Andre TaylorFinding the best toy store in Indianapolis can really feel like a massive treasure hunt. This is especially true when you’re looking for something safe, educational, and genuinely exciting for your little ones.
We all know the struggle of wandering through big-box aisles only to walk away with flimsy plastic toys that break in just two days.
Whether you’re a parent looking for developmental milestones, a gift shopper hunting for a rare collectible, or an educator seeking classroom materials, our city has some incredible spots waiting to be explored.
So, let’s dive into these magical local shops where play is truly the priority and imagination always comes first.
How much do toys cost in Indianapolis?
Prices across local toy shops range from pocket-friendly trinkets under $10 to rare, high-end collector items surpassing $500.
| Category | Price Range |
| Budget Items (Small plush, basic action figures) | $5 – $15 |
| Mid-Range Toys (Board games, dolls, playsets) | $15 – $50 |
| Specialty/Collector Items (Vintage figures, rare sets) | $50+ |
1. The Toy Pit
Website: https://www.yourtoypit.com/
Address: 3827 N College Ave
Contact: (317) 703-8697
Hours:
- Tuesday – Friday: 11:00 AM – 6:30 PM
- Saturday: 10:30 AM – 6:00 PM
- Sunday: 12:00 PM – 6:00 PM
If you have a knack for nostalgia, you’ll be thrilled to know that this spot is a true haven for collectors. They let you buy or trade items, which is ideal for Lego collectors and vintage video game hunters.
Last month, I brought in a box of my old childhood action figures and was really impressed by how the staff appraised everything right there at the counter.
However, you do have to visit the physical storefront to take advantage of those great in-person trading services.
The shop really is a collector’s dream, and they stay very active on social media, keeping fans updated on all their fresh hauls.
But just keep in mind that you’ll likely leave empty-handed if you’re only looking for standard infant or toddler items.
Customer Reviews:
Staff has always been friendly and helpful
Always have a great selection and th best spot for funko pops and hard to find figures. Staff has always been friendly and helpful, special thank you to owner for helping me find a gauntlet that been wanting for years! Thank you👍🏾
- Benjamin Baird | Google Review
Such an incredible store!
Such an incredible store! They have treasures old & new! I specifically went to buy legitimate LaBuBus & to buy one of my sons a birthday present & my oh my!! The selection! The vintage Barbie’s! Star Wars!! The funko pop selection! We could spend days in this store! They also buy things so that’s cool too because we are quite the collectors & have some duplicates we could part with potentially in the future 🤪 I can’t wait to spend more money here!
- Brittany Stallcup | Google Review
2. The Toy Drop
Website: https://www.thetoydropindy.com/
Address: 6025 Madison Ave E
Contact: (317) 781-7990 | [email protected]
Hours:
- Monday – Saturday: 11:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Sunday: 12:00 PM – 5:00 PM
The Toy Drop has earned its reputation as a top Midwest destination by expanding significantly in size. In their large store, they have a huge selection that covers rare, vintage, and even modern eras.
They frequently buy entire collections at once to keep their inventory fresh and updated daily. This means you can easily trade your own stash for something new.
The team is made up of avid collectors who really understand the value of the items they appraise. You can just swing by for a firm offer and experience a fast-paced hub that’s perfect for anyone eager to hunt down those forgotten classics.
However, the biggest downside is that there’s no guarantee a specific piece will still be on the shelf when you arrive because stocks move fast.
Customer Reviews:
This second-hand toy store is a total nostalgia hit!
This second-hand toy store is a total nostalgia hit! I was over the moon to find the exact toy I loved as a kid here—and to my surprise, it still works perfectly, just like I remembered. I can’t thank the store enough for bringing back such sweet childhood memories. If you’re after a blast from the past, this place is a must-visit!
- jack li | Google Review
An absolute wonderful and friendly shop
An absolute wonderful and friendly shop. It is extremely well organized. At no time did I need to dig through parts bins and try to figure out what is what. Items were individually packaged and sorted by year.
- B “DKCave” J | Google Review
3. Its A Block Party
Website: http://itsablockpartyonline.com/
Address: 2220 E Southport Rd
Contact: (317) 494-5248
Hours:
- Monday–Saturday: 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Sunday: 12:00 PM – 5:00 PM
Brick builders will be absolutely delighted with this shop. It’s the largest brick store in Indiana, and they have a great trading system that focuses on finding retired or hard-to-find official LEGO sets.
