Sandra MillerYou might be changing a dead battery before work or starting an engine rebuild. Regardless, finding the best auto parts in Indianapolis is essential for a smooth ride.
Our local area has many shops for both pros and everyday drivers. However, some stores provide better quality than others.
You deserve a shop that offers reliable parts and fair prices without any hassle. I explored the city to find the most dependable suppliers.
Here’s a simple list of the top spots in town to find high-quality accessories and replacement parts for your vehicle.
How much do auto parts cost in Indianapolis?
Replacing common vehicle components ranges from $20 to $300 per part, resulting in an overall average price of approximately $115 for these typical maintenance items.
| Auto Part | Average Estimated Cost |
| Standard 12V Battery | $150 – $250 |
| Ceramic Brake Pads (per axle) | $50 – $100 |
| Spark Plugs (Set of 4) | $20 – $60 |
| Synthetic Motor Oil (5 Quarts) | $30 – $45 |
| Alternator | $150 – $300 |
1. AutoZone Auto Parts
Website: https://www.autozone.com/locations/in/indianapolis/5050-w-washington-st.html
Address: 5050 W Washington St
Contact: (317) 241-3231
Hours:
- Monday – Saturday: 6:00 AM – 12:00 AM
- Sunday: 6:30 AM – 12:00 AM
Working late in the garage often means discovering you need a critical part long after most shops have closed. That’s where AutoZone steps in as a vital local resource for car parts.
They allow customers to handle emergency repairs with late-night hours up to 12 AM.
I actually stopped by their Washington Street location at 11:30 PM last month to find an alternator belt. Even that late, the staff had the energy to help me verify the fitment. The team here provides great support to ensure you get the exact part for your vehicle.
Just keep in mind that some local deals and labor offers expire in only 14 days. This means you need to time your purchases carefully. Still, it’s a very reliable spot for late-night car help.
Customer Reviews:
Was very satisfied
Was very satisfied with the help that I received this evening needed some windshield wipers been to several different places this place found them got them for me and even held in umbrella over my head while I placed them on my vehicle best staff that I’ve met at an auto parts store would recommend anyone going there
- Brian Foutch | Google Review
Has always been extremely helpful
This store always has the parts I need for my Bronco & the staff has always been extremely helpful. Especially the manager, even though I couldn’t find my receipt he made sure I was able to swap out a part that didn’t match my vehicle to the part I needed.
I’ll always make the extra drive to visit this location.
- Zack Wilson | Google Review
2. O’Reilly Auto Parts
Website: https://locations.oreillyauto.com/en-us/in/indianapolis/autoparts-1705.html
Address: 7161 Pendleton Pike
Contact: (317) 546-5604
Hours:
- Monday – Saturday: 7:30 AM – 10:00 PM
- Sunday: 8:30 AM – 9:00 PM
Before you call professional auto repair services in Indianapolis, you might want to visit this popular retailer first.
O’Reilly Auto Parts provides a wide range of replacement pieces and a helpful loaner tool program for your projects. They go beyond just selling parts by offering free battery testing and engine code checks in the parking lot.
You can even have custom paint mixed or recycle your old fluids there. This is very helpful both for the environment and your budget.
One thing to keep in mind is that they don’t install all exterior lights for free. This service depends on your specific vehicle type and can be limited. Despite that, the free tools and testing make it a top spot for local drivers.
Customer Reviews:
5 star customer service
3 months later Dustin saved me again with his 5 star customer service.Make sure to ask for him thank you Dustin..again!
On a very snowy January,
Dustin was friendly , super knowledgeable and quickin helping me out with parts much needed, especially in the cold.Thanks Dustin!
- Kim | Google Review
Everything was in stock and available
Everytime I go to this location the service is ALWAYS exceptional, no matter what time of day. Walking into this store I feel welcome, and safe. This location is clean, open,and well lit. Oh let me point out that RUDOLPH is awesome! Not only him , everyone I have interacted with were very pleasant and knowlegeable,and PATIENT! I have came in to get replacement headlight bulbs, car fresheners ,tire shine,,each time everything was in stock and available. Thanks again for all you do!
