Andre Taylor
Identifying the best digital marketing agencies in Indianapolis means partnering with a team that truly understands the local market. You can boost your e-commerce sales or draw customers to your Broad Ripple storefront with the right local expertise.
Dozens of agencies appear every month, but separating true experts from those who outsource can be a headache.
To save you the trouble, I investigated the local scene to find the agencies driving results for Indianapolis businesses right now.
This guide highlights the top partners ready to elevate your brand, ensuring you find a collaborator who can navigate the nuances of the Circle City rather than applying a generic strategy from halfway across the country.
How much does digital marketing cost in Indianapolis?
Costs vary significantly based on your specific goals. Small local shops often spend around $1,000 to $5,000 monthly for essential services. In contrast, e-commerce brands targeting national audiences might see comprehensive campaigns run from $10,000 to $50,000 or more. Agencies typically charge a monthly retainer or take a percentage of your ad spend. Specialized help usually costs $25 to $150 per hour. In the end, your total cost depends on how much work you need, whether it’s a small fix or a complete strategy overhaul.
Local Blitz
Website: https://localblitz.com/indianapolis-seo-company/
Address: 6055 N College Ave Suite #201B, Indianapolis
Contact: +1 317-672-1156
Hours: Mon – Fri: 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Local Blitz fills the gap between a big national agency and a hands-on local partner.
With teams in both Indianapolis and San Diego, they offer a mix of West Coast tech know-how and Midwestern market understanding.
They don’t use generic packages. Instead, they build campaigns around your specific KPIs.
Transparency is a core part of how they work. They know many people have had bad experiences with SEO agencies, so they focus heavily on measurable, trackable results.
I spoke with a business owner who used them for a local campaign, and she said their ability to explain complicated SEO terms in plain English made a huge difference.
One thing to note: timelines aren’t fixed. They’re upfront that competitive industries take longer, which can be frustrating if you’re looking for fast results.
Customer Reviews:
Nick and his team do a tremendous job keeping our marketing efforts up to date and working toward attracting potential clients to our site. It very genuinely seems that he is as excited as we are to see positive results.
- Patrick Gaul | Google Review
We have been working with Local Blitz for just over a year now, and needless to say we are absolutely pleased with their services. Nick and his team go above and beyond and we are happy with choosing them for our marketing purposes. Would definitely recommend!
- Wastewater Supply | Google Review
Sixth City Marketing
Website: https://www.sixthcitymarketing.com/indianapolis-seo-services/
Address: 429 N Pennsylvania St, Suite 300H, Indianapolis
Contact: +1 317-676-6045
Hours: Mon – Fri: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Sixth City Marketing has a family-owned vibe but runs with enterprise-level discipline.
They never outsource, so everyone working on your account is part of their in-house team, giving you reliable quality and clear accountability.
Notably, they are very focused on your ROI. Before a campaign starts, they set measurable goals such as call volume and sales, so you know exactly what to expect.
You might begin with a focused SEO audit and later move into a full website redesign on whatever CMS you prefer.
One drawback is that if you like on-call support or emergency weekend meetings, their schedule may feel limiting. They work strictly during normal business hours with no weekend availability.
Customer Reviews:
Sixth City Marketing is amazing! They are so easy to talk to and truly have your best interest at their forefront. I have had the opportunity to know John well and he is SO creative and was passionately invested in the marketing. I highly recommend this business to help yours prosper!
- Regan Berg | Google Review
It has been a joy to work with the team at Sixth City Marketing. Everyone is always communicative, helpful, and insightful. I can count on a prompt response from Hannah, Maureen, Kelsey, Brian, and anyone else I reach out to. It is comforting to know that they are always on top of our data and ready to take swift action whenever needed. I would highly recommend their services to anyone who needs web design and general digital marketing support.
- Celeste Caraker | Google Review
Circulus Digital Media
Website: https://circulusdigitalmedia.com/
Address: 1950 N Meridian St, Indianapolis
Contact: +1 317-956-8591
Hours: Mon – Fri: 8:30 AM – 5:30 PM
Circulus Digital Media gives local businesses access to big-data tools that are usually only available to large companies.
