Rachel SmithCraving a dining experience that encourages sharing, sipping, and lingering over incredibly flavorful dishes?
Finding the best tapas in Indianapolis can totally transform your weekend dinner plans! Instead of committing to one massive entrée, you get to sample a colorful parade of small plates loaded with bold spices and fresh ingredients.
As a massive food enthusiast always looking for a fun spot to gather with friends, I absolutely love the social vibe that comes with ordering multiple plates for the table.
So, to help you find your next spot for a flavorful night out, I’ve reviewed the best tapas spots in the city. Read on and get ready to satisfy your appetite for incredible Spanish and Latin-inspired bites!
How much do tapas cost in Indianapolis?
Tapas served in Indianapolis restaurants typically range from $30 to $50 per person for a full meal of shared small plates, with individual tapas orders ranging from $12 to $22 depending on the ingredients.
| Plate/Meal Type | Estimated Cost |
| Vegetarian & Simple Tapas | $12 – $16 |
| Meat & Seafood Tapas | $16 – $22 |
| Premium Plates | Up to $26 |
| Mid-Range Dining Total | $20 – $30 per person |
| Upscale/Lively Dining Total | $31 – $50 per person |
| Happy Hour Deals | 2 small bites for $15 |
1. Delicia
Website: https://www.deliciaindy.com/
Address: 5215 N College Ave
Contact: 317-925-0677
Hours: Tuesday – Thursday 4:00 PM – 9:00 PM, Friday – Saturday 4:00 PM – 10:00 PM, Sunday Brunch 9:30 AM – 1:30 PM, Sunday Dinner 5:00 PM – 8:30 PM
Finding a memorable restaurant in Indianapolis often leads me straight to places that take creative liberties with classic recipes.
Delicia brilliantly blends the culinary traditions of the Americas, the Caribbean, and Spain to deliver unique small plates grounded in deep cultural roots.
The lively atmosphere inside makes it a fantastic spot for social gatherers wanting to sip cocktails and pass around slow-braised barbacoa empanadas.
They even have a dedicated 21-and-over Cantina room if you want a slightly quieter, more intimate vibe while digging into their extensive gluten-free options.
My only gripe is that the menu leans heavily into Latin fusion instead of strictly traditional Spanish fare, which might deter culinary purists looking for classic tapas.
Still, the incredible flavors easily make up for the lack of strict authenticity. When I stopped by last month for their Sunday brunch, the savory spices still completely blew me away!
Customer Reviews:
I went to celebrate my birthday and the food was excellent, the presentation of the dishes was superb, the drinks were delicious too, and the bartender’s service was incredible. I’d been to this place before and I’ll definitely be back. 100% recommended.
Jair | Google Review
Love this place!! The food is always amazing and the service is great! The cocktail menu can’t be beat! I ordered my usual empanadas and was not disappointed!! They only knock on the spices. The parking lot is rather small. Otherwise, no notes!
Elizabeth Scott | Google Review
2. Livery
Website: https://www.livery-restaurant.com/
Address: 720 N College Ave
Contact: 317-383-0330
Hours: Monday – Thursday 4:00 PM–10:00 PM, Friday – Saturday 4:00 PM–11:00 PM, Sunday 4:00 PM–9:00 PM
Dining inside a beautifully restored 1890s horse stable instantly sets a rustic-chic mood for the entire evening, and Livery capitalizes on this unique aesthetic.
Elevating the mood further is their delivery of vibrant Latin American flavors through expertly crafted, high-end shared plates.
You’ll definitely want to try their famous mushroom and truffle empanadas, especially while sitting on their popular rooftop seating area under the open night sky.
The bartenders also pour a robust selection of tequilas and mezcals that pair wonderfully with their bold, spicy dishes.
I’ve noticed, however, that some of their offerings can be overly rich or a bit busy in their presentation. If you order too many heavy items, it might occasionally overwhelm the palate.
To keep things balanced, I highly recommend consulting a nutritionist in Indianapolis if you plan on indulging in their decadent shrimp ceviche every weekend!
Otherwise, sharing a few of these intensely flavorful plates with coworkers makes for an unforgettable night out.
Customer Reviews:
We had a wonderful dining experience on the upstairs open air seating area. Our server was very knowledgeable about the menu and drink options. We decided to order from the various appetizer dishes and do a “tapas” style meal with drinks. Food was delicious and service and ambiance were excellent. Staff was very friendly and well accommodating. My only recommendation, outdoor seating could have more lighting at each table after sunset. Highly recommend!
James Aguilar | Google Review
We ordered albondigas, pan y tomate, ceviche, and pork belly tacos. The food is tapas style, but the portion sizes are larger than I expected.
The albondigas and pan y tomate were amazing. The pork belly was way too dry though. I would definitely come back again!
N | Google Review
3. Almost Famous
Website: https://almostfamousindy.com/
Address: 721 Massachusetts Ave
Contact: 317-986-7877
Hours: Tuesday 8:00 AM – 4:00 PM, Wednesday – Thursday 8:00 AM – 1:00 AM, Friday – Saturday 8:00 AM – 2:00 AM, Sunday 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Those looking for dinner and a show will absolutely fall in love with Almost Famous.
This hotspot along Massachusetts Avenue seamlessly combines a quality small-plate culinary experience with a lively entertainment venue that regularly features live music and performance art.
