Rachel SmithNo one plans for a lawsuit. Business owners staring down contract breaches and individuals caught in property disputes often find the legal system to be a confusing maze.
These cases often overlap with issues handled by criminal defense lawyers in Indianapolis, making it critical to work with attorneys who understand both civil and courtroom strategy.
You need someone who can cut through the noise and fight for your interests.
Finding the right representation in Indianapolis doesn’t have to be another headache on top of your legal troubles.
I’ve dug into the local legal scene to find firms that actually answer the phone and win cases. Here is my rundown of the top professionals who can handle your civil litigation needs.
How much does a Civil Litigation Lawyer cost in Indianapolis?
Legal fees are rarely one-size-fits-all, so you should prepare for a range of possibilities depending on your specific trouble. Generally, you are looking at hourly rates between $200 and $400, with the local average sitting right around $261 per hour. However, billing structures vary by case type. If you have a personal injury claim, many lawyers work on a contingency basis, taking about a third of the winnings only if you succeed. For routine business disputes, you might find flat fees. It is crucial to have a frank conversation about billing before you sign anything.
1. Law Office of Mark Nicholson
Website: https://www.marknicholsonlaw.com/
Address: 6284 Rucker Rd
Contact: +1 317-219-3402
Schedule: Available 24/7
If you value a fighter’s spirit in your corner, Mark Nicholson’s background as a veteran-owned business sets a strong tone right away.
Mark Nicholson brings a published author’s perspective to the courtroom, detailing his unique background in his book, The Law: From Prison to The Street.
This isn’t your standard corporate firm. Mark brings high-profile media experience to the table, having appeared on national TV, which suggests he knows how to handle pressure and public scrutiny.
Accessibility is a standout feature here. Knowing you can reach out for a consultation 24/7 provides peace of mind when legal panic sets in at midnight.
They also offer a client portal, making it easy to check case status without playing phone tag.
However, keep in mind that their services are strictly focused on Indianapolis and Indiana. If your legal battle crosses state lines, you might find their geographic limitation a bit restrictive for your needs.
Customer Reviews
I was extremely impressed by the knowledge and expertise
I was extremely impressed by the knowledge and expertise of the Law Office of Mark Nicholson. Their compassion and professionalism made a stressful situation feel manageable, and I could sense genuine integrity in every interaction. They provided the kind of service you expect from a great criminal defense lawyer, with thorough preparation and clear communication. I feel confident in their ability to protect my rights and I am excited to return here again for any future legal needs.
- tyler S | Google Review
I feel he truly cares about my situation
I contacted Mr. Nicholson about a civil rights case and I feel he truly cares about my situation. Even though the case wasn’t something he was able to help me with he still spent an hour answering all my questions, free of charge. He was very patient as he listened to my story and then helped me understand what options may be available to me.
I would definitely recommend him to anyone who is seeking representation. In the future if I am in a position to hire an attorney, Mark Nicholson will be my first choice.
- Millie Rouse | Google Review
2. Rob King & Associates, Trial Lawyers Indianapolis
Website: https://robkinglaw.com/
Address: 320 N Meridian St, Suite 906
Contact: +1 317-648-1339
Schedule: Available 24/7
Rob King & Associates makes a bold promise with their “No Fee Unless You Win” structure, which makes legal help accessible for anyone hesitant about costs.
They position themselves as the go-to team for the hard fights, explicitly stating a willingness to take on difficult cases that other lawyers might shy away from.
This includes lawsuits involving real estate transactions, investor conflicts, or disputes commonly seen with property management companies.
When I called them late one evening to test their response time, I was genuinely surprised to get a helpful human on the line rather than a robot, which really validated their 24/7 claim.
The only real downside is their physical footprint. While they serve all of Indiana, they only have offices in Indianapolis and Carmel. If you prefer face-to-face meetings and live in a different part of the state, the travel might be a hassle.
Customer Reviews
I had an excellent experience with Rob king and his team.
I had an excellent experience with Rob king and his team. The attorneys were professional, knowledgeable, and truly cared about my case. They took the time to explain everything clearly, kept me informed throughout the process, and were always responsive to my questions. Their expertise and dedication made a stressful situation much easier to handle. I highly recommend them to anyone in need of reliable and trustworthy legal representation thank you Rob and your team you guys rock.
- Brandon Bellamy | Google Review
Rob King & Associates is an outstanding law firm.
Rob King & Associates is an outstanding law firm. Their team is professional, knowledgeable, and genuinely committed to helping people navigate complex legal situations. Rob King leads with integrity and experience, and it’s clear he cares deeply about the clients and community he serves.
- Emma Hamilton | Google Review
3. Hayes Ruemmele LLC
Website: https://www.chjrlaw.com/
Address: 22 E Washington St UNIT 61
Contact: +1 317-978-9779
Schedule: Available 24/7
Hayes Ruemmele LLC operates with a justice-driven philosophy that feels very personal, emphasizing that “no one stands alone.” They distinguish themselves by bridging the gap between criminal and civil law.