With an exclusive local digital network in Indiana, they work with more than 90 data providers to make advanced media buying possible for small and mid-sized businesses.
This setup lets you run highly targeted ads on streaming TV or mobile apps. Their omnichannel approach keeps your brand visible across every screen your customers use.
Interestingly enough, working with them feels more like tapping into a large media system than hiring a single freelancer. Their ad monitoring tools are built to reduce waste and improve efficiency.
One thing to note is their strong local identity. Their branding highlights being “Indiana’s local leader,” which builds trust in the community but may feel too regional if your business is aiming for international reach.
Customer Reviews:
Circulus Digital has been a great partner to us for more than 7 years. We keep coming back for their expertise and ability to take what we can accomplish in-house and stretch it further. The sales management team is knowledgable, always staying current. As a team, they are talented, responsive and accountable.
- Claire Belby | Google Review
I work with the team at Circulus Digital Media on behalf of my clients, providing the content pieces needed for my clients’ digital marketing strategy. The team is professional and extremely responsive each month combining strategy and creative. Whenever I have a client wanting to add digital marketing, I recommend Circulus because of their knowledge, expertise and commitment to their client’s success.
- Angela Mattingly | Google Review
sMaac Digital
Website: https://smaacdigital.com/
Address: 2625 N Meridian St, Suite 46, Indianapolis
Contact: +1 317-260-8767
Hours: Mon – Fri: 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
sMaac Digital brings a refreshing, no-nonsense attitude to the corporate world with a core philosophy of simply getting things done.
They focus on updating digital experiences for traditional blue-collar industries like roofing and lawn care, which often get overlooked by high-tech agencies.
They are very direct and promise no hidden fees, which shows respect for your budget.
I haven’t hired them myself, but I have seen their work for a local home service company. The improvement in the company’s web presence was noticeable, modern, and strongly focused on lead generation.
They also assign a dedicated account manager so you never feel like just another support ticket.
Their bold “get things done” tone can be motivating, but if you prefer a very formal, polished corporate partner, their informal style might feel too casual.
Customer Reviews:
AMAZING WORK. Chad Sims and his team put together an amazing site and were able to increase my traffic dramatically within 2 months. They make the process very easy and I wish I would have used them sooner. If you are looking to build a business and attract customers or employees, I would highly recommend a call with Chad Sims and sMaac Digital.
- Casey Thompson | Google Review
Love these guys! They took the time to get to know our business inside and out in order to build the best possible product for our business to serve our customers! We truly appreciate the dedication from the team
- Leslie Snider | Google Review
Indy Digital Marketing Solutions
Website: https://www.indydigitalmarketingsolutions.com/
Address: Indianapolis and nearby areas
Contact: +1 317-752-2103
Hours: Mon – Fri: 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Indy Digital Marketing Solutions is a good fit for business owners who want a personal consultant instead of a large, impersonal agency.
They take a hands-on, strategic approach backed by more than 35 years of combined experience.
One thing that sets them apart is their pre-campaign analysis. They review your online presence before you spend anything to make sure the strategy is right for you.
They also market themselves as affordable, which is great for startups, and their Google Partner status adds credibility for PPC work.
I also like that they offer a wide range of services, from reputation management to live chat integration.
The only drawback is that they don’t publish their pricing online. You’ll need to contact them directly to get details, which adds an extra step to your research.
Customer Reviews:
Indy Digital built our neighborhood association website in early 2022 and we have had great response from our neighbors. Quality work and follow up with Mark is what makes working with Indy Digital a wonderful experience. We would recommend them for any digital work, including advertising, web design, search engines, etc…. Thanks Mark!
- CENA Board | Google Review
Indy Digital Marketing Solutions is great! Mark got our website up and rolling for our new business 3 years ago. He is very responsive and easy to work with and with very affordable rates. I would highly recommend this company to anyone.
- Sarah Frey | Google Review
