Sandra MillerCraving the best chicken wing in Indianapolis? You’re definitely not alone. If you’re like me, you’ll definitely appreciate a flavorful bite after a long day.
I’ve actually eaten my way through countless joints to figure out exactly which spots deliver the most satisfying crunch. Finding top-tier restaurants is a serious mission, and I’ve done the heavy lifting so you do not have to guess.
Keep reading to discover where to satisfy those deep-fried cravings right here in the Circle City!
How much do chicken wings cost in Indianapolis restaurants?
In Indianapolis, a standard casual dining order of six to ten chicken wings typically costs between $10 and $20, depending on the establishment and portion size.
| Restaurant | Typical Order & Estimated Price |
| Wingstop | 10 wings for around $13.59 |
| Chicken Wing Co. | 10-piece for $13.99; 6-piece for $9.99 |
| Buffalo Wild Wings | 10-piece bone-in for roughly $12.99 |
| Ale Emporium | Large orders typically $15+ |
| Twisted Wings | Known for good deals and large portions |
1. Twisted Wings
Website: https://www.twistedwingsindy.com/
Address: 4148 Boulevard Pl
Contact: (317) 377-4171
Hours: Sunday to Saturday 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM
Finding late-night dining options near uni can be a hassle, but Twisted Wings caters specifically to after-hours diners with an impressive lineup of house-made signature sauces.
You get a solid variety of poultry preparations here, and their hearty appetizer pairings, like fried pickles and street corn, really round out the meal.
I recently stopped by to grab one of their convenient meal bundles, which includes 15 traditional or boneless wings, two dips, large fries, and two drinks, and the rich flavor absolutely hit the spot!
It’s just frustrating that they don’t do deliveries. You’ll have to arrange your own transportation or rely on third-party apps like DoorDash or Uber Eats to get their wings at home.
Single diners might also feel left out by their daily deals; the “Traditional Tuesday” and “Boneless Wednesday” specials, for example, require a 15-wing minimum purchase.
If you’re a first-time buyer, though, you even get a 10% discount when you sign up for their newsletter.
Customer Reviews
This place is worth reviewing which I don’t do much. Im a chicken wing connoisseur and these guy’s wings are fudging amazing. Im from out of town and am trying to rationalize a way to go there again in the next few days. Don’t sleep on the Mango smoothie. It might actually have impressed me as much as their wings. Real ripe mangos, just so good
- Nate Wight | Google Reviews
I was in from out of town I Googled chicken spots and this popped up the wings was great that was delicious they was flavorful they was reasonably priced I like a hard fried wing and that’s what it was and it was still juicy in the inside staff was friendly place was clean the atmosphere was nice next time I’m in Indianapolis I will partake in the restaurant again
- Nada Gardner | Google Reviews
2. Ale Emporium
Website: https://www.ale-emporium.com/
Address: 8617 Allisonville Rd
Contact: (317) 842-1333
Hours: Monday to Thursday 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM | Friday to Saturday 11:00 AM – 1:00 AM | Sunday 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Sports fans seeking high-density visual entertainment will feel at home inside Ale Emporium, which boasts over 190 TVs and nearly 100 draft lines.
They’ve built deep community ties over decades, serving an award-winning recipe that uses a unique dry rub and signature Hermanaki sauce, a secret, sweet, and tangy glaze that’s been an Indianapolis staple since the ’80s.
Beyond stellar chicken, they operate as a full-service bar with extensive options for every palate, including popular thick-crust pizzas.
Their jumbo servings offer great value, and they even provide boneless options made from lightly floured chicken breast strips for an easier bite.
Just expect long queues during peak hours due to their intense popularity. Also note that the original Castleton location is strictly 21+ only. If you’re dining with minors, head to their alternative family-friendly locations in Fishers, Avon, or Greenwood instead.
Customer Reviews
Love the atmosphere, food, beer selection, and service. Waiter made a great suggestion and definitely knew what he was talking about. The boneless wings are some of the best “wings” I’ve ever had, but keep in mind that they’re different from a typical boneless wing from somewhere. It’s such a great cut of chicken that they use. The larger pan pizza was great and gave me a ton of leftovers. Definitely look forward to future trips.
- Tyler Simon | Google Reviews
Got the boneless wings. Normally, i call those “chicken nuggets.” At least that’s what you get from other wing places, but these were in no way a chicken nugget. They were amazing, actual peices of chicken hand cut, lightly breaded, and deep fried. I will only eat boneless wings from this place now on.
- Eric VB | Google Reviews
3. R&R Extreme Wings Bar and Grill
Website: https://rrextremewings.com/
Address: 4361 N Keystone Ave
Contact: (317) 377-4490
Hours: Monday to Friday 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM | Saturday 12:00 PM – 8:00 PM
Finding a reliable late-night spot can be a gamble, but R&R Extreme Wings delivers with a massive selection of over 15 house-made sauces.
