Sandra MillerSpace runs out faster than expected. It often happens during a move or while managing a growing home business. What starts as a temporary squeeze can quickly turn into daily frustration.
That is where the right storage solution comes in. The best self-storage options in Indianapolis act as a reliable extension of your home or workspace. You get flexibility without stretching your budget.
The difference comes down to the details: consistent security, convenient access, and pricing that still makes sense over time.
To simplify your search, I reviewed local facilities that stand out for safety, accessibility, and overall value. This way, you can clear the clutter with confidence and take back your space.
How much does it cost to rent a self-storage unit in Indianapolis?
You can expect to pay around $117 per month for a storage unit in Indianapolis, with prices varying based on size and climate control features.
| Unit Size | Average Monthly Cost |
| 5×5 Unit | $35 – $45 |
| 5×10 Unit | $58 – $77 |
| 10×10 Unit | $96 – $124 |
| 10×15 Unit | $129 – $170 |
| 10×20 Unit | ~$177 |
1. Store Space Self Storage
Website: https://www.storespace.com/
Address: 2715 Madison Ave
Contact: 317-900-4366
Hours: Wednesday & Sunday 8 AM–9 PM; Monday, Tuesday, Thursday–Saturday 9 AM–5:30 PM
If you’re looking for a facility that treats your vintage furniture with the same respect you do, Store Space Self Storage in Madison Avenue is a top contender.
Their “Storage That Cares” philosophy shows in their drive-in loading bays that protect you from Indy’s snowy winters.
I actually used their touchless rental system recently, and it was a breeze to get an access code without even stepping into an office.
They even offer an AI-powered app for gate access, which feels incredibly futuristic compared to old-school padlocks.
While they do require a monthly insurance fee if you aren’t covered elsewhere, the 10% military discount is a fantastic touch for our local veterans.
“Office Staff was So Helpful in My Time of Need”
Office staff was so helpful in my time off. Hershey was very helpful and super Knowledgeable. I had no clue about storage stuff as I have never had to rent one before. She was able to help me get the right size unit to fit my needs. Thanks Hershey!!!
Josh Ammerman | Google Review
“…Goes Above and Beyond…”
Hershey always make sure she provides great customer service to her tenants. She had upgraded me two units in the past year or two. She goes above and beyond to answer all questions and concerns.
Alicia Thomas | Google Review
2. Extra Space Storage
Website: https://www.extraspace.com/
Address: 3380 N Post Rd
Contact: (317) 708-4072
Hours: Monday–Friday 9:30 AM–6 PM; Saturday 9 AM–5:30 PM; Sunday Closed
Convenience is the name of the game here, as Extra Space Storage has locations scattered across the area, from the airport to near Butler University.
Their N Post Rd facility is a standout thanks to Bluetooth-enabled keyless entry, so no more digging for a scrap of paper with a gate code. It’s a great fit for business owners who need a professional, well-lit environment for inventory or expensive equipment.
I also love their focus on sustainability. Their use of solar power makes them feel like a more modern choice for the eco-conscious renter.
Just keep an eye on your bill after the first few months. Those introductory rates tend to climb fairly quickly once the initial phase ends.
“First Good Experience with Renting a Storage!”
First good experience with renting a storage! Jeff was great! He was very knowledgeable about the process and kinda funny too! Definitely eased my anxiety. I’m glad I chose this EXTRA SPACE for my familles needs! KEEP UP THE GREAT JOB MY BROTHER!
Jae Rule | Google Review
“The Staff Here is Amazing!”
The staff here is amazing! Bianca, Jeff and Keith have all helped me and been fantastic. They are all trained well, easy to work with and very polite. They actually seem to enjoy thier jobs and it shows. Thank you all!
Chris Rauch | Google Review
3. Infinite Self Storage – Broad Ripple
Website: http://storage-indianapolis.com/
Address: 1102 E 52nd St
Contact: (317) 466-1707
Hours: Open 24/hours
For those who live in the heart of Broad Ripple, Infinite Self Storage – Broad Ripple near the Indianapolis Art Center is a local staple.
