Andre TaylorFinding yourself on the wrong side of the law is terrifying, plain and simple. It feels like the walls are closing in, but here is the truth: a criminal charge demands a shield, not just a lawyer.
Living in Indy has taught me that who you have in your corner matters immensely. You need someone who sees you as a person, not just a case number.
I examined the local legal scene to uncover the firms that truly fight for their clients. If you need help right now, here is a breakdown of the top criminal defense attorneys Indianapolis has to offer.
How much does criminal defense cost in Indianapolis?
Freedom is priceless, but protecting it requires a financial investment. Public defenders remain an option for those with limited funds, though high caseloads often stretch their resources. Private counsel in Indy spans a wide range of costs. A simple misdemeanor might set you back a flat fee of around $1,500 to $3,500.However, serious felony charges involve a steeper climb. Retainers often start at $5,000 and can easily soar past $15,000 depending on the complexity. Most attorneys charge hourly rates between $100 and $400, but many now prefer flat fees so you know exactly what the “battle” costs upfront.
Hayes Law Office
Website: https://www.thehayeslawoffice.com/
Address: 101 W Ohio St, Suite 2024, Indianapolis
Contact: +1 317-759-1515
Hours: Mon – Fri: Available 24 Hours, Sat: 10:00 AM – 2:00 PM
Clients seeking a lawyer who enters the courtroom ready for a fight will find a strong contender in Hayes Law Office.
Their “Battle-Ready” philosophy stands out because they prepare every case for trial from day one, an assertive approach that often leads to stronger outcomes as prosecutors realize they cannot simply pressure clients into accepting a plea.
When I tested their 24/7 availability by calling late on a Tuesday, a real person answered immediately with no automated menus, which inspired my confidence in their responsiveness.
Philip Hayes personally reviews the evidence to pinpoint weaknesses in the state’s case rather than delegating critical work to junior staff.
This creates a high-energy, protection-focused strategy that serves clients well in high-stakes situations, although it may not suit clients needing emotional considerations.
Customer Reviews
Hayes Law Office provided outstanding representation in my Marion County, IN case. Attorney Hayes and Ms. Coleman were professional, knowledgeable, and dedicated throughout the entire process. They communicated clearly, treated me with respect, and worked hard to achieve the best possible outcome for my case. I highly recommend them for anyone in need!
- Jalen Little | Google Review
I had an excellent experience with Ms. Coleman. She was highly professional, attentive, and extremely helpful in answering all of my questions. I truly appreciate her guidance and support. I would highly recommend Hayes Law Office to anyone seeking a knowledgeable and dedicated criminal defense attorney.
- RJ Cook | Google Review
Cardella Law Office
Website: https://cardellalawoffice.com/
Address: 350 Massachusetts Ave #357, Indianapolis
Contact: +1 317-695-7700
Hours: Available 24 Hours
If you’re facing a criminal charge in the Indianapolis area, Jeff Cardella offers a meaningful advantage: he previously worked for the Hendricks County Prosecutor’s Office.
This insider experience gives him a clear understanding of how the state builds its cases and where mistakes commonly occur.
He uses that knowledge to identify weaknesses in the prosecution’s arguments and leverage them for his clients’ benefit.
Another major strength is the direct access he provides. During a stressful legal situation, you don’t want to navigate layers of staff just to speak with your attorney.
Jeff treats clients as individuals rather than case numbers, which sets him apart from high-volume firms.
His work on constitutional challenges, including contributing to a Supreme Court amicus brief, also demonstrates legal skill beyond routine defense work.
If you need a sharp, strategic defense attorney in Indy, Jeff is worth consulting. Just note that office meetings require a scheduled appointment.
Customer Reviews
Jeff Cardella is one of the best criminal defense attorneys in Indianapolis! Someone close to me was accused of felony drug charges, and there was a period of time where it really looked like they might be going to prison but Jeff Cardella was able to get the case dismissed without even doing a trial. Thank you, Jeff!
- Kristen Kaps | Google Review
I have worked with Jeff for many years. He has worked effectively and responsibly to resolve the issues that have arisen for me. I am looking forward to completion of the expungement process and I wouldnt choose anyone else to handle the matter. He is an invaluable resource for life.
