Sandra MillerChoosing a psychotherapist in Indianapolis can feel overwhelming, especially when you’re already coping with anxiety, depression, or relationship challenges.
Therapy is a deeply personal experience, so finding a professional who truly fits your needs is vital. The right support helps you process past trauma or navigate relationship hurdles, helping you build your overall emotional well-being.
To make that process easier, we’ve done the research for you and curated a list of highly regarded services in the Indy area, highlighting practices that offer specialized care and clear, supportive paths forward.
How much does psychotherapy cost in Indianapolis?
When you’re looking into therapy, the cost is often a major question. In Indianapolis, if you’re paying for sessions without using insurance, commonly referred to as self-pay, you can generally expect to pay between $100 and $200 per session. For many private practices, rates often fall between $120 and $150, and in some cases, they may be higher. The final amount you pay depends on a few things: the therapist’s specialized training and credentials, where their office is located, and whether they accept your specific health insurance plan. For example, some specialized trauma treatments might be on the higher end, while a therapist-in-training might offer a reduced rate.
1. Indy Therapy and Counseling
Website: https://www.indytc.com/
Address: 7550 S Meridian St Suite A, Indianapolis
Contact: +1 317-992-1919
Schedule: Mon – Sun: 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Indy Therapy and Counseling is unique because they offer a way to fast-track your healing.
Instead of going to weekly appointments for months, you can do a ‘deep dive’ over just one or two days through EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing) intensives.
EMDR is widely recognized for its effectiveness in processing difficult memories, and the intensive format is especially appealing for busy individuals seeking a clear breakthrough.
This option is also ideal for people who are ready to address trauma head-on and want meaningful progress in a shorter timeframe.
Beyond trauma work, the practice supports individuals, couples, and families, offering services such as grief counseling, premarital therapy, and substance abuse treatment.
With two convenient office locations, one in South Indianapolis near Greenwood and another in the northern area near Fishers, the practice is accessible across much of the metro area.
Do note that their phone support is limited to weekday hours, and you’d have to wait for business hours.
Customer Reviews
My counselor is wonderful. Ms. Brandi is an excellent listener. She is kind and compassionate. She doesn’t judge you and you can just talk to her. She offers practical advice that is actionable. She has helped me through grief, depression and bouts of anxiety. I am grateful I found her and this company. I’d give more stars if I could.
- Toine Cloud | Google Review
Kat has been an amazing resource for me as I process my PTSD through therapy. She is especially adept with EMDR, which has changed my life and allowed me to tackle my anxiety and depression independently. The location is easy to find, and I love how easy it is to book time with her. I cannot recommend Indy Therapy and Counseling enough – plus, Kat is the BEST!
- Michelle Molnar | Google Review
2. Brave Life Therapy, LLC
Website: https://www.thebravelifetherapy.com/
Address: 9135 N Meridian St SUITE C5, Indianapolis
Contact: +1 317-533-0329
Schedule: Mon – Fri: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Brave Life Therapy centers on a holistic, multidisciplinary approach that blends emotionally focused therapy, EMDR, and play therapy for children.
This broad mix of methods allows care to be tailored to each individual, rather than forcing clients into a single therapeutic model.
Their practice is also clearly inclusive and affirming, creating a welcoming environment for people of all body sizes, genders, sexualities, and racial backgrounds.
To reduce the stress of choosing a therapist, Brave Life Therapy offers a free 15-minute phone consultation, giving clients a low-pressure way to see if the fit feels right.
Note that you’ll have to pay out of pocket since they aren’t linked to insurance plans. However, you have the option keep costs down by letting you book discounted sessions with their counseling interns.
Medication management is also available through a partner, making this a strong option for individuals, families, and children who can benefit more with easier-to-access medicines.
Customer Reviews
I have known Jennifer, owner of The Brave Life Therapy, for about ten years professionally and personally. She truly is a No B.S. therapist (and person!) and works unbelievably hard for her clients, staff, and practice. I have not hesitated to refer clients to her, especially with her professional expertise. Knowing her, this high quality therapy easily carries over to her expectations for staff as well. If you are on the fence, definitely reach out!
- Lindsay Gayle | Google Review
The Brave Life Therapy staff is so wonderful! They truly care about creating a safe and welcoming environment for their clients and strive to produce the best outcomes. Would highly recommend to anyone looking for therapy!
- Angela Elder | Google Review
3. LifeStance Therapists & Psychiatrists Indianapolis
Website: https://lifestance.com/location/indianapolis-in-8470-allison-pointe-blvd/
Address: 8470 Allison Pointe Blvd #130, Indianapolis
Contact: +1 463-403-1476
Schedule: Mon – Fri: 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
The best part about LifeStance is that they handle everything in-house. Because their therapists and doctors work together, it’s much easier to coordinate your care.
