Sandra MillerFinding the right support for aging parents is a deeply emotional journey. You want your loved ones to stay safe and healthy while keeping their dignity and independence intact.
I’ve been there, so I know how hard it is to balance family needs with finding caregivers you can trust. That’s why I put together this guide to the best elder care in Indianapolis to ease your mind.
Sorting out the paperwork is part of it too, from insurance forms to a mobile notary public for power-of-attorney documents. Once that’s handled, the right care team treats your parents like family. Here are my top local picks to help you decide.
How much does elder care cost in Indianapolis?
Elder care in Indianapolis runs anywhere from about $15 an hour for an independent caregiver to $8,700-$11,000 a month for a private nursing home room, with assisted living landing around $4,000-$5,000 a month.
| Type of Care | Estimated Cost |
| Nursing Home (Private Room) | $8,700-$11,000 / month |
| Nursing Home (Semi-Private) | $7,133-$8,350 / month |
| Memory Care | $5,852 / month |
| Assisted Living | $4,036-$5,053 / month |
| Independent Living | $3,089 / month |
| In-Home Agency Care | $20-$30 / hour |
| Adult Day Health Care | $1,733-$1,907 / month |
| Independent Caregiver | $15-$22 / hour |
1. Amada Senior Care
Website: amadaseniorcare.com
Address: 8444 Castlewood Drive, Suite 500
Contact: 317 960 4171
Hours: Monday-Friday: Available 24/7
Amada Senior Care really shines at managing Long-Term Care (LTC) insurance claims and finding free senior housing placements. That takes a huge financial weight off your family’s shoulders.
Their local office staff is responsive and easy to reach. I contacted them last year to untangle my uncle’s complex insurance policy, and the whole thing was such a relief.
The rep patiently walked me through the entire claim process step by step. Their caregivers are also warm and dependable when it comes to daily routines.
Their one trade-off is that hourly rates run a bit above the national average. They also stick strictly to non-medical custodial care, so you’ll need a different service if your loved one needs skilled nursing.
Customer Reviews
I highly recommend Amada
I have been a client of Amada Senior Care since 2022. They have helped me understand and navigate the use of a long term care policy, and as my mom’s health declined, began to provide companion services in 2023 at her life plan community. Belinda and her team are organized, kind, compassionate, honest, and well trained. I have deep faith in the aid that assists my mom with all activities of daily living now and shepherds her participation in facility activities. I highly recommend Amada.
– Rich Hauser | Google Review
The caregivers have been extraordinary
The caregivers provided by Amada Senior Care have been extraordinary. Their professionalism, kindness, and care for my father have been wonderful. I am very thankful to have such dependable and capable support for my father as it really provides comfort to our family to have this assistance. Further, the schedulers are pro-active, actively communicate, and make every effort to ensure necessary and timely service. THANK YOU Amada Senior Care! I highly recommend this company as they have proven their commitment to providing the highest standards of dependable care from day one.
– Eugene Martin | Google Review
2. Home Instead
Website: homeinstead.com
Address: 941 E 86th St, Suite 250
Contact: 317 207 1017
Home Instead stands out by carefully matching caregivers to clients based on shared personalities and interests. They back this relationship-first approach with deep training in Alzheimer’s and dementia care.
Their staff really knows how to handle complex age-related conditions. Caregivers here also get extensive education in things like hospice support and emergency response. That high level of support often leads to much better continuity of care.
On top of that, you get a flexible range of non-medical help, from personal grooming to light housekeeping.
The one catch is the strict hourly minimums per shift. Some families also run into scheduling changes that bring different aides to the door, and it can cost more than hiring an independent worker for the same tasks.
Customer Reviews
I would not hesitate to recommend Home Instead
I have been with Home Instead for over 2 years. I have had 2 different caregivers in that time. Both of them were great. The caregiver I have now will do whatever needs to be done and is pleasant and friendly and professional. I have never had a negative experience in the 2+ years I have been with them. I would not hesitate to recommend Home Instead to anyone and have had a positive experience.
– Darren Laughlin | Google Review
A great fit for my mom
We’ve been extremely grateful to have Elly as a caregiver. Her personality has been a great fit for my mom. It’s nice to know that when we can’t be there, my mom can spend time with someone whose company she really enjoys. Elly is a great companion and a HUGE help to us! Thanks also to Home Instead for doing a great job in trying to find the right match of client to caregiver.
– Cara Kurtz | Google Review
3. Senior Helpers
Website: seniorhelpers.com
Address: 6845 Parkdale Place, Suite C
Contact: 317 927 7700
Senior Helpers shines with its own care programs built for specific age-related diseases. Their Alzheimer’s program and custom Parkinson’s care are wonderful resources for struggling families.