- Kyle Keith | Google Review
Law Office of Corey L. Scott LLC
Website: https://www.coreyscottlaw.com/
Address: 1099 N Meridian St Suite 150, Indianapolis
Contact: +1 317-218-9772
Hours: Available 24 Hours
Dealing with criminal charges in Indianapolis is stressful, but Corey Scott can understand what you are going through.
His firm sees “people problems,” not just legal issues, which can feel like a huge relief when you are in trouble.
He brings big-firm experience, including clerking for an Indiana Supreme Court Justice, yet still offers the personal attention of a small practice.
Working with him feels more like a partnership focused on getting your life back on track. His “Fresh Start” approach is especially helpful for anyone who needs a reset, whether you are facing a criminal charge or bankruptcy.
Corey is straightforward and honest, but while his directness is often exactly what you need in a legal battle, his geographic focus is limited to the Greater Indy area.
Customer Reviews
Corey is a rare one! He speaks to you with respect and integrity. He listens and understands your needs and wants. You may not like what he says, but thats because hes fully honest and doesn’t sugar coat anything. Corey is one of the best attorneys Ive had the pleasure of dealing with. I 10/10 recommend for any legal needs!
- Kay Turner | Google Review
Attorney Corey L. Scott was amazing. He returned my phone call after work hours and gave me the best advice, and I live in a different state! I can’t thank him enough!.
- Camrin Wooten | Google Review
Marc Lopez Law Firm
Website: https://marclopezlaw.com/
Address: 120 E Market St Suite 710, Indianapolis
Contact: +1 317-632-3642
Hours: Mon – Fri: 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM (office hours); Available 24/7
If you are dealing with a legal headache in Indianapolis, the Marc Lopez Law Firm is quite renowned for its “Prove It” rule, a mindset that pushes the state to meet its burden every single time.
They prepare every case, whether it is a DUI or an injury claim, as if it is headed straight to trial.
This level of preparation means they leave no stone unturned and make sure you fully understand the strengths and weaknesses of the evidence.
They also put real effort into client education, offering helpful resources on their website so you are never in the dark about your situation.
Plus, their bilingual support through Abogado Benitez makes the firm especially welcoming to Spanish-speaking clients.
Just keep in mind that their business hours operate Monday through Friday, so plan your communications accordingly. However, they are available anytime of the day for any legal emergencies.
Customer Reviews
About two years ago I was pretty down on my luck and in a bad place. My attorney Ben Shoptaw and paralegal Cassie helped me get through a tough time without judgement. They got me a fair deal leading to my life doing a 180. I am beyond grateful to be given a second chance at my dream life because I had a fantastic team on my side. Highly recommend. Everyone is so empathetic and hard working, it really makes a difference. 💕
- Reid Schuetz | Google Review
The Marc Lopez Law Firm is the most amazing law firm in the entire world. Thanks to the greatest lawyer ever, Zach Richey, my mother’s case got dismissed. I am so grateful to The Marc Lopez Law Firm and Zach Richey. I am currently eating cookies while sitting with my mother and that would not be possible without Zach Richey.
- Theodore Luke (Theo) | Google Review
Banks & Brower
Website: https://banksbrower.com/
Address: 8770 Purdue Rd, Indianapolis
Contact: +1 317-623-4321
Hours: Available 24 Hours
Banks & Brower offers a serious advantage if you need defense. Founders Brad Banks and Adam Brower are former prosecutors, which means they have key “intel from the other side.”
They know exactly how the State builds a case because they used to do it, letting them dismantle charges quickly.
This firm is a powerhouse with over 80 years of collective experience among its attorneys, giving you a tactical edge in cases such as DUI and other major felonies.
They also make sure their attorneys are available 24/7 for you.
Just keep in mind that they are a “Generalist” firm handling practices such as family law and Personal Injury, too, so their focus isn’t only on criminal defense. This is something you might have to consider if you want a law firm with a specialized focus on criminal litigation.
Customer Reviews
Adam was easy to work with, professional and always available. He answered all my questions thoroughly and talked through the best approach. Most important, he achieved the outcome desired which was our best goal. Definitely would recommend him to friends and family.
- Eric Schoolcraft | Google Review
I would recommend this company to bring you needs to. They were very prompt and responsive to any concerns or questions. The cost also was extremely fair. The best part is I didn’t even have to move from my house, i live in Washington State and did I completely online. They even helped out with a bit of aftercare for me to make sure things were right. I would use this firm again if needed.
- John Johnson | Google Review
