Lucas BrennanDealing with cracked walls or sagging ceilings can turn your home into a stressful place. You might be managing short-term rentals or restoring a beautiful historic home, but you still need an expert for delicate repairs.
It is important to find someone who understands historical lath techniques and modern finishes.
To help narrow down your choices, we looked into local contractors to find the best plasterers in Indianapolis to save you the trouble.
Below, we break down the top professionals who can blend new patches into your surfaces.
How much does plastering cost in Indianapolis?
Plastering in Indianapolis costs $2 to $10 per square foot for materials and labor.
| Service or Material | Estimated Cost |
| Standard Room (10×10) | $800 – $4,000 |
| Minor Repairs | $20 – $80 per square meter |
| Professional Labor | $60 – $80 per hour |
| Skim Coating | $1.10 – $1.30 per square foot |
| Ceiling Work | $600 – $800 |
| Exterior Stucco | $4.50 – $9.00 per square foot |
1. Drywall and Plaster Repair Indianapolis LLC
Website: https://drywallandplasterrepairindianapolis.com/
Address: 327 Jefferson Ave
Contact: (317) 909-1577
Hours: Monday – Sunday: 12:00 AM – 12:00 AM
If you’re working on an older home, you know it takes a special touch that most contractors just do not have. Drywall and Plaster Repair Indianapolis is a great choice because it specializes in historic plaster-and-lath repair.
With over twenty-five years of experience, they know exactly how to restore walls and ceilings. They do more than just patch holes by matching textures and paint, so the fix stays hidden.
One thing we also love is that they are happy to take on small projects. You can reach out for a minor crack, and they will treat it with care.
However, they only work within the city limits. This means you might need to look elsewhere if you live in the suburbs.
Their expertise makes them a solid local resource.
Josh did an excellent job
Josh did an excellent job of drywall repair, even installing a drywall access panel. After receiving other estimates, I selected josh, and it was the perfect decision. His pricing was fair and he finished the job on schedule. For upcoming drywall projects, I will certainly call on him again. I highly recommend him.You won’t be disappointed.
- cheryl starkey | Google Review
Absolutely reasonable price
I had a ceiling bulge in my 100+ year old home (all lath and plaster) that Drywall and Plaster Repair came and removed, then fully repaired. I have heavy, nonstandard texture and he did a great job matching. 2 days of work (1 for removal, 1 for repair) for an absolutely reasonable price. Will be calling them in the future for any further repairs and will recommend to any others that have plaster or drywall needs.
- Mariane Sheline | Google Review
2. Linehan’s & Son’s Plastering
Website: http://linehanandsons.net/
Address: 2306 Reformers Ave
Contact: (317) 626-6312
Hours: Monday – Sunday: 8:00 AM – 7:00 PM
It’s easy to make visible mistakes when you rush a structural repair, but Linehan’s & Son’s Plastering uses a structured four-phase plan to get things right.
They start with a free strategy session to make sure everyone is on the same page before any work begins. This team brings generations of knowledge to a craft that many people have forgotten.
When I worked with them on a ceiling issue, their planning removed all the stress from the situation. It feels great to hire a team that cares more about high-quality results than finishing as fast as possible.
However, their thorough process might feel slow if you only need a same-day patch. Because their pricing depends on that first meeting, you will not find flat rates on their website.
Very positive experience
Cannot recommend Russ and his team enough! Their attention to detail, efficiency, and friendliness made our stucco repair a very positive experience. It’s clear that Russ and his team are true experts at what they do and the job they did on our stucco repair reflects that.
- Maddie Venable | Google Review
Rusty did an outstanding job
Rusty did an outstanding job on our home that was damaged from a tree falling and had cracks in plaster ceilings and walls. They took care in each room to cover the floors and prevent dust from spreading and did excellent repair work. Now the house looks great. Every other contractor said they couldn’t repair plaster and we should rip it out. I am grateful that Rusty and his crew were able to restore our home without losing its character.
