Lucas BrennanFinding a skilled drywall contractor in Indianapolis can feel overwhelming, especially when you’re staring at a massive hole in your living room wall.
As a homeowner or property manager, you need someone dependable who delivers flawless results without breaking the budget.
Having navigated the tricky process of vetting tradespeople, coordinating with general contractors, and scheduling post-renovation air duct cleaning, I understand how frustrating it can be.
That’s why we’ve carefully researched the local market to identify the top drywall professionals in the city. These experts combine precision craftsmanship with reliability, ensuring your walls are both structurally sound and perfectly finished.
How much does a drywall installation cost in Indianapolis?
Drywall installation in Indianapolis costs $0.65 to $1.90 per square foot. The final cost depends on several factors, including the type and thickness of drywall used, the complexity of the project, and any additional services.
1. Blankenship Drywall & Plaster Repair
Website: https://frankblankenshipdrywall.com/
Address: Indianapolis, IN 46208
Contact: 317-258-9186 / [email protected]
Hours: Monday – Friday: 8 AM–5 PM
Tackling a home improvement project is much easier when you have a dedicated expert managing the details. That’s exactly what Blankenship Drywall & Plaster Repair offers.
It operates on a hands-on, owner-led model, with the same person handling your estimate and the actual construction.
When a friend hired them for a recent interior upgrade, Frank Blankenship (the owner) personally ensured the texture matching was flawless.
With over 30 years of industry experience, they handle standard installations alongside complex water-damage repairs. They also excel at delivering custom-built solutions tailored to your specific needs.
However, their services primarily cater to residential properties, so large-scale commercial developers might need to look elsewhere.
Clean work.
Fantastic work!!
Highly skilled Veteran at his trade
He’s the Richard Petty of Drywall repair!!
Explained all of the work and materials needed.
Was on time. Very courteous.
Clean work. Cleaned everything after job was done.
Best prices in town.
Felt I knew him 30 yrs.
Very hard to find a contractor of this caliber anymore…
5 stars. Highly Recommend!!
Tom Coglianese, Google Review
The patch is seamless
I can’t say enough about the fantastic drywall repair I received. The frank was professional, prompt, and the quality of his work is absolutely top-notch. You can’t even tell there was a hole in the ceiling. The patch is seamless. Highly recommend the services for anyone needing drywall repair
Justus McGill, Google Review
2. Drywall and Plaster Repair Indianapolis LLC
Website: https://drywallandplasterrepairindianapolis.com/
Address: 327 Jefferson Ave
Contact: (317) 909-1577
Hours: Monday – Sunday: 12:00 am – 12:00 am
Finding a contractor willing to take on minor wall damage can be surprisingly difficult in this city. Drywall and Plaster Repair Indianapolis LLC solves this problem by explicitly welcoming small repair jobs alongside their core services.
Backed by over twenty-five years of specialized experience, they expertly handle both modern drywall systems and historic plaster restorations.
Their ability to seamlessly integrate new patches into older lath-and-plaster walls is a huge advantage for residents of historic neighborhoods.
The main downside is that their business model heavily prioritizes smaller residential fixes over major new builds.
Still, their round-the-clock availability means you can request a fast quote for urgent repairs at any hour.
Finished the job on schedule
Josh did an excellent job of drywall repair, even installing a drywall access panel. After receiving other estimates, I selected josh, and it was the perfect decision. His pricing was fair and he finished the job on schedule. For upcoming drywall projects, I will certainly call on him again. I highly recommend him.You won’t be disappointed.
cheryl starkey, Google Review
An absolutely reasonable price
I had a ceiling bulge in my 100+ year old home (all lath and plaster) that Drywall and Plaster Repair came and removed, then fully repaired. I have heavy, nonstandard texture and he did a great job matching. 2 days of work (1 for removal, 1 for repair) for an absolutely reasonable price. Will be calling them in the future for any further repairs and will recommend to any others that have plaster or drywall needs.
Marianne Sheline, Google Review
3. The Patch Boys of Northeast Indianapolis
Website: https://www.thepatchboys.com/northeast-indianapolis/
Address: Greenfield, IN, 46140
Contact: 317-324-1488
Hours: Mon-Sun 24 Hours
Dealing with ugly wall shadows and uneven finishes after a repair is incredibly frustrating. The Patch Boys of Northeast Indianapolis operates as a highly specialized repair unit, focusing solely on flawless patching and texture-matching.
My sister recently had them fix a prominent hole in my hallway, and their crew completed the entire job perfectly in a single afternoon.
