Andre TaylorFinding the perfect custom tee in the Circle City can feel tricky, but Indianapolis makes it easier than most. Event planners and organizers needing 500 fundraiser shirts and individuals seeking a unique gift will find stellar local options in Indianapolis.
High-speed printers near Speedway handle big runs efficiently, while Northside specialty studios focus on detail, premium materials, and creative finishes. Together, they prove local printing quality has never been better.
I visited and compared these businesses to see which ones truly deliver on quality and consistency. This list highlights the top shops with the best blend of speed, craftsmanship, service, and local flair.
How much does T-shirt printing cost in Indianapolis?
The cost of custom shirts in Indy depends heavily on how many you need and which method you choose.
For a single, one-off shirt using digital printing, you will likely pay between $20 and $30.
If you are ordering for a large group or business, bulk pricing kicks in. Standard cotton shirts for orders over 300 pieces can cost as little as $4 to $12 each.
If you want a premium, soft-feel fabric, expect to pay closer to $8 to $18 per shirt. Design complexity and the number of ink colors will also play a big role in your final quote.
1. Underground Printing
Website: https://undergroundshirts.com/pages/custom-t-shirt-printing-indianapolis-in
Address: 350 Massachusetts Ave
Contact: +1 317-939-1030 / [email protected]
Hours: Mon-Fri 9 AM – 5 PM
Underground Printing (UGP) is a great pick if you want the personalized feel of a local shop but need the reliability of a national brand.
What’s remarkable here is that their clients get the bulk-pricing of a national production facility without losing local support. At their Mass Ave storefront, you can walk in and discuss your design face-to-face, which keeps communication clear while maintaining the value of large orders.
When I visited, the staff was incredibly patient while helping me pick out the right fabric for a small batch of event tees. I noticed that they assign specific account managers to review your artwork, which prevents those “it looked better on my screen” disasters.
However, because they are a big operation, communication can sometimes feel a bit corporate during their busiest seasons. Some users have also noted that the online instant quote might change slightly once an artist actually looks at your design complexity.
Great delivery service, fast!
I use UGP every year for an order of 1300-1500 items – they are amazing. Great service, quick response, our sales rep is always on top of it. Patient and kind, even when I review proofs 19 times (Sorry!) Great delivery service, fast! Always willing to go the extra mile for service and make us feel valued as a customer.
– Jenny Empson (Jenny), Google Review
Customer service has been extraordinary
I don’t often offer to leave reviews for businesses, but I’ve ordered from Underground Printing 4 times now and each time the customer service has been extraordinary. Zach, in particular, promptly replies to all my emails, and the rest of the team turns my design into shirts on my team’s back in just a few weeks. Yes, pick them to work with.
– Matthew Messer, Google Review
2. A+ Images, Inc.
Website: http://www.aplusimages.com/
Address: 5700 W Minnesota St A5
Contact: +1 317-405-8955 / [email protected]
Hours:
- Mon-Thu 8:30 AM – 5 PM
- Fri 8:30 AM – 2:30 PM
If you’re in the education sector and need custom apparel, A+ Images should definitely be on your radar.
What really sets them apart from the competition is their massive library of ready-to-print designs made specifically for teachers and schools.
It’s the perfect spot to find niche items like 100th Day of School shirts or Teacher Appreciation gear that are surprisingly tough to track down elsewhere.
Local educators I’ve spoken with swear by them for district wholesale orders, mostly because their pricing is incredibly competitive.
Another huge perk is their printing tech. Because they were early adopters of high-end Direct-to-Garment (DTG) printing, you get full-color, photo-quality designs with absolutely no minimum order required.
Just keep one caveat in mind: since they handle so many national orders, their turnaround times can definitely stretch during the peak back-to-school rush. Plan accordingly!
The result is perfect!
AMAZING! Doug was able to help me with a last minute request on a costume, he was so kind, helpful and accommodating! The result is perfect! I’d highly recommend using them for any screenprinting needs you have!
– Molly Habby, Google Review
Great communication with the customer and product quality
I selected A+ Images, Inc. at random based on the info on their website. Doug and everyone I worked with from A+ were delightful – from the prep process through to approval and even picking up the finished goods. I highly recommend them great communication with the customer and product quality. They are now our vendor for custom embroidery!
– Kenna Wood, Google Review
3. I Custom 4 You
Website: https://icustom4yo.com/
Address: 5824 Crawfordsville Rd, Speedway
Contact: +1 317-500-8670
Hours:
- Tue-Sat 11 AM – 6 PM
- Sun 12 PM – 6 PM
For immediate custom shirts, I Custom 4 You offers the fastest service in the city. They specialize in extreme turnaround speed, with the ability to finish some custom orders in as little as one hour.