The staff goes through strict condition-specific training to handle these exact challenges.
We actually hired them a few months ago for my grandmother’s respite care. The aide took great initiative with meal prep and safely walked her on outings.
Plus, their flexible scheduling works perfectly for out-of-town relatives who need a trusted extra set of hands.
On the flip side, your experience leans heavily on the specific caregiver assigned. Some local branches deal with high turnover and shaky office communication, so you might even get no-shows if staffing gets tight during the week.
Customer Reviews
Great price and great personality
Great price and we have had several of your staff and each has a great personality. No long term commitment with a long contract. Several other companies have higher price and minimums. They seem to REALLY care about helping, but still run as a business.
– Norman Hillman | Google Review
Truly been a blessing for our family
Senior Helpers Indianapolis has truly been a blessing for our family. The caregivers have treated my grandmother with such kindness and compassion, making her feel like part of their own family. From the very first meeting, they developed a personalized care plan that was both detailed and thoughtful, ensuring all her needs were met. Their professionalism and genuine care have given us peace of mind, knowing she’s in excellent hands. If you’re in the Carmel or Indianapolis area and looking for trustworthy home care, I highly recommend Senior Helpers!
– Patricia Simon | Google Review
4. Visiting Angels Senior Home Care
Website: visitingangels.com
Address: 3815 River Crossing Pkwy #100
Contact: 317 284 6867
Visiting Angels lets you interview and choose your specific aide for a perfect skill and personality match. They pair this hands-on selection with custom plans focused heavily on emotional companionship.
You even get a free in-home consultation to size up your exact needs. Their services also go beyond the basics with modern digital assistance options.
Seniors can use smart voice devices to stay safe and connected to their families. Better yet, the caregivers focus deeply on building a genuine, lasting bond with their daily clients.
The main downside is that you might still see several different aides across the week based on availability. Their strict shift minimums often mean booking four-hour blocks, and hourly rates can run high depending on the franchise location.
Customer Reviews
She has been wonderful
Visiting Angels has provided the main caregiver for my wife, who has advanced Alzheimer’s. An agency is only as good as the individual caregiver they provide—and in our case, she has been wonderful. Felicia has been the primary caregiver for my wife 5 days a week for over a year. She is like family, and is an amazing, caring professional that is irreplaceable.
– Michael Lynam | Google Review
Prompt, helpful and very caring
My father needed around-the-clock care for the last two weeks of his life. We contacted Robyn with the Visiting Angels and we had caregivers scheduled by the next day. The Angels who stayed with my father in his independent living apartment were prompt, helpful and very caring. Initially, my father did not see the need for constant care, but he soon came to rely on the caregivers, and he truly looked forward to their visits. He made several new friends in the final few days of his life.
– Jeffrey Claretto | Google Review
5. Advantage Senior Care
Website: advantageseniorcareindy.com
Address: 3905 Vincennes Road, Suite 315
Contact: 317 986 5814
Advantage Senior Care offers flexible, contract-free plans built around immediate or short-term needs. That makes it a perfect fit for families needing temporary respite or post-surgery help without a long commitment.
They use a personal local matchmaking process to pair clients quickly.
Moreover, one huge plus is their willingness to take a wide variety of payment methods.
You can easily use Medicaid waivers or private pay for their services, which takes a lot of the usual payment friction out of the process. It really smooths out a stressful part of caretaking.
Just keep in mind that their services stick strictly to non-medical personal companionship. They also have a smaller local footprint that limits availability during sudden emergencies, and caregiver turnover can sometimes disrupt your daily routine.
Customer Reviews
Very happy with Advantage Senior Care
We have been very happy with Advantage Senior Care. My mom’s caregiver is very kind and attentive. She keeps the apartment in tip top shape. Having someone be able to run errands and take my mom to appointments has been so helpful as well. The peace of mind it gives me to know my mom has someone with her while I’m at work can’t be overstated. The office staff is wonderful too. They are always quick to communicate and have my mom’s best interests at heart.
– Susan Bryant | Google Review
I highly recommend Advantage Senior Care
My name is Marty. I have had good care and my Helper has, and continues to assist with my everyday needs. I also very much appreciate the Office Staff and their continued support and working with me. It’s not just for scheduling and the regular daily business stuff, but they are great about checking in on me and my continued care. Jasmine is great! I highly recommend Advantage Senior Care!
– Marshall Purvis | Google Review