They differentiate themselves by offering full finishing services, meaning they will paint the repaired area, so you do not have to hire an additional contractor.
One drawback is that some customers report their premium pricing does not always align with the value of larger, complex projects.
Despite this, their impressive speed and deep specialization make them highly appealing for quick residential fixes.
Perfect upon completion
I had the most amazing experience with Patch Boys. My contractor completed a drywall and texture match job that I thought was impossible to do. The work was not only perfect upon completion but it was done in a timely and efficient manner. And the clean up was also prioritized. I would recommend Patch Boys to all of Indy. They did an excellent job.
Cynthia Jackson, Google Review
Gave me a reasonable estimate
I had a small area of my ceiling that was damaged by a roof leak. The drywall was okay but the texture was ruined. The Patch Boys responded quickly, gave me an reasonable estimate based on a photo, but suggested I hold off until warmer weather (damage was in my garage). I was able to schedule in early May. The Patch Boys workman showed up on time, protected the surrounding area, and completed the work quickly. Texture is an excellent match to existing ceiling. Would recommend. Note: I have not painted the repaired area in photo, yet, so color does not match.
Tim Fath, Google Review
4. ER Drywall Repairs
Website: https://erdrywallrepairs.com/
Areas served: Hamilton, Hancock, Shelby, Johnson, Hendricks, Boone, Madison
Contact: 317-270-7171 / [email protected]
Hours: Monday – Friday: 8:00 – 5:00
Managing a large-scale renovation requires a team capable of handling every phase of wall construction. ER Drywall Repairs excels as a full-service contractor, managing all stages of construction.
They hand initial tear-outs, wall hangings, and final texture matching. They confidently tackle both commercial and residential spaces too, ensuring that no project is too big or too small.
Their commitment to safety and trust is evident in their strict policy of deploying only background-checked, drug-tested employees.
What we love more is that they help ease financial burdens by offering flexible financing options and insurance support.
The only notable limitation is their standard weekday operating schedule, which leaves no room for weekend or emergency availability.
Very professional and completed the project
ER Drywall was hired by my primary contractor to address drywall issues resulting from storm damage roof leaks. They were very professional and completed the project and cleanup to my satisfaction. One small area stood out after painting and required an adjustment to the ceiling texture. Eric and Travis handled this the following day and the repair looks great. Extremely professional, they use top of the line dustless sanding equipment and are very customer service oriented. I highly recommend ER Drywall.
Marty W, Google Review
They take pride in their work and professionalism
ER Drywall was referred by a friend and am so glad. Had ceiling leak from upstairs restroom and Travis from ER Drywall took great care in restoring everything back to new, also restored our garage ceiling to new from roof leak damage years ago that was not repaired so well by an insurance contractor. Refreshing to do business with those that take pride in their work and professionalism, from initial estimate, scheduling work, and kept informed to the time would be at job which made this a pleasant experience. Definitely would recommend to everyone and will keep them stored on phone.
Walt D, Google Review
5. Cornerstone Painting and Drywall, LLC
Website: https://cornerstone-pd.com/
Address: 13163 N Elster Way, Fishers
Contact: 317.459.4544 / [email protected]
Hours: Monday – Thursday: 8 AM–5 PM, Friday: 8 AM–3 PM, Saturday: 8 AM–12 PM
Coordinating multiple tradespeople for a single room update can cause unnecessary scheduling headaches. Cornerstone Painting and Drywall, LLC simplifies the process by offering fully integrated installation and painting solutions under one roof.
With roughly two decades of local experience, they have built a stellar reputation for precision finishing and maintaining spotless job sites.
Their structured approach to project preparation guarantees durable results for both local homeowners and small commercial clients.
A minor downside is that a few clients have experienced occasional delays in receiving their initial quotes or scheduling communication.
Still, their transparent pricing and award-winning craftsmanship make them a highly reliable contender.
His team cleaned everything up before they left
We experienced an unfortunate leak in an upstairs bathroom which resulted in some drywall and ceiling repairs needing completed. Mike Byers team completed an absolutely fantastic repair and paint to both areas with an expert ceiling texture match. His team cleaned everything up before they left including vacuuming the stairs! Price was extremely fair, half of what another contractor was asking. We are very happy with the results and would definitely use Cornerstone again.
Finish my drywall work on short notice
When another contractor left me high and dry, Mike was able to come to the rescue and finish my drywall work on short notice. His flexibility to get the job done quickly allowed me to keep other contractors on schedule, saving me $thousands$. Will 100% call Cornerstone back for future jobs.
Kelly Salter, Google Review
