Sandra MillerNo one wants to deal with a burst pipe or an icy cold shower, especially during an Indiana winter. Living in a Meridian-Kessler historic home or a newer Fishers build, you need a dependable plumber to keep things comfortable and stress-free.
That is why I took the time to research plumbing professionals across the Circle City who not only fix the immediate issue but also take the time to identify the root cause.
Plus, I focused on companies known for clear communication, honest pricing, and specialized expertise.
The result is a carefully selected list of plumbers you can trust to deliver reliable, long-lasting repairs and help you feel confident in your choice.
How much does hiring a plumber cost in Indianapolis?
Hiring a professional plumber in Indianapolis costs an average of $383, with most jobs ranging from $199 to $583, depending on the service and complexity.
| Service Type | Average / Typical Cost |
| Overall Average Cost | $383 |
| Typical Repair Range | $199 – $583 |
| Clogged Drain | $125 – $275 |
| Water Heater Replacement | $1,000 – $2,500+ |
| Service Call Fee | $75 – $150 |
| Hourly Labor Rate | $45 – $200 per hour |
1. Hope Plumbing, Heating & Cooling
Website: https://www.hopeplumbing.com/
Address: 1919 E 52nd St
Contacts: +1 317-807-6141 / +1 (317) 912-0222
Hours: Available 24 hours
Restoring an older home takes more than basic plumbing skills. In neighborhoods like Broad Ripple, vintage systems often come with quirks that modern technicians can easily overlook or even damage.
That is why it helps to work with a team that truly understands historic properties. From handling galvanized piping to protecting original details, the team at Hope Plumbing, Heating and Cooling offers expertise that gives homeowners true peace of mind.
Another advantage is that they handle both plumbing and HVAC, which makes renovation projects far easier to manage. Instead of coordinating multiple general contractors, you can rely on one experienced team.
That said, their specialized expertise can mean higher pricing, and they may not be the quickest choice for a minor clog during a busy season.
But for homeowners who value craftsmanship and careful restoration, they remain a strong and dependable option.
Customer Reviews
We couldn’t have been more appreciative of this company!
had chris mobley out here late in the afternoon we were without water. He got under our home in the freezing cold and replace a burst pipe and fixed the freezing pipe issue so we had water again. He was very knowledgeable. Very fast and we couldn’t have been more appreciative of this company! Thank you hope plumbing for have dependable people like him!
- Keanna Church Google Review
Did an amazing job
John Moody from Hope Plumbing did an amazing job. He understands customer service. He briefed us on what to expect and then he got it done quickly. Very impressed. Love to see great customer service these days. Price was great and so was John. I will not hesitate to reach out to Hope Plumbing again if I need help in the future.
- Phillip Gibson | Google Review
2. Benjamin Franklin Plumbing of Indianapolis
Website:https://www.benjaminfranklinplumbing.com/indianapolis/
Address: 4040 Industrial Blvd
Contacts: +1 317-406-5299 / +1 (317) 886-0567
Hours: Available 24 hours
Waiting around all day for a plumber is frustrating, especially when you have a packed schedule. For busy homeowners in Indianapolis, reliability and clear timing matter just as much as the repair itself.
That is where Benjamin Franklin Plumbing of Indianapolis really sets itself apart. Their Punctuality Promise means they will actually pay you for every minute they are late, which feels like a breath of fresh air in the service world.
On top of that, their fully stocked service trucks act like a warehouse on wheels, allowing most repairs to be completed in a single visit.
Of course, that level of convenience can come at a higher flat-rate price, and some customers feel they lean toward replacement over repair. Even so, if your time is valuable, their dependable service can be well worth it.
Customer Reviews
Fast workers and did what they came to do
had to get my water heater replaced because i was randomly out of hot water. Called at 9:30 am and had it all done and replaced by 4!! I already have hot water again and it’s still daylight!!! they did amazing. fast workers and did what they came to do and got out. Will definitely be contacting in the future if anything else happens !!!
- Mackenzie Retz | Google Review
Friendly, professional, and thorough
Kody was friendly, professional, and thorough. He came out for an annual maintenance inspection for our tankless water heater. He asked questions and then explained everything. He was knowledgeable and low pressure when I asked about replacement costs if needed. This couldn’t have been a better experience. Thank you, Kody!