- Lisa | Google Review
3. BLANKENSHIP DRYWALL & PLASTER REPAIR
Website: https://frankblankenshipdrywall.com/
Address: 2860 Harlan St
Contact: [email protected]; (317) 258-9186
Hours: Monday – Friday: 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Handing over your home to a rotating crew of strangers during a renovation can be really nerve-wracking. With BLANKENSHIP DRYWALL & PLASTER REPAIR, the owner personally handles every phase from the initial estimate to the final labor.
This ensures you get strict accountability and consistent results every time. With 33 years of experience, they are experts at restoring historic plaster and matching tricky textures such as knockdown.
They even provide custom services for bathroom cabinets and built-in bookcases to help you finish your space.
What’s even better is that you can just send photos for a fast and free estimate, which is great for busy homeowners.
Just be aware that their service area is mostly focused on neighborhoods like Meridian Hills.
Also, they only do residential work, so property managers seeking industrial projects will need a larger firm.
Fantastic drywall repair
I can’t say enough about the fantastic drywall repair I received. The frank was professional, prompt, and the quality of his work is absolutely top-notch. You can’t even tell there was a hole in the ceiling. The patch is seamless. Highly recommend the services for anyone needing drywall repair
- Justus McGill | Google Review
4. 317 Wall and Ceilings
Website: http://317wallandceilings.com/
Address: 426 N Gray St
Contact: (317) 795-5337
Hours: Monday – Sunday: 8:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Finding a contractor willing to show up for a small wall dent is surprisingly hard. 317 Wall and Ceilings focuses on smaller residential jobs and brings 20 years of experience to older, historic homes.
They use an artistic eye for matching textures to ensure the transition between old and new surfaces is flawless.
When my sister hired them to fix a water-damaged corner in her hallway, she was so impressed by how well they blended the new material into the wall. You also save time because they handle painting and trim work too.
Just keep in mind that an accurate quote usually needs an in-person inspection.
Their skills are also better suited to homeowners than to large commercial projects. This makes them a perfect choice for those small but important home repairs.
Did an amazing job
This guy did an amazing job. He was responsive, followed up consistently, and delivered clean, professional work backed by years of experience and artist talent. I would highly recommend Josh to anyone who needs help with plaster repairs.
- Michelle Lemond | Google Review
Extremely pleased!
Could not be happier with the multiple dry wall repair work done earlier this week. This is the second time I have used them and I would never think of calling anyone else. A great fair price, amazing outcomes, efficiently done and a complete clean up. The owner is an artist and somehow replicated the look of our textured ceiling in a large dry wall patch. Extremely pleased!
- Roger Sweets | Google Review
5. The Patch Boys of Northeast Indianapolis
Website: https://www.thepatchboys.com/northeast-indianapolis/
Address: Greenfield, IN 46140
Contact: (317) 324-1488
Hours: Available 24/7
Living in a construction zone for weeks is a common frustration during home updates. The Patch Boys of Northeast Indianapolis solves that problem by specializing in single-day turnarounds for small repairs.
They expertly match existing textures and even provide painting services, leaving you with a finished surface.
Their team focuses on the minor jobs that large firms often overlook, and they always check the framework to ensure the repair lasts. They also maintain high standards of cleanliness by using drop cloths to protect your floors.
Just keep in mind that they only handle patching, so they are not the right fit for total gut renovations.
Plus, their service is limited to the northeast suburbs, so residents on the other side of town are outside their area.
I was very happy with the work
We needed a drywall repair in a difficult spot in our garage around out HVAC return duct, and also some joint taping throughout most of the garage. Rob came out early, repaired our drywall, and re-taped the majority of our garage. I was very happy with the work he did, especially considering the troublesome location of the drywall repair. Good price, and professional work. I highly recommend
- Isaac Miller | Google Review
They’ve done a great job
I’ve used Patch Boys for two projects in my 1909 home. They’ve done a great job skim coating and repairing plaster walls, patching dry wall and painting. Sarah is easy to communicate with and is quick to schedule projects. I would definitely recommend.
- Alecia Nafziger | Google Review
