Sandra MillerLike every other person, I dreamed of building my own home. I get to customize every single detail to make it really mine, from the backsplash that my mom would hate to the pink garage that would drive my dad to cringecore.
So when the budget was secured, I finally did! It was no easy feat—a totally different experience than a kitchen remodel—but it was so worth it. There were bumps in the road, but I couldn’t have made it through without my home building team.
Who else would navigate all these permits and complex steps? Certainly not me! You need a reliable service, like our tried and tested home builders in Indianapolis who have earned our seal of approval!
What is the cost of hiring a home builder in Indianapolis?
Hiring a home builder in Indianapolis can start at $200,000 to $500,000, but can reach up to a million. The overall cost depends on the size of the home, site preparation fees, materials, labour, and more.
1. Compendium Group
Address: 961 N Highland Ave
Contact: 317-506-6367, [email protected]
Hours: Monday – Friday: 8 am – 5 pm
When it comes to home building, Compendium Group is one of our top choices for their incredible work. Seriously, the quality and design are impeccable, and it’s no wonder they’ve earned the trust of lots of clients.
You get a 3-in-1 service: builder, general contractor, and developer. Instead of outsourcing these things, they can do them all in-house, which showcases their reliability.
Their experience is also worth highlighting. Apart from building single-family homes and townhouses, they’re experienced in historic renovations, giving them specialised skills that you may want to incorporate into your new build.
It’s also not tough to collaborate with them, as they listen and give advice. Plus, their process is very organized, as they update clients every step of the way and always have answers to all questions.
The attention to detail we’ve seen has been incredible, from painting to installations, which speaks volumes about their reliability. It’s a shame they only operate in downtown Indianapolis because they’re not accessible to future homeowners who live elsewhere.
The team was incredibly responsive, professional, and fair
“As first-time homeowners, we were admittedly a bit overwhelmed by the process, but working with Micah, Tony, and Tatum made everything so much easier than we expected. From start to finish, the team was incredibly responsive, professional, and fair. They took the time to walk us through every step, answered all our (many!) questions with patience, and made sure we felt confident in every decision. The quality of work was outstanding—our home turned out absolutely beautiful and exactly how we envisioned it. Every detail was thoughtfully executed, and it’s clear that the Compendium team takes great pride in what they do.
We’re so grateful to have had such a positive and smooth experience with a team that truly cares. If you’re considering building a home, we can’t recommend Compendium enough!”
– Ethan Riddle, Google Review
Trusted partners at every step
“We love Compendium! Micah and Tatum were incredible as they built us our custom home in downtown Indy. From finding the right lot, designing, and building, they were trusted partners at every step. We love our new home and are thankful for the care and skill they brought to the project. Thank you, Michal and Tatum!!”
– Gillian Lackey, Google Review
2. Carrington Homes
Address: 10418 Hague Rd, Fishers
Contact: 317-336-8002
Hours: Monday – Friday: 9 am – 5 pm
What we admire most about Carrington Homes is their dedication to a stress-free home-building process. And they can back it up through various happy clients who have only good things to say.
Let’s start with their services, which include a full-service team of architects and designers who will help you build your dream home. Everything is custom-designed, and we appreciate that they know how to properly bring visions to reality.
Furthermore, they know how to pick the right subcontractors and suppliers. From what we’ve seen, the materials and workmanship have been incredible, as clients didn’t find issues after moving in—and any problem was resolved promptly.
Their specialisation lies in custom high-end homes, so expect higher costs. Not skyrocket prices, by the way, because they look for cost-effective solutions without compromising the quality of the build.
We also want to mention their team, who have been professional overall. They were responsive and flexible when it came to changes and addressed challenges immediately.
Amazing partner from start to finish
“Almost four years in our custom home and couldn’t be happier. Carrington was an amazing partner – from start to finish a smooth and enjoyable build. Carl, Grady and Zach were easy, flexible, timely and on top of every detail. I appreciated their experience, knowledge and willingness to make our dream come true! I also enjoyed working with their trusted vendors (lighting, plumbing, electrical, etc). It makes all the difference when you trust the experts and go with the best!”
– Sally Wlasuk, Google Review
Wonderful and responsive to work with
“I love the house that Carrington built for me. The team was wonderful and responsive to work with. The quality is unmatched. Carl had great ideas on how to improve the design and features to complement how I live. It really is my home, and I could not be happier with it.”
– Deborah Robins, Google Review
3. Integra Builders
Address: 9003 Technology Ln
Contact: 317-426-7807, [email protected]
Hours: Monday – Friday: 8 am – 6 pm
Integra Builders is a solid contender for modern homes in Indianapolis. They specialise in contemporary designs, which look luxurious in every corner.
But since they focus on modern luxury, their designs are limited in range. The aesthetics and functionality are never lost in their builds, anyway.