- Denise | Google Review
3. Carter’s My Plumber
Website: https://www.cartersmyplumber.com/
Address: 450 E 96th St #500
Contacts: +1 317-893-2462 / [email protected]
Hours: Monday – Saturday 7 AM – 7 PM
Finding a plumber who feels like part of the community can make a stressful repair much easier. Carter’s My Plumber brings multi-generational family experience to the table, along with a level of personal care that larger chains often lack.
They truly live up to their reputation as a friendly neighborhood plumber.
When I had a stubborn leak under my kitchen sink, the technician was polite, patient, and explained the issue clearly without being condescending.
Another thing I appreciated was the upfront, flat-rate pricing, which meant no watching the clock or worrying about surprise charges.
That said, they do not typically offer round-the-clock emergency service, so a middle-of-the-night burst pipe could be a challenge. Also, as a popular family-run company, same-day appointments for non-emergencies can sometimes be limited.
Customer Reviews
I am very satisfied with the work
Great service. He did a good job finding my problem, laid out a plan with options. Straight forward and upfront. It’s weird to say I really like my plumber, but I am very satisfied with the work. They have my loyalty and my business now. Great job. Thank you.
- Bill Ruggz | Google Review
Very quick, friendly, and professional
Myles was very quick, friendly, and professional. He serviced our sink to perfect running condition. The prices were transparent ahead of time and there was even a courtesy call before arrival. I would definitely do business with again. Thank you!!
- Midfielddbgt | Google Review
4. Pristine Plumbing
Website:https://www.callpristine.com/
Address: 5950 W Raymond St
Contacts: +1 317-245-3480 / [email protected]
Hours: Available 24 hours
When you hire a plumber, you want the problem fixed without turning your home into a construction zone. Pristine Plumbing raises the bar with its Pristine Quality Standard, blending modern leak detection methods with a strong focus on keeping your home tidy.
Their team uses electronic leak detection to find hidden issues, helping you avoid unnecessary demolition and floor damage. For homeowners who appreciate precision and a clean workspace, that approach offers real peace of mind.
However, they do require a diagnostic fee for the initial assessment, and that expense remains even if you decline the repair. Plus, their schedule fills quickly during peak seasons like winter freezes, so non-urgent repairs may require some patience.
On the plus side, their financing options are helpful for larger projects.
Customer Reviews
Love this company and will continue to give them my business
Pristine was able to send someone out right away to replace a kitchen faucet that was inoperable due to lime buildup. It was a straight shot, no upselling various other things. In other words, I was heard. Love this company and will continue to give them my business.
- Mary Harley | Google Review
Scott and Carter were both absolutely exceptional
Scott and Carter were both absolutely exceptional. Very respectful. They didn’t lag on the job. They both were very hard workers If we ever have to have any plumbing or line issues in the future, we will definitely be calling Pristine plumbing I highly recommend this company above and beyond any company I’ve ever used.
- Dolly Haynes | Google Review
5. L. D. Smith Plumbing & Drains
Website: http://www.ldsmithplumbing.com/
Address: 2400 Southeastern Ave
Contacts: +1 317-927-7186
Hours:
- Monday – Friday: Available 24 hours
- Saturday: 8 AM – 4 PM
When it comes to major plumbing work, quality and compliance really matter. L. D. Smith Plumbing and Drains operates by what they call The Master Plumber Standard, focusing on high-level workmanship and doing the job correctly from start to finish.
That attention to detail is especially important for structural projects where shortcuts can lead to bigger problems later.
A neighbor of mine recently hired them for a sewer line replacement and was impressed that they used their own excavation equipment, which helped move the project along more efficiently.
Because they handle digging in-house, they keep better control over timelines and overall quality. On the other hand, their commitment to long-term solutions often means recommending permanent repairs instead of quick fixes, which can cost more upfront.
During busy seasons, detailed quotes for large renovations may also take a bit longer. For heavy-duty plumbing jobs, they are a dependable choice.
Customer Reviews
They did a meticulous job and went above and beyond
Trevor, Russell and Micah installed an external clean out for us. They also did a two-direction sewer cleaning and a camera inspection. They did a meticulous job and went above and beyond in making sure that we won’t continue to have main drain backups. Thanks guys! See you next Spring.
- Steve Bulloff | Google Review
Fixed my immediate problem quickly and at a very reasonable prize
I am very happy with Dave’s work to repair my toilet. It was a complicated issue, which he was able to repair without doing more costly work. He explained what would need to be done in the future, but was able to fix my immediate problem quickly and at a very reasonable prize.
- Jennifer Shaw | Google Review