The biggest draw is definitely the true 24/7 access. It’s perfect if you’re a night owl or just have a non-traditional work schedule.
I also appreciate that they don’t hit you with a security deposit upfront. Combine that with the help of some of the top movers in Indianapolis, and your move can go a lot smoother.
Their month-to-month flexibility is also great. It’s ideal for students who only need a spot for a few weeks between semesters.
That said, some neighbors have mentioned that getting a hold of management for cancellations can take a bit of persistence. I highly recommend planning your move-out early.
“Highly Recommend”
Working with Infinite Storage was a great experience. The setup was extremely easy, the price was very fair, and working with the team there was terrific. Very flexible solutions, which I greatly appreciate. Highly recommend!
K Hicks | Google Review
“The Manager of the Place is Amazing”
The manager of the place is amazing. Very friendly and nice customer service. It was easy to pay ! Easy access! ALWAYS CLEAN ! I HAD ZERO issues with bugs spiders etc. This place is very clean. The inside hallways are always clean as well. Im so glad i decided to rent from infinite self storage in broad ripple!
Rayana Jefferson | Google Review
4. U-Stor Self Storage Indianapolis, IN
Website: https://u-stor.com/
Address: 5055 W. 106th St.
Contact: (317) 873-9600
Hours: Monday-Friday 10 AM–6 PM (closed 1-2 PM); Saturday 9 AM–5 PM (closed 12-1 PM); Sunday Closed
Security buffs will likely gravitate toward this facility because it installs an individual alarm on every unit door. It provides a massive sense of relief, knowing that if anyone messes with your lock, a siren will wail.
I also love that they provide a 6-month price guarantee. This prevents those annoying “surprise” rate hikes that are so common in the industry.
The solid brick construction also feels much sturdier than the thin metal walls you see at most places, which is a plus when Indiana storms roll through.
Some of the buildings are a bit older, but U-Stor has an on-site manager who actually lives on the property. It adds a layer of human oversight that’s hard to beat.
“I Like the Customer Service, Very Comfortable Expereince”
I personally never had an issue from over a year ago until now . I like the customer service very comfortable experience. I feel like my things will be safe and this facility to me is the best one that you can have just off of my own experience
Natasha Battle | Google Review
“Great People to Do Business with”
Great people to do business with and after doing so I consider everyone of the people there my friend . Nice and maintained and very convenient. Definitely a place to relief the stresses of the moving process. Great job u-stor!!
Billy Nixon | Google Review
5. Public Storage
Website: https://www.publicstorage.com/self-storage-in-indianapolis
Address: 5151 W Pike Plaza Rd
Contact: (317) 643-5421
Hours: Monday-Sunday 6 AM–9 PM
Public Storage provides a convenience that’s hard to ignore.
Their Pike Plaza location offers a “contactless” experience, allowing you to complete the entire lease online in under 10 minutes.
They also have a mobile app that makes accessing the units a lot easier. It acts as a digital key for the gates and elevators, so you don’t have to fumble with physical keys while carrying boxes.
They often run aggressive “first month for $1” deals, which are great for anyone on a tight budget during a move.
Just be prepared to buy their specific cylinder locks at signup. They are mandatory and non-refundable.
Also, keep in mind that the gate hours aren’t 24/7 like some of the local competitors.
“Thank You for Going Above and Beyond for Me”
Want to thank Emmie. What a kind, helpful lady !! Why can’t more people be as sweet as she is the world would be happier. Thank you for going above and beyond for me !
KM Carter | Google Review
“Very Kind and Enthusiastic Employee”
Emille is one of the nicest employees here at the location. She always doing a nice job and always makes sure that me and my family have everything that we need. Very kind and enthusiastic employee, she goes out of her way I would recommend her to anybody!
Kadijha Hoskins | Google Review