This dual focus is useful if your situation involves complex intersections, like civil rights violations or institutional accountability. They specifically tackle niche, heavy areas like injuries in prison or clergy abuse, showing they aren’t afraid of powerful opponents.
Their approach is described as holistic, meaning they look at how a legal issue affects your whole life, not just your record.
Conveniently, they are centrally located downtown, which is great for city dwellers.
However, it is worth noting that this is a boutique firm. With just two primary attorneys listed, Charles Hayes and Jane Ruemmele, you might worry about bandwidth compared to a massive agency.
If you prefer a large army of associates, their smaller, more intimate size might be a drawback for you.
Customer Reviews
Hayes Ruemmele LLC did an outstanding job handling our case.
Hayes Ruemmele LLC did an outstanding job handling our case. They were extremely professional, courteous, and genuinely caring about the outcome of our case. They were also very easy to communicate with and demonstrated great attention to details.
I highly recommend this team.
- Jeanne Maclean | Google Review
I applaud thier hard work, Knowledge and Advice.
I would like to not only recommend these attorneys. But also Thank them. They took the hardest part of my life and fought for justice. They advised and did so much work for my son’s death. To make a difference in today’s world. I applaud thier hard work, Knowledge and Advice. They did it!! Made a Difference. Justice for my Son- who is deceased. And settled the case with everyone’s closure satisfied!
I would highly recommend them on your side.
- Dayton Collins | Google Review
4. Marc Lopez Law Firm
Website: https://marclopezlaw.com/
Address: 120 E Market St, Suite 710
Contact: +1 317-632-3642
Schedule: Available 24/7
The Marc Lopez Law Firm leverages the intense background of a former Deputy Prosecutor, giving them an insider’s view of how the other side thinks.
While known for their work in DUI law, their specialized credentials and criminal defense background translate well when you need aggressive representation.
A standout feature they have here is their team-based approach. You aren’t just hiring one lawyer, but you get a roster including Marc Lopez and Anthony Benitez.
Inclusivity is a major plus, too, with bilingual staff available to ensure Spanish-speaking clients feel fully understood and supported.
However, similar to other local firms, their expertise is hyper-focused on Indiana laws and Marion County courts. If your legal troubles involve cross-border issues or federal jurisdictions outside the state, their specialized local focus might limit their effectiveness for you.
Customer Reviews
I am so grateful to The Marc Lopez Law Firm and Zach Richey.
The Marc Lopez Law Firm is the most amazing law firm in the entire world. Thanks to the greatest lawyer ever, Zach Richey, my mother’s case got dismissed. I am so grateful to The Marc Lopez Law Firm and Zach Richey. I am currently eating cookies while sitting with my mother and that would not be possible without Zach Richey.
- Theodore Luke (Theo) | Google Review
Paralegal Sofi & Zach Richey did a great job on my case.
Paralegal Sofi & Zach Richey did a great job on my case. I only had to appear in court 1 time so I did not miss work. They kept in contact with me about any changes. They handled everything professionally and were confident my case would end up how I needed it to!
- Stephanie Price | Google Review
5. CohenMalad, LLP
Website: https://cohenandmalad.com/
Address: One Indiana Sq #1400
Contact: +1 463-282-6287
Schedule: Mon – Fri: 8 AM – 5 PM
If you are looking for heavy hitters with a history, CohenMalad, LLP is the powerhouse on this list. Founded in 1968, they bring over 55 years of stability and a staggering track record of over $1 billion in recoveries.
Their team is massive compared to others, with over 30 attorneys. This is the firm you call for high-stakes class actions or complex business litigation where deep resources are mandatory.
Their attorneys handle cases as varied as complex personal injury claims and high-stakes real estate litigation, allowing them to address diverse legal needs under one roof.
That said, their reputation is solidified by industry recognition and significant settlements, like a $237 million fraud recovery.
The only friction point I found was in their initial contact process. Their web form requires you to select an Indiana county, which feels like a procedural hurdle if you are an out-of-state client trying to initiate a lawsuit in Indianapolis.
It’s a small detail, but it could be frustrating.
Customer Reviews
They were very attentive, kind, professional and most of all honest.
During an extremely difficult time in my life, I contacted CohenMalad, LLP for advise and their expertise. They were very attentive, kind, professional and most of all honest. They were able to settle my case without my going to court and I am extremely satisfied with the end result. A special thank you to Chad Bradford and Jodi Bennett for all of their kindness, patience and hard work.
- Linda | Google Review
They handled it with professionalism and care.
Gregory Laker, Laurel Gilchrist and Donovan Smith took on a complex and messy case. They handled it with professionalism and care. They brought closure when I didn’t think it was possible. I cannot recommend these attorneys enough.
- Julien Slaughter | Google Review