It’s a great choice if you think you might need medication along with talk therapy, as it simplifies coordination and keeps your care aligned between providers.
They also stand out for their broad insurance acceptance, covering major plans like Medicare, Aetna, and Anthem BCBS. This accessibility makes therapy much less of a financial barrier for many in Indy.
It’s great that they serve all age ranges and also offer flexible in-person or virtual appointments.
They also provide a massive list of services, including specialty treatments and in-depth assessments like Neuropsychological Testing, which is not always available in other clinics.
Something worth considering before deciding on them is their limited operating hours. They are only open 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM on weekdays and are completely closed on the weekends.
So, if you’re looking for evening or Saturday appointments, this might not be the right fit for your schedule.
Customer Reviews
Nurse Practitioner Amy Horn is amazing! She was lovely to speak with and really made me feel like I wasn’t alone in everything I had going on. She is very personable and funny, and I found her extremely knowledgeable and easy to talk to. I have put off being seen for too long, and I am so glad to have been referred here.
- Valerie Fox | Google Review
I have really enjoyed speaking with Ashley. While it was just the first time, she was very attentive and responsive, and I felt very comfortable. Sometimes you just have to “let things out”. I have looked some appointments for the future..
- Sheri Carte | Google Review
4. Brooke-Randolph, LMHC
Website: https://brooke-randolph.com/
Address: 447 E 38th St, Indianapolis
Contact: +1 317-455-5642
Schedule: Mon – Fri: 9:00 AM – 3:00 PM
Brooke-Randolph, LMHC, stands out because Brooke, the founder, brings a high level of expertise to the table. On top of being a therapist, she is a published author and a consultant who trains others in Brainspotting.
Her practice is highly specialized, offering in-depth specialization in the adoption constellation (adoptees, adoptive parents, birth parents, etc.), alongside developmental trauma and relationships.
This niche focus is perfect if you or your family are navigating the complex dynamics of adoption. She genuinely integrates her professional knowledge with personal experience, which is a powerful combination for building trust.
I especially appreciate the wealth of pre-recorded webinars and training she offers, making her educational resources widely available to both therapists and the public. The workbooks she has authored for children are also fantastic tools.
She also actively engages as a keynote speaker, but her training schedule for speaking engagements is booked out years in advance for 2026 and 2027. This is something you may have to consider if you want to book her for a group soon, but it also reflects the high demand for her specialized expertise.
Customer Reviews
My fiance and I chose Brooke as our premarital counselor and we are so happy that we did. Brooke does a great job of helping couples navigate through tough subjects and had great ways to help us see each issue through the other person’s point of view. We have a much stronger and more understanding relationship because of our sessions with Brooke!
- Ashley Etzkorn | Google Review
Brooke is an exceptional therapist who is extremely knowledgeable about adoption issues, attachment, addictions, and trauma. She has a heart of gold, and I would recommend her to anyone who is seeking a warm, nurturing, and highly attuned therapist.
- Mariya Javed-Payne | Google Review
5. Thriveworks Counseling & Child Therapy Indianapolis
Website: https://thriveworks.com/indianapolis-therapy/
Address: 429 N Pennsylvania St Suite 111, Indianapolis
Contact: +1 463-218-6599
Schedule: Mon – Sun: 8:00 AM – 9:30 PM
If you have a hard time taking off work for appointments, Thriveworks is a great choice. They are open late and on weekends, and they focus on availability, meaning you likely won’t be stuck on a waiting list for weeks.
This is incredibly helpful if you have a demanding work schedule and can’t take time off during the typical 9-to-5 workday.
Their office also includes a specialized child therapy environment, a designated TherapyLand™ location, which is a fun and empowering space designed specifically for kids using play therapy tools like sandboxes and blocks.
They are another excellent choice for accessibility because they boast extensive insurance acceptance, working with most major plans, which could mean a co-pay as low as $0–$50 per session for many clients.
The fact that they have no recurring membership fees is a nice bonus.
However, while the service is generally focused on quick access, the real-time availability for immediate in-person appointments with a specific provider can sometimes be limited.
You have to be prepared to explore their online therapy options as well if these can serve more convenience.
Customer Reviews
Chase is an excellent therapist! He takes time to listen, understand, and develops approaches that really meet me where I am as a client. Our sessions have become vital to guiding me through a meaningful and fulfilling life!
- Marc McAleavey | Google Review
Scheduling process was so smooth and easy! My appointment with Jasmin for my first visit was a lot, I felt like I was just dumping everything into her lap but she is extremely gracious and I am grateful to have started this journey!
- Christy Titus | Google Review
