Rachel SmithThink about the crispy edges of slow-roasted gyro meat or the fiery sizzle of fresh saganaki. If those sounds make your stomach rumble, then you’re in the right place.
Indianapolis hides some incredible Mediterranean gems within its busy streets. I set out to find the absolute best Greek food in the city to satisfy those intense feta cravings.
We tasted tangy tzatziki and devoured massive pita wraps to find the winners. Grab a napkin and get ready because we’re diving into the best local spots for authentic flavors.
How much does dining at a Greek restaurant cost in Indianapolis?
You can expect to spend anywhere from $5 for a quick gyro lunch to over $30 per person for a full sit-down dinner.
| Dining Type | Estimated Cost |
| Casual / Quick Bites (Gyros, combos) | $5 – $13 |
| Mid-Range / Full Service (Entrees, Moussaka) | $15 – $25+ |
| Appetizers / Sides (Spanakopita, salads) | $5 – $12 |
1. Greek Islands
Website: https://www.greekislandsrestaurant.com/
Address: 906 S Meridian St.
Contact: (317) 636-0700 | [email protected]
Hours:
- Tuesday – Friday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Saturday: 3:00 PM – 9:00 PM
The Stergiopoulos family has run the Greek Islands since 1987, making it the longest-operating Mediterranean spot in the city.
When you walk in, you’ll immediately feel a high-energy vibe. This is especially true when the staff lights the signature saganaki cheese right at your table.
I visited last Tuesday for a quick lunch, and the rich, lemon-infused Avgolemono soup totally blew me away. They serve massive portions of authentic dishes like pastitsio, and they even happily adjust meals for gluten-free diets.
You can also enjoy a chilled Greek frappé while you eat.
The only downside is their limited schedule. They stay completely closed to the public on Sundays and Mondays. This means you must plan your cravings carefully, but the fresh flavors make every visit worth the wait.
Customer Reviews:
Everything was great
Oh my goodness! Everything was great: the food, the service, the appetizers, the desserts. It wasn’t my first time there and I have never been disappointed. I cannot say good enough about this place. These people know how to cook great food and service was above and beyond great.
- Sharon Eckstein | Google Review
Absolutely fantastic food
Absolutely fantastic food, and the staff are passionate and excited about food and quality as well. This place is heavenly for people who not only love quality food clearly made with culinary expertise, but a welcoming atmosphere to those who feel the same. Greek island restaurant is worth a visit, easily.
I personally ordered the Saganaki and Kreatopita (meat pie), and it’ll be difficult to get anything else next time.
- Austin Terry | Google Review
2. ATHENS ON 86th
Website: http://www.athenson86th.com/
Address: 2284 W 86th St West
Contact: (317) 879-8644
Hours:
- Tuesday – Thursday, Sunday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
- Friday – Saturday: 11:00 AM – 9:30 PM
Tina Konduris and her family pour genuine love into every meal they serve at ATHENS ON 86th. They cater to large groups and special celebrations, so you always feel a warm, communal energy in the dining room.
The kitchen refuses to cut corners on fresh ingredients, resulting in hearty lamb entrees and specialty gyros that rival the top meals in town.
If you need a break from exploring Japanese restaurants, their diverse menu hits the spot with plenty of gluten-free options. The staff also manages special dietary requests without any fuss.
You should keep an eye on the clock if you want a late dinner, though. They close early on weekends and shut the doors at 9:30 PM.
Customer Reviews:
The food was wonderful
We had a truly great experience dining here with our large group of 12 people on a busy Friday night! The food was wonderful, the atmosphere was great, and the unique entertainment was fantastic—they even had a belly dancer come around a couple of times! It was quite the spectacle. Just a heads up on the facilities: They only have one restroom per gender, which could lead to a wait during a busy rush. But overall, a wonderful night of great food and great fun!
- Mason Adams | Google Review
5 Stars for Food, Service, and Atmosphere!
5 Stars for Food, Service and Atmosphere!
I stopped in and ordered the Hummus Plate and the Athens Shrimp. Both were equally delicious and the atmosphere was quite nice. Very quiet and quaint during lunch time!
- Charlotte Pardue | Google Review
3. Canal Bistro
Website: http://www.canal-bistro.com/
Address: 6349 Guilford Ave
Contact: (317) 254-8700
Hours:
- Monday – Thursday, Sunday: 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM
- Friday – Saturday: 11:00 AM – 9:30 PM (Weekend Brunch: 10:00 AM – 1:00 PM)
Canal Bistro is located on the Central Canal Towpath, providing diners with a relaxing and unmatched waterfront atmosphere.
