Lucas BrennanA property’s exterior is more than just a first impression. It’s a shield against the elements and a statement of style.
Because Indianapolis weather can be unpredictable, hiring a skilled stucco contractor is key to ensuring your walls remain both durable and visually appealing.
While some projects might require the broader expertise of renovation contractors or the heavy-duty foundation work of concrete contractors, specialized wall finishes need a dedicated professional.
To simplify your search, I’ve reviewed the top local experts and highlighted those who combine exceptional craftsmanship with lasting results. Here’s a look at the best stucco contractors in Indianapolis!
How much does stucco installation cost in Indianapolis?
Stucco installation in Indianapolis typically costs between $7.50 and $13.25 per square foot, with pricing varying based on the scope of the project.
| Service Type | Estimated Cost |
| Small Repairs | $200 – $750 |
| New Installation | $10.63 per sq. ft. on average |
| Full Replacement | $11,953 – $15,983 |
1. Linehan’s & Son’s Plastering
Website: https://linehanandsons.net/
Address: 2306 Reformers Ave
Contact: +13177832251
Hours: Monday – Sunday, 8 AM–7 PM
Securing a dependable crew is crucial when you need high-quality craftsmanship for your property, and Linehan’s & Son’s Plastering delivers on that front.
Their deep knowledge of the trade shows in every wall and ceiling project, from standard drywall to complex faux finishes.
I like that they start with a free consultation, which makes it easy to plan the best approach before any work begins.
Customers I spoke with also highlighted their skill with tricky repairs, such as fixing stubborn ceiling leaks or seamlessly patching large cracks.
Based on their track record, the team consistently comes across as professional while keeping pricing very reasonable for residential jobs.
Because they offer such competitive rates, their schedule fills up quickly. You might find yourself waiting a few weeks to lock in an appointment, which isn’t ideal if you are in a rush to fix a sudden exterior issue.
Attention to detail, efficiency, and friendliness
Cannot recommend Russ and his team enough! Their attention to detail, efficiency, and friendliness made our stucco repair a very positive experience. It’s clear that Russ and his team are true experts at what they do and the job they did on our stucco repair reflects that.
Maddie Venable, Google Review
Very prompt with all communications
Rusty and 2 others were at our home to repair several spots in ceilings and walls. Rusty was very prompt with all communications from estimate to work timing and any questions I had. They relocated items and covered areas to protect our furnishings. They repaired all noticeable cracks in areas near those we had identified. We would highly recommend these folks for your plaster repair needs!
Mary Conners, Google Review
2. Rhino Shield of Indiana
Website: https://www.rhinoshieldin.com/
Address: 7745 E 89th St
Contact: +18887446641
Hours: Monday – Friday, 8 AM–5 PM
Rhino Shield of Indiana stood out for the durability of its materials. They offer a proprietary ceramic elastomeric coating that is applied eight to ten times thicker than standard exterior paint.
This unique application method bonds directly to the surface, creating a durable layer that preserves your home’s original texture.
Even better, they handle the entire process from inspecting cracks to sealing the facade. This makes the service more consistent throughout the whole project.
One of the biggest selling points for me is their 25-year transferable warranty, which can add serious long-term value.
That said, some customers have reported challenges when trying to make warranty claims.
A few experienced peeling and found it difficult to get timely support from management, which is something potential buyers should keep in mind.
Executed on what they promised
Rhino Shield did a fantastic job repairing the exterior of our 30,000 square ft. commercial building. We were quoted 40% more by another company to repair and paint the stucco of our building. Rhino Shield was not only better priced, they were also very prompt, professional and executed on what they promised. I was beyond thrilled with the results.
Olivia Warner, Google Review
Absolutely wonderful to work with
Rhinoshield was absolutely wonderful to work with. Great communication, timely completion, and great customer service. Caesar was the lead technician for our project. He was courteous and kept us informed every step of the way. Our results are better than I could have ever imagined. Absolutely love how it all turned out. I would recommend this company over and over
Alie White, Google Review
3. BLANKENSHIP DRYWALL & PLASTER REPAIR
Website: https://frankblankenshipdrywall.com/
Address: 2860 Harlan St
Contact: +13172589186
Hours: Monday – Friday, 8 AM–5 PM
Owners of older homes often face tricky challenges when restoring original walls and ceilings. Thankfully, I found Blankenship Drywall and Plaster Repair for that.
