Lucas BrennanStorms in Indy can wear shingles down fast, so metal is an easy upgrade to look at when you want a roof that lasts longer.
If your project also includes drainage work, lining it up with gutter repair services in Indianapolis can make the whole exterior job easier to plan.
To help narrow it down, I looked into the best metal roofing in Indianapolis and focused on crews with solid installs and warranties that make the price easier to trust.
How much does metal roofing cost in Indianapolis?
The best metal roofing in Indianapolis usually costs about $9,000 to $38,000 for a standard residential replacement, though size, metal type, and tear-off work can push the total higher.
| Property Size / Metal Type | Estimated Price Range |
| Small ranch (1,500 sq. ft.) | $15,000 – $22,000 |
| Standard home (2,000 sq. ft.) | $19,000 – $28,000 |
| Two-story house (2,500 sq. ft.) | $26,000 – $38,000 |
| Large estate (3,500+ sq. ft.) | $38,000 – $55,000+ |
| Corrugated metal | $7.50 – $8.50 per sq. ft. |
| Standing seam | $9.00 – $13.00 per sq. ft. |
| Premium metal shingles | $10.00 – $17.00+ per sq. ft. |
1. Metal Roofing Indianapolis
Website: metalroofingindianapolis.net
Address: Indianapolis
Contact: (463) 231-3049
Hours: No set hours listed
If you want one crew that can handle more than just panels, Metal Roofing Indianapolis is an easy name to keep on your list.
They work on both homes and commercial buildings, and they also take care of related exterior jobs when a project needs more than a simple roof swap.
Just as important, their wider service mix can help if storm damage spreads beyond the roof line. They also offer emergency tarping, plus work on gutters and skylights, so you don’t have to call several companies just to close out one repair.
At the same time, that broad menu is also the main trade-off. Because the team covers several exterior services, they lack the hyper-focused dedication you might find with a contractor who only builds roofs.
Customer Reviews:
Couldn’t Be Happier
I couldn’t be happier with the roof installation service from this roofing company. They were professional, timely, and the quality of work was top-notch. We opted for metal roofing, and it has completely transformed the look of our home. The roofers were polite and made sure everything was cleaned up after the job. I highly recommend them!
Charles Cole | Google Review
Best Business Roofing Services
Based on our many years of working together, we can say for sure that this roofing company provides the best business roofing services in the area. To companies that need a new roof, their metal roofs are a great option because they are made to last and are of high quality. In the course of the project, the crew was always on time and communicated clearly.
Earl Farrell | Google Review
2. Erie Home
Website: eriehome.com
Address: 5757 W 73rd St
Contact: (317) 934-2391
Hours: 24 hours
Some homeowners want the strength of metal without giving up the look of a classic roof. Erie Home fits that need well because they install metal systems that copy the look of dimensional shingles or barrel tile while still offering stronger weather protection.
Because of that, they make sense for older homes or places where the roof still needs to match the rest of the block.
They back their work with a limited lifetime warranty, and the around-the-clock customer support makes the process feel easier if questions come up after the install.
The downside is crew consistency. Because they use third-party installers, the final experience can vary a bit depending on which crew handles your project.
Customer Reviews:
Our Erie Metal Roof Is Spectacular
Our Erie metal roof is spectacular. Though it’s metal, it has restored the original tile look back to our 100+ year old home. Erie’s specialized metal roofing team was quick, hardworking, and professional. Overall, our dealings with Erie have been wonderful. I’d highly recommend their roofing services to anyone.
Lorijo Metz | Google Review
Great Product
We went with the 3D shingles. Cause we didn’t think our HOA would allow the metal. And I have to say, this is GREAT PRODUCT! We have had some pretty good storms come through since we had it installed. And not one shingle is out of place. The guys came out installed in a half a days time. And left no trash on the ground. Very impressed with Erie Construction and would suggest them to anyone!
Bryan Stevens | Google Review
3. Indiana Elite Metal Roofing
Website: indianaelitemetalroofing.com
Address: Indianapolis
Contact: (463) 258-2149
Hours: No set hours listed
Insurance paperwork can drag out a roofing project fast, especially after storm damage.
Indiana Elite Metal Roofing feels useful in that situation because the team pairs free contactless inspections with help during the claims process, which can take some stress off the homeowner.
That support matters when you want answers before the job starts and not after. They’re also fully insured and bonded, and the financing options can make a larger roof bill easier to spread out instead of paying the full amount at once.
The catch is their supply setup. Since they depend on third-party suppliers for materials, some jobs can slow down when a certain panel or finish is backordered.
So, if you need a very specific product on a tight timeline, you may need extra patience before the work begins.
4. Metal Solutions
Website: indianametalroofing.com
Address: 5756 Churchman Rd
Contact: (317) 699-4696
Hours: Mon-Fri 7 AM-4 PM
Fast turnaround matters when you don’t want a roofing project dragging across several weeks.
Metal Solutions stands out here because they make their components in-house, which can cut down the wait that usually comes with outside suppliers and shipping delays.
Beyond that, the tighter process also works well with their factory-trained crews. Instead of handing the installation to random subcontractors, they keep the work more controlled from the material stage to the final placement.
I also like that they use recycled content, which adds value if you want a lower-waste option.
The downside is scheduling. They only work standard weekday business hours, so consultations and project updates can be harder to fit around a full workweek.
Customer Reviews:
Envy Of The Entire Neighborhood
After having a rough experience with another contractor, Doug and Mike came in and did what nobody else could do. Our metal roof has a 50 year warranty and is the envy of the entire neighborhood. The crew was very professional and cleaned up after themselves. They showed up on time, every time. Can’t say enough good things about these guys. Amazing.
jlegear2 | Google Review
Fantastic Job On Our New Metal Roof
I would highly recommend Metal Solutions for your roofing needs. The did a fantastic job on our new metal roof this summer. Doug was always checking in to see the progress of the job and that everything was done correctly. Their workers worked hard and made sure the job was done right. We love our new roof and I would highly recommend them for your roofing needs. Thank you Metal Solutions for an awesome job, well done!
Sandi Shoulders | Google Review
5. Horning Roofing & Sheet Metal
Website: horningroofing.com
Address: 2340 Enterprise Park Place
Contact: (317) 636-9128
Hours: Mon-Fri 8 AM-5 PM
Large commercial properties usually need a very different kind of roofing partner than a single-family home.
Horning Roofing & Sheet Metal makes the most sense in that lane because the company is built around commercial work, backed by decades of experience and a full in-house maintenance team.
For larger sites, that scale can be reassuring when a project involves warehouses or other bigger buildings that need strong coverage and quick response.
They also offer emergency service at any hour, and the added liability coverage gives owners one more layer of protection when the job size gets serious.
The main downside is fit. Since they focus so heavily on commercial and institutional buildings, they may not be the right match for a standard residential roof replacement.
