to a typically slow industry.
However, since they are so huge, it is very difficult to reach your specific attorney directly. You will likely be routed through a maze of case managers, and response times for non-urgent updates can be slow due to the high caseloads of individual staff members.
Customer Reviews
The gal who helped me was so terrific
I just got accepted as a client, but the gal who helped me was so terrific and like me, is an animal person, which made it so much better, and made my day. To be honest, I was skeptical about MORGAN & MORGAN, TV ADS, HUGE FIRM, but she made me relax and was so nice and helpful. This accident has all but destroyed my faith in people, but she made me laugh and smile. 1 million.points for her.🥲🥰🥰🥰🥰😀😀😀😀😀😀
- Ruth Lickey | Google Review
I got a call back right away, which was surprising
WhenI reached out to Morgan & Morgan with my concerns, I got a call back right away, which was surprising, I didn’t think they would call. The young lady that I spoke with, had taken me seriously. She answered all the questions that I was unsure of, along with showing empathy during our conversation. Thank you.
- Sylvia Manuel | Google Review
