Rachel SmithTaking the first step toward better health can feel overwhelming, especially when trying to navigate conflicting nutrition advice.
The best dietitians in Indianapolis provide wonderful, personalized support for managing a chronic condition or building sustainable habits without feeling restricted.
I explored some of the most dedicated professionals in the area to help you find a practitioner who truly listens and meets you exactly where you are on your wellness journey.
How much does going to a dietitian cost in Indianapolis?
In Indianapolis, an initial dietitian consultation typically ranges from $70 to over $200, depending on the provider’s experience and whether you utilize insurance or purchase a package.
| Service Type | Average Cost Range |
| Initial Consultation (60-90 minutes) | $100 – $250 |
| Follow-Up Session (30-45 minutes) | $50 – $150 |
| Monthly Subscription / Package | Varies (e.g., $249/month) |
| With Insurance (e.g., Medicare Part B) | $0 – standard copay |
1. Hannah Batic, RD – Dietitian Nutritionist
Website: https://www.faynutrition.com/
Address: 8111 S Emerson Ave, 46237
Contact: (617) 982-3658
Hours: Monday – Sunday, 7:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Stepping into a clinical office can feel intimidating, but Hannah Batic completely flips that script by integrating evidence-based nutrition science with spiritual and emotional healing.
I recently spoke with a colleague who visited Hannah for anxiety management, and she felt incredibly supported by the focus on whole-food recipe integration.
Hannah offers a holistic approach to eating that you won’t find elsewhere. Instead of simply recommending diets, her approach is akin to a full counseling experience.
To get started, she accepts major insurance plans to remove the steep out-of-pocket barrier, and her flexible evening hours make scheduling remarkably simple.
While her integration of spirituality is comforting for many, it might not appeal to patients looking for a strictly secular medical consultation.
Customer Reviews:
Look Forward To Working With Her More
Hannah is amazing! So informative, very sweet caring personality! I had an hour and a half meeting with her about starting my nutrition road and it went so fast because she was easy to talk to! Look forward to working with her more!
- Natalie Apellaniz | Google Review
They are Patient and Kind
First appt was great! She was patient, kind, listened, and truly zoned in on my questions and concerns. She validated my feelings and applied no pressure. She let me guide the conversation to be able to voice my thoughts and offered feedback along the way. She really took my unusual situation and researched appropriate avenues to travel. Kind of a rarity these days when speaking with professionals about your health.
- Cookie Leigh | Google Review
2. Laurie Elmore, RD – Dietitian Nutritionist
Website: https://www.healthgrades.com/
Address: 1481 W 10th St
Contact: (630) 635-5950
Hours: Monday – Sunday, 7:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Laurie Elmore uniquely combines her deep expertise as a Registered Dietitian with her background as a Certified Personal Trainer to help clients step away from yo-yo dieting entirely.
I have a friend who used her services and appreciated how her passion for culinary application provided practical recipe ideas instead of abstract macronutrient targets.
With over six years of dedicated outpatient practice, Laurie easily translates complex therapies into manageable steps for those managing chronic diseases.
She also has extensive telehealth hours that offer wonderful convenience and accessible support.
However, clients seeking a physical office experience might find her virtual-forward model somewhat isolating.
3. Sara Wisehart, RD – Dietitian Nutritionist
Website: https://www.faynutrition.com/
Address: 9105 E 56th St SUITE J, #2009
Contact: (617) 982-3658
Hours: Monday – Sunday, 7:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Navigating blood sugar issues is a delicate process that needs the direction of a credentialed provider. Sara Wisehart provides exceptional guidance as a Certified Diabetes Care and Education Specialist.
She brings 15 years of rigorous clinical experience to her practice, making you even more confident in her expertise. She establishes actionable goals to prevent patient overwhelm while tackling root-cause resolutions.
A relative of mine found her customized meal plan subscription incredibly helpful for their long-term self-care journey.
But because her coaching philosophy relies heavily on the patient being self-directed, individuals who require rigid daily accountability checks might struggle with her flexible framework.
Customer Reviews:
Easy To Recommend Her
Sara has been fantastic to work with. I started seeing her about 6 weeks ago and I’m down 8 lb, I feel confident we’ve developed a strategy for continued weight loss. She’s had some fantastic ideas and shared some valuable information about how I should approach healthy eating, and generally live a more healthy lifestyle. Sara is personable and professional, it’s easy to recommend her.
- Ryan Griffith | Google Review
4. Kimberly Carlton, RD – Dietitian Nutritionist
Website: https://www.faynutrition.com/
Address: 7240 Shadeland Station Way # 200
Contact: (617) 982-3658
Hours: Monday – Sunday, 7:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Finding a provider who understands renal health is crucial for a truly healthy diet plan. Kimberly Carlton brings exactly that with 30 years of experience dedicated entirely to managing complex kidney nutrition protocols.
From what I heard, this nutritionist is highly skilled at guiding patients through complex elimination protocols without causing accidental malnutrition.
She even confidently collaborates with your nephrologist to align dietary goals with medical treatments, helping you build a solid internal foundation.
However, a few clients have noted they wished for a more rigid follow-up cadence, indicating her approach requires you to actively take the initiative in scheduling ongoing care.
5. Aligned Health Practice
Website: http://www.alignedhealthpractice.com/
Address: 300 E Main St E
Contact: (317) 210-3722, [email protected]
Hours: Monday – Friday, 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
For those seeking an all-encompassing wellness destination, Aligned Health Practice is the go-to. This office operates as a cutting-edge hybrid clinic that seamlessly unites registered dietitians and Nurse Practitioners.
This unique setup allows them to provide medical weight loss and advanced lab testing entirely under one roof, ensuring that any diet or nutritional plan supports your long-term health.
Unlike many functional clinics, they actively accept and bill insurance for preventative nutrition services to drastically reduce out-of-pocket stress.
But because of their immense popularity, certain lead practitioners are frequently closed to new patients, meaning you might need to join a waitlist instead of getting immediate access.
Customer Reviews:
Helped Me So Much
Nikki is a great dietician. She has helped me so much with my health issues. She listens to my concerns, addresses them completely, asks relevant questions and always has knowledgable, creative and specific suggestions. I feel that I am doing all I can to support my health through my diet, supplements, tracking my food and working with Nikki.
- Sue Iffert | Google Review
Responsive, Knowledgeable, And Very Kind
Awesome! Lindsey was responsive, knowledgeable, and very kind. This is not a place that will sell you fad diets or tell you to make monumental changes all at once. With moderate changes to my diet and exercise, I lowered my A1C 0.6% in three months. I suspect this drop was largely due to lowered stress, which was helped by working with a good dietician.
- Eliza Foran | Google Review