While you sit, you can actually watch the chefs grill fresh meats over an open fire right in the middle of the dining room.
I grabbed brunch here last Sunday, and the baklava-stuffed French toast completely changed my morning. The owners blend their Egyptian and Lebanese heritage into the menu, creating a fun twist on standard fare.
They also clearly mark dozens of gluten-friendly dishes, which makes ordering a breeze for everyone.
However, you do need to watch out for extra charges. They charge a separate fee for every additional cup of tzatziki or garlic sauce you request. Even with the extra fees, though, the experience and flavors are truly unique and worth the trip.
Customer Reviews:
Service and food were fantastic
Really cozy place on canal. We loved the service and food was fantastic. Many great choices for vegetarian meals. Also, surprisingly the rice was wonderful and unique taste. Our most favorite was cheese fries. It was very delicious.
- Kunal_Kool | Google Review
High-quality food and consistently flavorful
Fantastic option for Mediterranean food in broad ripples. Quaint ambiance. High quality food and consistently flavorful. I love the hummus, schwarma, pita, and the garlic feta fries are INCREDIBLE and crunchy. We got carry out and the food was delicious and traveled really well without impacting the texture. Some carry out food doesn’t hold up, this does.
- Sarah Jerrell | Google Review
4. Indy Gyros
Website: http://indygyros.com/
Address: 6658 West Washington Street
Contact: (317) 340-1093
Hours:
- Monday – Saturday: 10:30 AM – 10:00 PM
- Sunday: 11:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Indy Gyros is a huge hit for adventurous eaters because it mixes spicy Indian appetizers with rich Mediterranean staples. One of the best things on the menu is a signature plate featuring gyro meat and feta cheese over crispy fries.
It’s basically a decadent twist on classic poutine. This creative style bridges the gap perfectly if you love Indian restaurants but find yourself craving a traditional pita wrap.
You can even enjoy huge platters of falafel or catfish served over seasoned rice. And be sure to wash your meal down with a sweet, homemade mango lassi.
Just keep in mind that modifications come with an extra cost. Since almost all items have à la carte pricing, side sauces and extra protein will quickly increase your final bill.
Customer Reviews:
This food is simply spectacular
This food is simply spectacular. From the very first bite, you feel an explosion of flavors in your mouth that are indescribable. I truly invite everyone to come to this place and try delicious, super fresh food. The in-store service is great. The guy who works there helps you really well, explains everything in detail, and is just wonderful. I recommend it 100%.
My plate was the combo over rice (Lamb and Chicken) AMAZING!!
- Roimer Campos | Google Review
I always go here, and it’s amazing
I always go here and it’s amazing, I’m just frustrated because I drove home and open the box for great food and there was no white sauce or hot sauce. Very disappointed we are not doing rocket science so still 5 stars , just frustrating
- Richard Nickerson | Google Review
5. Taziki’s Mediterranean Cafe – Keystone Crossing
Website: https://www.tazikis.com/location/keystone-crossing
Address: 4025 E 82nd St., Suite 101
Contact: (317) 315-1125; [email protected]
Hours:
- Sunday – Thursday: 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Friday – Saturday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Taziki’s Mediterranean Cafe has a very relaxed, welcoming energy. They have set up large community tables and a gorgeous outdoor patio to encourage neighbors to connect over a fresh meal.
Building a menu centered on a healthy Mediterranean lifestyle, the kitchen sources premium goods from American farmers while importing authentic staples directly from overseas.
You can really taste that high quality in every handcrafted and minimally processed bite.
Plus, the central location near the fashion mall makes it an ideal pit stop during a busy shopping trip.
However, you’ll need to wrap up your dinner conversations relatively early. The kitchen completely shuts down at 9:00 PM on Friday and Saturday nights.
Customer Reviews:
All the food has been great!
I’ve had this twice now and all the food has been great! The lemon soup is top notch, the hummus has great texture and flavor. I recently had the chicken kabobs, potatoes and Greek salad. The chicken was cooked and seasoned perfectly, the potatoes were great and the salad had great balance. Has become my new favorite lunch spot!
- Christine Landeros | Google Review
Food is amazing
The first time here, food is amazing. The service was excellent, and the atmosphere was super chill. I got the Street Gyro and an appetizer of falafel. Talk about slap ya mama good! OMGOODNESS, this is my new favorite place. My sister got the build-your-own-feast it looked amazing, and she said it was fantastic. Cannot say enough about this place. So good!
- Debby Ursery | Google Review
