Lucas BrennanRenovating a home combines the thrill of a fresh start with the high stakes of a major investment.
When you need to refresh an outdated Broad Ripple kitchen or add a master suite to a Carmel home, what you need is a true partner, not just a worker.
Living in Indy gives us access to incredible craftsmanship, but finding the right team requires sifting through the noise.
Thus, I have dug into the local market to uncover professionals who answer their phones, honor their quotes, and respect your space.
This guide breaks down the best renovation contractors in Indianapolis, helping you find a team that can turn your specific vision into a reality without the usual headaches.
How much does home renovation cost in Indianapolis?
Budgeting for a remodel in the Circle City can be tricky because no two older homes are alike, but whole-house renovations typically range from $15 to $60 per square foot. For a standard 2,000-square-foot home, that usually totals between $20,000 and $100,000.
Room-specific upgrades can raise your overall costs, with kitchens typically running $10,000 to $50,000 and bathrooms $5,000 to $25,000. High-end finishes potentially reaching $150+ per square foot, while labor often accounts for 50–60% of the total budget. Ultimately, your final price depends on the project’s complexity and chosen materials, which can range from $0.50 subway tile to $100 luxury stone.
Modern Touch Contracting, LLC
Website: https://mtcindyllc.com/
Address: 22 E Washington St Suite 640 C, Indianapolis
Contact: +1 317-855-9930
Hours: Mon – Fri: 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Agility is the hallmark of Modern Touch, supported by a dedicated in-house team that maintains tight quality control and keeps projects moving faster than many competitors.
Interestingly, if you change your mind mid-project, they can quickly pivot without throwing off the schedule.
What I like about them is how they maximize space in basements and kitchens, and how they use modern technology to visualize smart storage solutions you might not have considered.
However, the business itself is fairly new compared to their well-seasoned competitors, which may be something that those who prefer tenured contractors will have to consider.
Though the company only launched in 2020, its in-house team brings more than 25 years of combined experience, offering homeowners a balance of fresh innovation and seasoned craftsmanship.
Customer Reviews:
Wonderful experience with all involved from the owner to each of the craftsman. They made sure our new porch was exactly what we wanted. Their courtesy, kindness and attention to detail is what separates them from others. Thank you to everyone at Modern Touch for helping my family with our renovation!
- Katy Fischer | Google Review
Hands down one of the best companies I have had the pleasure of working with. Not only did they do an amazing job finishing our basement, they were also communicative, flexible and just overall a great group of guys! We plan to finish our backyard at some point and will definitely use them again. Highly recommend!
- Kacee Murphy | Google Review
Heartland Builders
Website: https://theheartlandbuilders.com/
Address: 8345 Clearvista Pl Suite 100, Indianapolis
Contact: +1 317-420-2455
Hours: Mon – Fri: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
At the core of Heartland Builders’ approach is the “Heartland Promise,” a commitment to strong client care and proven quality.
Their design work has even been featured in Architectural Digest, a sign they can handle more complex, high-end aesthetics.
For homeowners with larger projects, their partnership with Synchrony offers interest-free financing that helps make big renovations more manageable.
Beyond the interior, these builders are GAF Certified Roofing Contractors, meaning you can trust them with the structural shell of your home just as much as the kitchen layout.
I watched them handle a complex roofing and exterior remodel recently, and their speed in responding to texts stood out immediately.
However, keep in mind that they subcontract mechanical work like plumbing and electrical, so you will need to monitor that layer of coordination.
Customer Reviews:
I reached out to The Heartland Builders as I was looking to get the exterior of my house repainted. I could not be any happier with the service that was provided. They brought our vision to life and were a pleasure to work with. They were very transparent with us and made sure that we were happy each step of the way. The quality of the work speaks for itself. We will definitely be working with them again in the future!
- Darren Pirtle Jr. | Google Review
Our experience with Tony and his talented team helped us with a kitchen backsplash and a patio. Both were exceptional! The backsplash is a show piece and was constructed quickly, cleanly and with skill. Tony and his teams turned my vision of our patio extension into a dream. I will be using this group for my future projects.
