Lucas BrennanWhen the winter freeze hits, a malfunctioning heating system is a homeowner’s worst nightmare. Finding the best boiler repair in Indianapolis is crucial for keeping your property safe and comfortable during the colder months.
Whether you manage a large commercial building or simply want to keep your family warm, hiring a qualified technician ensures the job gets done right.
Property managers and homeowners alike know that maintaining your heating system is just as vital as hiring reliable renovation contractors for structural updates or scheduling routine gutter repair before the rainy season.
Let’s explore the top local experts who can restore your heat quickly and efficiently!
How much do boiler repairs cost in Indianapolis?
Boiler repair in Indianapolis generally costs between $190 and $660, with an average service call running around $425.
| Service Type | Estimated Cost |
| Average Service Call | $190 – $660 |
| Labor Rates | $75 – $130 per hour (or $150 – $300 flat fee) |
| Minor Repairs (Ignitor/Sensor) | $125 – $250 |
| Major Repairs (Circulator Pump/Expansion Tank) | $400 – $800+ |
| Gas Boiler Repairs | $100 – $400 |
| Electric or Oil Boiler Repairs | $200 – $500 |
1. Broad Ripple Service Experts
Website: https://www.serviceexperts.com/indianapolis-in/
Address: 8227 Northwest Blvd Suite 300
Contact: +13176498983
Hours: 24/7
Broad Ripple Service Experts combines the personal touch of a local shop with the resources of a major national brand.
Serving Indianapolis since 1962, the company is backed by Brookfield, a global leader in infrastructure. Plus, their ACE-certified technicians focus on full-system optimization rather than quick patches, helping to prevent future boiler breakdowns.
A standout feature is their Advantage Program, which allows homeowners to lease new, high-efficiency equipment with no upfront costs. I like how this plan covers all future maintenance and repairs under a single monthly payment.
For those facing a winter storm, their 24/7 emergency service provides reliable support.
Just keep an eye on your budget. Their premium, nationally backed service structure often means their pricing runs noticeably higher than smaller, independent local competitors.
Great company. Great people.
10/10 recommend. Josh and Aurek were very professional and did a great job replacing our water heater, on the same day I called. Thanks, guys! Broad Ripple also put in a new boiler. Great company. Great people.
Janice Wilson, Google Review
efficient and tidy around the units he inspected
Ira, the service technician, arrived early in the appointment period. He was efficient and tidy around the units he inspected. He was a good communicator about describing the condition of my boiler and AC units about abour my options on how to prolong their service. Ira is a credit to your firm.
Ron Gyure, Google Review
2. Bolls Heating & Cooling
Website: https://www.bollscomfort.com/
Address: 3648 W 16th St
Contact: +13178303010
Hours: 24/7
Finding a contractor who values honesty over a quick sale is a priority for most homeowners.
Bolls Heating & Cooling delivers on this by explicitly promising to recommend only necessary fixes, drawing on over 70 years of proven local experience.
It’s also great that their NATE-certified technicians are trained to handle modern installations and legacy boiler systems with impressive accuracy.
I spoke with a property manager recently who praised their rapid emergency response during a severe winter freeze. They arrived within 90 minutes and efficiently restored the heat without pushing an unnecessary system replacement.
While their diagnostic skills are generally excellent, a few clients have reported isolated incidents. For instance, some of the heating systems they repaired didn’t fully restore warmth immediately after the initial service visit, requiring a follow-up.
on time and at a great price!
Our boiler pump started leaking water. Bolls had someone out that day to diagnose. New pump was recommended and installed on time and at a great price! We had the same Tech through the entire process, and he was very professional. Communication was top notch.
Archie Fowler, Google Review
they made the process smooth
Both the account rep and the service team were awesome to work with. We needed our very old boiler replaced and they made the process smooth, were quick to respond to questions. It’s several months in now with the new boiler and we couldn’t be happier.
Rachel Matthea, Google Review
3. Complete Comfort Heating, A/C & Plumbing Repair
Website: https://completecomfortgo.com/heating-installation-in-fishers/
Address: 11650 Lantern Rd Suite 118, Fishers
Contact: +13175939506
Hours: 24/7
Heating emergencies rarely happen during convenient business hours. Complete Comfort Heating, A/C & Plumbing Repair stands out by offering round-the-clock emergency service with absolutely no extra after-hours fees.