They also have a very strict no-minimum policy, which makes professional embroidery and personalization accessible for single gifts.
I stopped by their Speedway shop for a last-minute birthday gift and walked out with a perfectly embroidered hoodie in less time than it took to grab lunch nearby.
The stitching quality was flawless, with clean seams, tight embroidery, and a finish that looked truly professional up close.
The shop also has a friendly, neighborhood vibe with staff who take their time, which is something the larger, more industrial spots often can’t match.
The only downside is that they aren’t built for massive corporate orders of 5,000 shirts.
Their business hours are also specific, and being closed on Mondays can be a hurdle if you’re on a tight weekday schedule.
The turnaround was quick and the embroidery was perfect!
I am so glad I found I Custom 4 You! From my first call, I was impressed with owner, Moe, who provides excellent customer service. Moe answered all my questions and made suggestions for my design. He provided a visual example for me to approve. The very next day, he had both shirts finished and ready for pick up. The turnaround was quick and the embroidery was perfect! Thank you, Moe for making my gift special!
– Robin, Google Review
My shirts were finished early and they are beautiful
I called on Sunday requesting Family Vacation t-shirts. I only needed 7 shirts. So my order was too small for many shops. When I call here, he was extremely pleasant, friendly, and knowledgeable. My shirts were finished early and they are beautiful. I consider myself a very detailed/picky person. I had no complaints. I highly recommend.
– Adrienne Shields, Google Review
4. Perfect Apparel
Website: http://www.perfectapparel.com/
Address: 8730 Commerce Park Pl # C
Contact: +1 317-389-5553 / [email protected]
Hours: Mon-Fri 10 AM – 6 PM
Perfect Apparel is a powerhouse when it comes to high-end embroidery and licensed Greek gear.
Rather than simply applying letters, they create organization-specific items like blazers and survival accessories with incredible detail. Their quality-first guarantee is simple: if it isn’t perfect, it doesn’t leave the shop.
One thing about them, they’re a prominent minority-owned business that feels deeply connected to the local community. The owner, Willie, has scaled this from a basement business into a serious commercial operation that can handle major corporate volume.
Because they are so specialized in Greek life, the marketing can sometimes make them look like a niche boutique, but this also makes them a premier authority for Divine Nine fraternity and sorority paraphernalia.
However, they are fully equipped for any general business or athletic league needs too.
Just be aware that their prices for licensed or highly detailed items are a bit more premium than the budget-bin wholesalers.
I could not be more pleased with their professional presence
I have used Perfect Apparel for logo embroidery on corporate shirts. I could not be more pleased with their professional presence, their helpfulness, timeliness and above all – extraordinary outcomes. Logos are always perfect! Highly recommend Perfect Apparel!
– Shawn Longerich, Google Review
Price is super reasonable, final quality is superb
Super nice store, I would recommend this place for golf bag embroidery (or any embroidery work)! The owner really went above and beyond on the design for only 1 bag I had for the embroidery work. Price is super reasonable, final quality is superb, communication is very straightforward, and work is done in only 3 days. Cannot be happier with the work, highly recommend!
– S.H., Google Review
5. ICS Inks Screen Printing & Embroidery
Website: http://www.icsinks.com/
Address: 8501 Bash St #400
Contact: +1 317-981-2011
Hours: Mon-Fri 10 AM – 6 PM
If you need retail-quality shirts for a business or a large event, ICS Inks is the way to go. They perfectly blend high-volume capacity with a premium, boutique finish.
Whether you need a dozen shirts or thousands, they specialize in complex techniques like soft-hand and water-based inks. That means you get vibrant designs without that heavy, plastic feel.
Plus, they can handle all your other promotional branding products, too.
One of their best features is the professional showroom. Before dropping serious money on a bulk order, you can actually go in and feel the difference between a basic Gildan tee and a premium blend, such as a Bella+Canvas one.
Just keep in mind that they have a 12-piece minimum, so this isn’t the place to grab a single gag gift. But for large-scale, top-tier printing, they are fantastic.
I had an amazing experience with ICS Inks!
I had an amazing experience with ICS Inks! Jen and Alan were absolutely awesome—so warm, welcoming, and personable. They made hoodies for my son’s Special Olympics basketball team, and the team was over the moon! The entire process was smooth and easy, and I received my order right on time. You simply won’t find better prices or service anywhere. I highly recommend ICS Inks and will definitely be back!
– Shawnita Washington, Google Review
The customer service was so great!
Such a great company! I was in a bit of a bind and needed to order quite a few holiday gifts for my team. With very little notice they took on the challenge and knocked it out of the park. They even finished early. The customer service was so great (and thats rare these days). I will definitely be making them our go-to for our future company needs.
– Caitlynn Ray, Google Review