You get a solid variety here, from traditional and boneless wings to chicken tenders. These are then paired with hearty sides like hush puppies, fried pickles, and even fried biscuits with apple butter.
I recently grabbed one of their traditional wing baskets, which comes with seasoned fries and a side of ranch, and the flavor was spot on.
They’re especially known for friendly service; regulars often rave about “Auntie” and how the staff welcomes full orders just minutes before closing.
They don’t do native deliveries, though. You’ll have to head to their Michigan Road location or use third-party delivery apps.
Also, while “80-Cent Wing Tuesdays” are a great value, they can lead to significantly longer wait times. If you’re a first-time buyer, ask about their lunch specials, which offer a full meal at a discounted rate.
Customer Reviews
Just moved to Indy and found my wing spot. The chicken was lip shmackingly delicious. Never had better sauce and couldn’t help but eat the cartilage. God bless the beautiful souls that work there too, namely ‘Auntie. Every one I came in contact with showed me the warmest welcome and care. Come for the wings but stay for the fine folks!
- Gerold Abrea | Google Reviews
I wasn’t expecting a lot of meat on each boneless wing, and there wasn’t. I was surprised at the generous amount of fries that came with them; as well as receiving more onion rings than I had expected as a side order. Honey barbecue was a good wing sauce option, without any spicy heat. This restaurant was also generous with additional ranch dressing and ketchup packets. Clean, comfortable seating, with lots of TVs tuned to sports during my visit. Pleasant hosts/waitresses.
- Mark Petrison | Google Reviews
4. Wings Mania
Website: https://www.keystonesportsreview.com/
Address: 2131 East 71st Street
Contact: (317) 358-1288
Hours: Monday to Thursday 10:30 AM – 9:30 PM | Friday to Saturday 10:30 AM – 10:00 PM | Sunday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Wings Mania sets itself apart from standard local fare, so it’s perfect for diners looking for a specific regional recipe.
This place specializes in multi-piece bundles designed for large group gatherings, including party packs that range from 30 to 80 pieces.
Their menu includes specialized low-heat seasoning, so that patrons sensitive to extreme spice levels can still enjoy a flavorful meal. They even provide a vast assortment of fried aquatic proteins for pescetarian guests.
It’s also fantastic that they have snack sizes that are perfect for those on a budget. However, be prepared for fluctuating costs since their menu prices aren’t set in stone.
Also, the lowest available quantity for their signature style is quite small, starting at just 5 or 6 pieces. This potentially requires multiple orders to constitute a full, satisfying meal.
Customer Reviews
This place has the best party wings in the city. Check it out just for that. (a hidden gem) Lemon pepper whole wing!! Prices good. I can vouch for chicken and sides. But they have seafood also… I love this place.
- Philip Jefferson | Google Reviews
Good little wing place. Fresh and hot Everytime I’ve ate here. Celery has been sub par but I never use it. Garlic parmesan is just what I expected, as well as the buffalo sauce. They do drown the wings in sauce. Some pretty decent sides available too. There is a seafood place inside of it as well. I have not tried it as I’m allergic to seafood.
- Aaron Reed | Google Reviews
5. Keystone Sports Review
Website: https://keystonesportsreview.com
Address: 2131 E 71st St
Contact: (317) 251-9902
Hours: Monday to Thursday 11:00 AM – 11:00 PM | Friday to Saturday 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM | Sunday 12:00 PM – 11:00 PM
Upon stepping inside Keystone Sports Review, you’ll immediately see why their “Hall of Fame” chicken wings are marketed as the city’s top offering.
They even have customizable dressing choices, including a “goated” homemade bleu cheese, so you can tailor the taste of their fried shrimp or poultry strips.
Just note that add-ons like celery and carrots are subject to extra fees, and that charge scales up depending on your portion size.
The kitchen also specializes in a unique style of thin-crust pizza, with ingredients distributed completely to the edges to maximize flavor.
If you want to have their food delivered to your place, though, note that they don’t have an online portal. You’ll have to phone your order in or use a third-party delivery app.
Don’t miss out on their indulgent weekday afternoon happy hour, by the way. Though you might want to skip this if you’re consulting with a nutritionist.
Customer Reviews
Great spot with a wide variety of options. The chicken wings were some of the best in the city—crispy, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. The pizza was just OK, nothing special. Overall, worth returning for the wings alone. A solid place for some great wings and bar food.
- Eric Marasco | Google Reviews
Chicken wings with blue cheese is unmatched. Strombolis are also really good. The new location needs some work on the atmosphere but the staff and food are top notch. My favorite place ti go for wings hands down.
- Cynthia Neff | Google Reviews