I recently picked up a vintage Star Wars set here for my nephew, and the staff’s expert knowledge made finding the missing pieces a breeze.
Just keep in mind that you won’t find traditional board games or dolls here, since they focus strictly on this one brand.
Still, their dedicated team travels to major conventions across the country to share a catalog that covers almost every theme you can imagine.
They even host lively events in an on-site party room. This serves as a wonderful community gathering spot for all kinds of creative minds.
Customer Reviews:
Very welcoming and awesome experience
Hey just wanted to say your store and staff are absolutely incredible we drove 2 hours from Cincinnati and it was well worth it. The men behind the counter today were super helpful and helped us complete our spaceman collection . The woman with dark hair was exceptionally polite and I appreciate the compliment. Your employees made this a very welcoming and awesome experience will drive up here agin. They deserve a raise.
- josh bauhofer | Google Review
It’s A Block Party is a magical place!
It’s A Block Party is a magical place!! Without fail, everytime I am there I feel like a little kid again. This last week they made Christmas magic by holding a Wicked For Good bookend set for me. The biggest LEGO set I will probably ever own and they made my dreams come true!!! Whether you are a LEGO super fan or new to the party (pun intended), you MUST visit Its A Block Party. Doug and Melissa you guys ROCK!!!
- Madeline Spilker | Google Review
4. The Mulberry Treehouse
Website: https://www.themulberrytreehouse.com/
Address: 7800 Golden Pond Court
Contact: (765) 808-7247 | [email protected]
Hours: Available 24/7
If your family wants to step away from mass-produced plastics, you’ll really appreciate this charming online boutique.
The Mulberry Treehouse specializes in open-ended, handcrafted wooden items sourced from artisans around the world. You can find some truly special gems here, like Waldorf dolls and Toverlux magic lamps.
Because these heirlooms are made by small-scale creators, top items often sell out in a flash. This means you might have to wait a little while for a restock window to open up.
Still, it’s a wonderful resource with an easy-to-use website that lets you sort by age and brand, which helps parents effortlessly create a gentle, eco-friendly environment for their imaginative kids.
Customer Reviews:
So impressed with this company
So impressed with this company. They shipped everything in a beautiful box with confetti and everything was wrapped in beautiful paper. They also sent a lovely hand written note. We have a beautiful memory opening the items with our child. We look forward to purchasing from this shop again soon.
- A M | Google Review
They have beautiful toys for all ages
I’m so happy I found the Mulberry Treehouse! I ordered some woodland animals to decorate for a baby shower (the mom will take them home). I called with a question and they were wonderful to talk to and made sure I would get my order on time! They came packaged with care as you can see from the photos! They have beautiful toys for all ages and I can’t wait to order more for my first grandson, arriving in April!
- Julie Frederickson | Google Review
5. Goodies And Giggles Toy Store
Website: https://goodiesandgiggles.com/
Address: 811 Massachusetts Ave
Contact: (317) 289-1226 | [email protected]
Hours:
- Tuesday–Wednesday: 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Thursday–Saturday: 10:00 AM – 7:00 PM
- Sunday: 11:00 AM – 5:00 PM
If you want playtime to actively support your child’s milestones, this locally owned downtown staple is a go-to.
Goodies And Giggles Toy Store features a catalog entirely curated by an owner leveraging a psychology and child development background from Indiana University.
By focusing on cognitive growth, the shop ensures every puzzle or sensory toy serves a greater purpose. Ten years of research has led to an inventory premium developmental products and custom-made gift baskets tailored to specific needs.
That said, their downtown location might feel inconvenient for suburban families looking for a quick shopping experience, though the unique selection and expert advice often make the trip worthwhile.
Even if your kids prefer loud afternoons running through laser tag arenas and lively arcades, the staff here provides personalized, age-appropriate recommendations to balance their high-energy activities with vetted, brain-boosting tools.
Customer Reviews:
Genuinely pleasant shopping experience
Delightful shop with wonderful gifts for all ages and a genuinely pleasant shopping experience. Staff are friendly and helpful, there are tons of local products, and the space is creatively designed to keep you exploring.
- Megan Real | Google Review
Such an adorable store!
Such an adorable store! So much cute kid toys and boys. Lots of cool stuff to see. Cooler items than what an average store would have! They had a cool old bank area! And they also had jelly blox! Love that toy!
Def recommend for anyone shopping for children! Plus there are some toys out for the kids to play w while shopping
- Jam Smith | Google Review