- Roderick Long | Google Review
3. Indy U-Pull-It
Website: https://indyupullit.com
Address: 940 W. 16th Street
Contact: (317) 925-2277 | [email protected]
Hours: Monday – Sunday: 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Indy U-Pull-It has a large salvage yard that lets you save money by pulling your own components from their huge inventory. They always have over 1,400 vehicles ready for you, and they add 200 more every single day.
I recently stopped by to look for a taillight, and I cut my repair bill in half by pulling it myself. You can bring your own tools to do the work and save even more on labor costs.
Plus, they offer a 45-day exchange warranty to make sure you’re happy with your parts.
This is a wonderful resource for anyone who likes to fix things themselves while staying on a tight budget.
Just remember that there is a $2 entry fee to access the yard and browse the cars.
Customer Reviews:
This place is awesome
This place is awesome I would highly suggest it to anyone they help you out automatically I didn’t have an issue finding a thing took me no time at all I felt completely happy and comfortable in what part I was getting specifically the two workers named Chris and Giselle are the best ones there they did amazing and helped me out with everything if I put my two cents in I would suggest they get a raise or a promotion immediately without amazing they did helping me out thank you
- Lacey Ciechanowicz | Google Review
4. Advance Auto Parts
Website: https://stores.advanceautoparts.com/in/indianapolis/3521-lafayette-rd
Address: 3521 Lafayette Rd
Contact: (317) 293-3695
Hours:
- Monday – Saturday: 7:30 AM – 9:00 PM
- Sunday: 9:00 AM – 8:00 PM
While you might need security camera experts in Indianapolis to protect your garage, keeping your car in good shape just takes regular maintenance.
Advance Auto Parts is a great local resource because they carry everything you need for basic tasks, like new wiper blades and motor oil. They stock quality components and helpful accessories that make it easy to keep your daily car running smoothly.
They even offer free engine code scanning to help you figure out why a dashboard light is on without paying a mechanic’s fee. And if you change your own oil, you can drop off your old fluids and batteries there for recycling.
This makes it a very convenient and eco-friendly spot for any local driver to visit. Just keep in mind that they close an hour earlier on Sundays than on weekdays.
Customer Reviews:
Very helpful on finding the parts I need
Young man works first shift on lafeyette Rd was very helpful on finding the part I was needing,he went way out of the way and gave me more options to choose from then any cashier before I couldn’t thank him enough.
- floyd proctor | Google Review
Always very attentive
Thanks to Lis for all her help. My car was having problems, and she patiently helped me find the necessary parts. She was also kind enough to install my windshield wipers. She’s always very attentive to all her customers. This is my fourth time buying parts from her, and as long as she’s there, I’ll continue to do so.
- skittles | Google Review
5. Speedway Auto Parts
Website: https://locations.autovalue.com/in/indianapolis/240548/
Address: 2113 E. Washington St.
Contact: (317) 636-4481
Hours:
- Monday – Friday: 08:00 AM – 05:00 PM
- Saturday: 08:00 AM – 01:00 PM
Navigating big corporate chains can feel impersonal when you just want a familiar face and local expertise. Speedway Auto Parts is a locally owned, family-operated business that handles everything from basic maintenance to complex car repairs.
They focus on a friendly service approach and make sure you leave with exactly what you need for your project. Their inventory spans many popular brands to fit different tastes and needs.
They’re also connected to several sister locations nearby. This means they can find parts for you quickly if they’re out of stock at their main store.
One thing to keep in mind is that the shop is closed every Sunday and has shorter hours on Saturdays. This might make it a bit difficult for people who only work on their cars over the weekend.
Customer Reviews:
The machinist was happy
I was not aware that A machinist so exists inside this parts store.
The machinist was happy to press in a u joint for my front 4×4 axel. 20$! Amazing… Rack and axel quoted 120
- derrek alexander whaley | Google Review