Judging by the homes we’ve seen, they know how to build with effortless flow, with nice, cohesive designs. The clients we spoke with noted the stunning modern aesthetics and attention to detail, which just shows that they know what materials to use.
The overall builds have gotten praise, not just by us. Homeowners appreciated the workmanship, since they didn’t find issues after moving in, even years later.
One of their strongest qualities as home builders is that they’re very easy to work with—yes, very, and we’re not exaggerating. The process, from start to finish, has been smooth, even with a few bumps in the road, as their team resolved issues quickly.
High-quality builders
“High quality builders, the building and quality of the build and materials internally have been incredible. They have a great eye for design and their experience shows.
Michael has a good heart and a great person and would recommend working with him. He is knowledgeable, responsive, and cares a ton.
– Colts Formstack, Google Review
Professionalism and attention to detail are second to none
“Integra Builders in one of the most professional organizations that I have ever been associated with. Their professionalism and attention to detail is second to none. I whole heartedly endorse them. You will not be disappointed!”
– Steve Kirk, Google Review
4. Timeless Tiny Homes
Contact: 463-666-7130
Hours:
- Monday – Friday: 8 am – 5 pm
- Saturday: 10 am – 2 pm
It isn’t easy to find a quality tiny home builder, but we found it in Timeless Tiny Homes. They specialise in tiny homes and ADU (Accessory Dwelling Unit) in Indianapolis, and they know how to build a functional and complete house, even with limited space.
They build homes from as little as 220 sq ft up to 1,200 sq ft, which is a good size range for these types of dwellings. The best part is that they have versatile designs, from modern to cottage styles.
Their versatility doesn’t stop at designing. It’s awesome how they can build in your lot, in your property beside your single-family home, or in a tiny home community.
We also want to note the streamlined process, as they’re not pushy. They provide transparent pricing without surprise charges—although permit fees aren’t included in the overall price—and offer affordable solutions without compromising on quality.
From the homes we saw, they’re an impressive team. Even with a small space, they managed to build a functional and stunning home.
Treats each customer like family
“Jonathan Carter has amazing vision and is dedicated to helping his customers bring their dreams of tiny home living to life. He treats each customer like they are family and will work tirelessly to achieve perfection with every detail. Timeless Tiny Homes is your go-to builder for a one of a kind luxury tiny home.”
– Tracy Brooks, Google Review
Brings insight and clarity to the building process
“I’ve been impressed by Jonathan Carter’s leadership at Timeless Tiny Homes. He brings insight and clarity to the building process in a way that makes sense. He’s thorough, thoughtful, and truly puts the client front and center. After talking with him, you’ll walk away understanding every step of your build. No fluff, just quality craftsmanship, clear communication, and solid follow-through. If you want someone who’s as invested in your vision as you are, Jonathan and his team deliver every time.”
– Jessica Charlesworth, Google Review
5. Loren Wood Builders
Address: 825 Massachusetts Ave, Suite C
Contact: 812-287-7575, [email protected]
Hours: Monday – Friday: 7 am – 4 pm
One of the things we like about Loren Wood Builders is that they’re serious about the design process. The whole operation, actually, because they’re very thorough with every little thing.
We appreciate that they bring in a collaborative process by ensuring the design team knows what the client wants. One of the compliments they received is that they guided their clients at every stage.
You can see that in their portfolio. They’re the kind of home builders who can design any style, from farmhouse to contemporary.
The quality? Superb. The eye for detail we’ve seen has been spectacular, as every material and finish looks like they were planned very carefully—and it’s true, because clients praised how they didn’t rush the process.
They get busy, though, since they also work on commercial spaces and remodeling jobs. And while a new project might not immediately receive a starting date, they’re worth the wait for the quality and customer service you get—an investment, really.
Exceeded our expectations
“We had used other general contractors in the past, and as with all construction, there will be unforeseen issues arise. The entire team at Loren Wood Builders far exceeded our expectations on communication, problem solving, and moving into planned action expeditiously. Their work product is superior! We have more projects to do and home building to consider, and one thing is for certain, we found our permanent contractor without reservation. The entire team at Loren Wood Builders are more than qualified in all areas of construction and provide their services with great care. Bravo to Loren and his entire team!!!!!”
– Mark Sims, Google Review
The end result was even better than I expected
“I cannot say enough positive things about my experience with the Loren Wood Builders Team. They are professional and knowledgeable, they communicate well, they respect your space and time, and they care. Their attention to detail was remarkable and they listened very closely to what I was looking to achieve. The end result was even better than I expected. The partners they have chosen to work with are equally outstanding. My kitchen remodel was a pleasant experience thanks the the Loren Wood Team.”
– Jennifer Riley Simone, Google Review