It even functions brilliantly as a daytime coffee shop before transitioning into a bustling evening lounge. In the latter setup, their authentic Spanish-style flavors like rich jamón and perfectly cooked tortilla de patatas are worth trying.
You can easily spend hours here sipping on their unique seasonal drinks or their incredibly popular espresso martinis. Just be aware that the atmosphere becomes quite loud and crowded during live performances.
If you embrace the energetic environment, the sheer sensory overload of fantastic food and vibrant music is completely thrilling. Sharing cheese boards while a local band plays in the background creates a truly electric weekend vibe!
Customer Reviews:
Celebrated my birthday at Almost Famous with my girlfriends and I must say the ambience is so chic and the overall experience was amazing! I tried the biscuits with gravy and let’s just say the portion and taste both had me so happy! There was a smoky touch which made the biscuits so good! Service was prompt and so good, I had a great time!
Highly recommend trying out the brunch in the day or cocktails at night! Such a nice place!
Fatima | Google Review
One of our favorite places in Indianapolis!
I absolutely love Spanish food. My grandfather was Spanish, and ever since I can remember, the flavors of jamón, cheese, and tortilla de patatas have been part of my life. It makes us so happy to have found a place in Indianapolis where we can enjoy authentic Spanish style tapas and everything is truly delicious! We also love their coffee and drinks; they’re always amazing.
Gaby | Google Review
4. Matador
Website: https://www.matadoronmain.com/
Address: 10 E Main St, Carmel
Contact: 317-669-6580
Hours: Monday – Thursday 4:00 PM – 9:00 PM, Friday – Saturday 4:00 PM – 10:00 PM, Sunday 4:00 PM – 8:30 PM
Escaping the usual downtown bustle brings you to a beautifully curated culinary gem in Carmel.
Matador delivers authentic Spanish traditions and absolutely delicious shareable bites inside a vibrant, elegantly designed corner restaurant.
Their menu shines with classic dishes, allowing you to feast on crispy patatas bravas and savor large pans of saffron-scented paella with your favorite people.
You’ll also find a fantastic outdoor seating area for al fresco dining alongside a dedicated private room for hosting special celebrations here.
I’m just iffy about the main dining room layout, which feels somewhat tucked away and disconnected compared to the highly prominent, bustling bar area.
Despite the slightly awkward floor plan, the food remains the absolute star of the show. I shared a massive pitcher of their house-made sangria here during a friend’s birthday, and the entire night felt like a quick getaway to Madrid!
Customer Reviews:
A wonderful place! We’re particularly happy to have found it because every time we searched for Spanish food online, it suggested Mexican food. But apparently there trick was to search ‘tapas’. And what tapas it was! The anchovies and calamari were flawless, as were the patatas bravas and brussels sprouts. The flan desert was also entirely authentic, though a wee bit on the sweet side. Also, surprisingly big portions, and excellent value. Recommended.
Subodhana Wijeyeratne | Google Review
This is one of our top 3 favorite restaurants in the Indy area! The tapas were absolutely incredible. We enjoyed the brussel sprouts, chicken skewers, patatas bravas, and mac & cheese. When we go back, we’d have a hard time not getting all of these again, but want to try several other things too! The almond cake was also delicious, and our waiter was very kind. The atmosphere made us feel like we were on vacation somewhere nice! Perfect date night spot.
Sara Clyde | Google Review
5. Don Quijote
Website: https://donquijotevalpo.com/
Address: 119 E Lincolnway, Valparaiso
Contact: 219-462-7976
Hours: Monday – Thursday 11:00 AM – 2:00 PM and 5:00 PM – 9:00 PM, Friday 11:00 AM – 2:00 PM and 5:00 PM – 10:00 PM, Saturday 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
True culinary explorers willingly travel great distances to uncover meals prepared with genuine historical reverence.
Don Quijote holds the impressive distinction of being the original, authentic Spanish restaurant in the state, offering traditional dishes crafted by a Madrid-born chef.
Sinking your teeth into their imported Jamón Ibérico or perfectly tender Galician-style octopus instantly transports your taste buds straight to Europe!
I definitely love their legendary outdoor dining patio that introduced al fresco dining to the area. It’s such a romantic space!
The biggest drawback is obviously the location, as driving out to Valparaiso requires a significant commute for central metro residents. If you don’t mind the journey, the authentic flavors and extensive selection of renowned Rioja wines make it worthwhile.
Additionally, reserving their unique Chef’s Table and Cellar Tour experience creates a highly immersive evening that you’ll remember for years.
Customer Reviews:
Don Quijote in Valparaiso is a fantastic spot for authentic Spanish cuisine. The food is flavorful and well-prepared, especially the paella and tapas like croquetas and patatas bravas. Great wine and sangria selection, friendly service, and a warm atmosphere. Highly recommended for a memorable dining experience.
Mile Dom | Google Review
We meet a couple monthly for dinner and tonight was the night. We alternate who chooses. This month it was our turn. Even though we’ve never been we chose Don Quijote. I had read several reviews saying the place was great and the food was awesome. It was. We went over the top too. Cafe Capuccino to start, Jamon Serrano appetizer, tapas combo platter dinner, the red fish special, flan for dessert with coffee. The other couple was equally pleased and will be back, as well as us.
T Williams | Google Review