Specializing in both modern installations and historic surface restoration, Frank Blankenship and his team bring over three decades of hands-on experience.
It’s no wonder their texture-matching skills are impressive. I really appreciate how they ensure repaired areas blend seamlessly with existing architecture.
I also appreciated their convenient photo-based quoting system. This really speeds up estimates and makes planning much easier.
Customers frequently praise their fast turnaround and responsive communication. Many inquiries get same-day replies, allowing critical repairs to be scheduled within days.
The only limitation is that their work is focused on residential interiors. Anyone needing large-scale exterior facades or commercial projects will need to look elsewhere
Work is absolutely top-notch
I can’t say enough about the fantastic drywall repair I received. The frank was professional, prompt, and the quality of his work is absolutely top-notch. You can’t even tell there was a hole in the ceiling. The patch is seamless. Highly recommend the services for anyone needing drywall repair
Justus McGill, Google Review
Result looks perfect
Frank was awesome and did a flawless job at a fair price. I had a large hole in the kitchen ceiling of my very old house after major plumbing repairs. He was on time, quick to get the work started, and the result looks perfect. I recommend Blankenship Drywall to anyone who needs a drywall or plaster repair! (The ‘after’ picture shows the repair without paint)
Sophia, Google Review
4. Indiana Wall Systems
Website: https://centralindianastuccorepair.com/
Address: 5202 W 700 S, Morgantown
Contact: +17653416020
Hours: Monday – Friday, 6 AM–5 PM, Saturday, 9 AM–12:30 PM
Understanding regional building styles is key to protecting the structural integrity of your exterior, and Indiana Wall Systems really leverages its Central Indiana roots. Their local knowledge gives them a strong grasp of how climate impacts building materials.
They offer a full range of services, from initial installation and ongoing maintenance to complex historical restorations. Customers I spoke with also shared that the team used premium materials, resulting in a long-lasting work.
Their approach is also consistently praised as thoughtful and customer-focused. They take the time to tailor methods instead of rushing through the work.
The only downside is pricing. Because they rely on high-quality materials and specialized expertise, their services are often more expensive than other local options.
Honest, consistent and fair
I cannot recommend this company enough! Indiana Wall Systems has been THE BEST repair company we have ever worked with! Jeff Johnson and his team are prompt, thorough, honest, consistent and fair. The level of integrity they have shown far surpasses any business we have dealt with. If you need help repairing EIFS (stucco) this is THE company to use! Thank you, again, Indiana Wall Systems!
Natalie Holzer, Google Review
Made the experience as smooth as possible
Jeff and the guys really knocked my exterior stucco project out of the park. on time and under budget, they rolled with the punches that the weather threw at them and genuinely made the experience as smooth as possible. would definitely recommend and will use them again when and if I ever need to..
Alex, Google Review
5. Knauss Property Services, LLC
Website: https://propertyservices.com/
Address: 2817 E 55th Pl Suite 101
Contact: +13172559789
Hours: Monday – Friday, 7:30 AM–6 PM, Saturday, 9 AM–12 PM
Managing a property means balancing routine maintenance with unexpected repairs, and Knauss Property Services makes that much easier.
They specialize in comprehensive property management. They handle everything from remodeling to tenant placement.
Their on-demand repair solutions help owners maintain property value and minimize vacancy. Meanwhile, their efficient maintenance team keeps buildings in top condition year-round.
I really love their customer-focused approach. They tailor projects to each client’s specific needs, which explains why they’ve built such long-term relationships.
Being locally focused also gives them a solid grasp of regional building codes and compliance standards.
The only limitation is specialization. While they cover a wide range of general construction needs, clients seeking luxury renovations or advanced green building techniques may find their approach too broad.
Work was done beautifully
The stucco over my front door was water damaged and sagging. There was a hole in the roof above it from a fallen tree branch.
The crew came out around 8am and worked until 5:30. They returned the next morning to finish. They were prompt, professional, and the work was done beautifully. Clean up was excellent.
I would recommend Knauss without hesitation, and would hire them again.
A+
Rosemary Igney, Google Review
Completed the job ahead of schedule
I contacted Knaus Property Services when the stucco on my home needed repair. Ralph Knauss and his hard working crew did excellent work, and more than that they were respectful, arrived on time, and completed the job ahead of schedule. I can’t recommend them highly enough.
Allen Strahl, Google Review