- Carol Coddington | Google Review
Booher Remodeling Company
Website: https://www.booherbuilding.com/
Address: 5840 W 71st St, Indianapolis
Contact: +1 317-852-5546
Hours: Mon – Fri: 7:30 AM – 4:00 PM
Booher Remodeling has served central Indiana since 2001, acting as a seasoned veteran in the local market. Their “design-build” approach stands out because it unifies the entire process.
Designers sit down with you to draft the initial layout, and the same team stays involved until they drive the final nail. This seamless transition from paper to reality reduces the stress often found in piecemeal renovations.
They also maintain a complaint-free history with the BBB, which suggests they resolve issues quietly and effectively before they escalate. Financing through Hearth adds another layer of convenience.
However, their service area is strictly limited to communities like Indianapolis and Carmel. If you live on the outskirts, you might need to look elsewhere, but within their zone, their integrated process is difficult to match.
Customer Reviews:
Outstanding job by Booher on our master bathroom renovation! The whole team from the designers, project manager, and all the trades personnel were extremely professional! We needed to make a design change and the whole Booher team came together to offer several solutions. We are so happy with the results! We highly recommend Booher to anyone considering a master bathroom renovation.
- Kevin Porath | Google Review
Booher Remodeling did a great job on our bathroom remodel! They listened to what we wanted and delivered a space that was even better than we expected. The whole process was smooth, with good communication, a professional team, and excellent workmanship. We couldn’t be happier!
- CJ | Google Review
Fairchild Renovations
Website: https://www.fairchildrenovations.com/
Address: 3185 Shadeland Ave, Indianapolis
Contact: +1 317-432-6758
Hours: Mon – Fri: 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
With Fairchild Renovations, your project is handled with a true “fiduciary” mindset, meaning they look out for your long-term interests much like a financial advisor would.
Homeowners appreciate their daily updates and white-glove service, which helps reduce stress throughout the remodel. It’s no surprise that most of their work comes from referrals.
They also avoid marking up finish materials like tile or fixtures, giving you full control of that part of the budget.
On top of that, their crews follow strict cleanliness protocols, using HEPA filters and sealing off work zones so your family can breathe comfortably throughout the project.
The only drawback, like most contractors, is their Monday-through-Friday only schedule, which means no weekend appointments, but many homeowners find the professionalism and smooth weekday experience well worth it.
Customer Reviews:
Marc & his team were outstanding to work with. Kudos to Nick & his construction crew, they were professional, knowledgeable, efficient, reliable, honest, kind and quickly became part of the family.
We couldn’t have asked for a smoother or a more beautiful renovation to be our master bathroom.
- Amy Perryman | Google Review
Marc was great to work with throughout the entire project. Helped us work with our insurance company in order to get what we needed. They did a great job installing our new roof and where very fast and cleaned everything up afterwards. Even moved my grills around to keep them safe from falling debris during the install. I’d highly recommend them to anyone needing work on their house.
- Bart Welch | Google Review
White Oak Construction
Website: https://www.whiteoakconstruction.com/
Address: 10967 US Hwy 136, Indianapolis
Contact: +1 317-743-9066
Hours: Mon – Fri: 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Honesty and integrity guide White Oak Construction, a construction company with more than 40 years in the industry.
Rather than simply promising durability, they back their Weather Defender Rain Gutters and roofing systems with a 50-year warranty that covers both labor and materials, which is not very usual in this field.
They ensure every employee is factory-trained, guaranteeing that the person installing your windows understands the product mechanics inside and out.
I recently visited a site where they were installing siding, and the crew moved with noticeable organization and politeness.
The primary limitation is their physical footprint. While they serve a large area, their offices are located solely in Indiana.
This might limit in-person accessibility for out-of-state clients near the border, but for locals, their expertise is accessible and reliable.
Customer Reviews:
I love my window. I haven’t put a curtain up yet. From the road, you cannot see anything in my living room. The glass is reflected. I can’t believe this window was installed in a matter of hours. Installer was very professional. Everything was cleaned up after the installation. Inside and outside. I would recommend White Oak Construction to everyone.
- Cindy Cole | Google Review
From the beginning to the end of our project was seamless. Phenomenal service and quality products. Communication about when everyone was coming for measurements and install was super easy and they worked great for our busy schedule. Even our neighbors have said how great our new windows look! We highly recommend them and look forward to working with White Oak for future projects!
- Marlena Krauth | Google Review