From what I’ve seen, they’re dedicated problem solvers rather than simple parts replacers. I like how their focus helps alleviate the common fear of being pressured into a full unit replacement.
Plus, their highly trained technicians arrive in fully stocked vehicles, aiming to resolve complex boiler breakdowns on the very first visit. This level of preparedness is crucial for minimizing downtime during freezing weather.
Do keep in mind that some clients have experienced frustrating scheduling issues. It was a bit disappointing to note that some experienced occasional appointment cancellations and poor communication from the dispatch office.
Have used them to service my heating unit for the past 5 years.
They are the guys to call for boiler repairs in Indianapolis. Have used them to service my heating unit for the past 5 years. My circulator pump failed and Garrett actually kept it on his truck!!!! A+
mike caylor, Google Review
professional and efficient
Had another great semi-annual check up for the two heating systems in my house, this time with Chris. He called to let me know when he would arrive and was professional and efficient while checking both systems. We purchased both HVAC systems, a tankless water heater and a water softener from Complete Comfort 3-4 years ago to replace aging systems and couldn’t be happier with the installation work and subsequent check up visits.
Michael Jacobs, Google Review
4. Carter’s My Plumber
Website: https://www.cartersmyplumber.com/
Address: 450 E 96th St #500
Contact: +13178932462
Hours: 24/7
Trust is built over decades. Carter’s My Plumber has been serving the local community as a family-owned business run by three generations of the Carter family since 1969.
They specialize heavily in water heating and hydronic systems, giving them the precise technical expertise needed to handle intricate boiler diagnostics.
What I love most about them is their clear upfront pricing and free estimates to ensure transparency before any work begins.
Their quotes are higher, though, compared to what smaller independent plumbers typically charge.
Nonetheless, their commitment to guaranteed workmanship adds a layer of confidence to every repair job. One of my neighbors used their services last winter and was highly impressed by the polite, knowledgeable technician who arrived the very same day.
our year maintenance on our boiler/dual water heater
We had our year maintenance on our boiler/dual water heater. Peyton was very professional and did he a great job.
Michelle Turner (Chelle), Google Review
making sure we felt informed and confident
We had a fantastic experience with Mr. Plumber, especially Luke W., who was thorough, professional, and incredibly helpful throughout our water heater installation. He took the time to clearly explain the issues and our options, making sure we felt informed and confident in the decisions being made. Luke not only did an excellent job solving the problem, but he also kept our budget in mind and helped us choose a cost-effective solution. We truly appreciate his care, expertise, and quality work, and highly recommend Mr. Plumber.
A M, Google Review
5. Masters Heating & Cooling
Website: https://mastersheatcool.com/
Address: 8450 W Washington St
Contact: +13172079983
Hours: Monday – Friday, 7:30 AM–4:30 PM
Navigating a sudden equipment failure is much easier when you hire seasoned professionals.
Masters Heating & Cooling brings over 40 years of experience to the table, offering comprehensive support for your entire heating setup.
Their NATE-certified technicians excel at explaining complicated diagnostics clearly, helping you make informed decisions about your specific repair needs.
Plus, as a Carrier Factory Authorized Dealer, they have direct access to high-quality replacement components and modern energy-efficient upgrades.
I also appreciate their convenient financing options that make major heating investments much more manageable for the average homeowner.
On the downside, there have been a few isolated reports of minor installation errors that required a follow-up visit to completely resolve the issue.
get parts ordered in a timely manner
Very good experience with Masters H&C,… Mike, the technician was very knowledgeable on the boiler system I had and was able to troubleshoot and get parts ordered in a timely manner as well as being all around good guy!….The staff was very good to work with and kept me updated on parts arrival and reschedule for fix. Would have no problem recommending Masters to anyone looking for HVAC service…. great job!!
Steve Mattox, Google Review
very professional
Our Crane gas boiler would not fire. Contacted Masters Heating & Cooling for a service/repair call. Mike arrived and was very professional. With his years of experience and knowledge explained in detail the issues we were faced with. After discussion of options we came to the the conclusion that a replacement was necessary. Thank you Mike.
Patrick Ashmore, Google Review
