Andre TaylorDealing with a cracked driveway or a pothole-ridden parking lot is a headache nobody wants. Having a well-paved road isn’t just about curb appeal; it‘s about safety and avoiding costly vehicle damage.
But finding the most reliable Indianapolis contractors for asphalt paving takes a bit of work, though it’s necessary if you want experts to handle the heavy lifting. It could make all the difference for your property!
Lucky for you, I’ve explored local options and tracked down the best asphalt paving pros in Indianapolis today. Read on to know the choices that can help you secure a durable pavement!
How much does asphalt paving cost in Indianapolis?
In the Indianapolis area, asphalt paving rates vary widely depending on the scope of your project and the type of repair or installation needed. Below are the current rates:
| Project Type | Average Cost Range |
| Routine sealcoating | $0.20 – $0.70 per sq. ft. |
| Asphalt repairs and patching | $250 – $800 |
| Driveway resurfacing | $400 – $1,800 |
| New driveway installation | $1,200 – $4,000+ |
1. AAA Sealcoating and Paving
Website: http://aaasealcoatingandpaving.com/
Address: 5614 N Oxford St
Contact: (317) 771-9281
Hours: Monday to Sunday: 7 AM – 7 PM
To achieve a resilient pavement seal, a detailed hand-applied squeegee or brush technique with industrial-strength sealer is vital, and that’s where AAA Sealcoating steps in.
Here, they avoid standard spray applications, opting instead to deeply saturate pores for maximum longevity. Furthermore, their commitment to quality is evident in the careful cleaning and edging they perform prior to any application.
This team is also highly punctual and operates with little impact on your daily routine. Clients receive reliable, unchanged estimates, even if unforeseen damage is discovered during the process.
While the service is generally excellent, it’s worth mentioning that a few customers I spoke with have noted small overlooked areas that necessitated a return visit for touch-up work.
Customer Review
Wonderful job
As a commercial real estate property manager, I have used multiple asphalt contractors over the years, and these guys are one of the best! They took on a large job of a complete removal and overlay of a retail property parking lot, and did a wonderful job! No problems! No delays! No excuses! Would I use them again, Yes! I have and I will.
- tracey creal | Google Review
We couldn’t be happier
Couldn’t have found a better crew in Indy. We had a giant project and Joe and his guys handled it smoothly and professionally. We couldn’t be happier. I wouldn’t use anyone else for asphalt work!
- Jason Basso | Google Review
2. Silvers Concrete and Paving, LLC
Website: https://silversconcreteandpaving.com/
Address: 1311 W 96th St
Contact: (317)-835-8991 | [email protected]
Hours: Available 24/7
Knowing your driveway can survive harsh Indiana winters brings a lot of peace of mind. Silvers Concrete and Paving backs their highly durable 4,500 PSI paving mixes with an impressive three-year structural warranty.
Impressively, they formulate their specialized mix specifically to enhance resilience to extreme weather.
My neighbor recently used them for a large custom layout, and I saw firsthand how swiftly they cleared the debris and finished the project.
Moreover, this team is fully capable of completing complex residential and commercial layouts ahead of schedule.
The only real downside is that occasional measurement discrepancies have sometimes led to finished slabs being poured smaller than initially planned.
Customer Review
Highly recommend
We had an estimate done for some concrete and asphalt work at our house, and Kyle handled it very professionally and in great detail. The communication throughout the process was top notch and the work matches that. Highly recommend using Silvers for your project!
- Caleb Sidener | Google Review
3. Five Star Paving
Website: http://5starpavingservice.com/
Address: 1350 W Southport Rd suit 262
Contact: 3173392107 | [email protected]
Hours: Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday: 9 AM – 5 PM; Friday: 9 AM – 6 PM; Saturday, Sunday: Closed
Working with a contractor feels much safer when you know leadership is heavily involved. At Five Star Paving, the owner is personally present at every job site from the initial estimate through final completion.
It’s impressive that this family-owned operation brings over 40 years of local paving experience to the table.
Notably, they offer cost-effective asphalt overlay options as a smart alternative to full tear-outs. You can also rely on them for comprehensive line striping to maintain ADA compliance in commercial lots.
Just keep in mind that their reliance on a smaller crew size can extend project timelines for large-scale commercial paving jobs.
Customer Review
Outstanding quality work
I had a great experience with Five Star Paving! The team was professional, punctual, and delivered outstanding quality work. They paid attention to every detail and made sure the project was completed on time. The driveway looks amazing and the pricing was fair. I highly recommend them to anyone looking for reliable and top-quality paving services in Indianapolis
- Taniya Taniyah | Google Review
Highly recommend Five Star Paving
I recently hired Five Star Paving for a paving project, and I couldn’t be happier with the results. The team was professional, punctual, and very detail-oriented. They completed the job on time and the quality of their work truly stands out. The driveway looks smooth, clean, and perfectly finished. I highly recommend Five Star Paving to anyone looking for reliable and high-quality paving services
- Curtis Reyes | Google Review
4. Grady Brothers Asphalt
Website: https://www.gradybros.com/
Address: 915 S Somerset Ave
Contact: (317) 937-6210 & (317) 710-6361
Hours: Monday to Friday: 7:00 AM – 5:00 PM; Saturday, Sunday: Closed
Major infrastructure projects require materials and sustainable practices that meet rigorous state standards.
As the area’s most established asphalt contractor, Grady Brothers Asphalt exclusively uses INDOT-specified materials and environmentally conscious recycling methods.
To be honest, it’s quite impressive to see how their crews actively reclaim and recycle old, milled asphalt, a practice praised by local municipal planners.
This deep-rooted expertise is bolstered by veteran crews with an average of 24 years of experience, ensuring exceptional structural integrity on every project.
However, because they primarily focus on large-scale commercial contracts, they may not be the most practical choice for small residential driveway repairs.
Customer Review
Communication was excellent
I was the project manager for a large project. We vetted multiple companies and Grady Brothers was the best choice to award the bid. They had the experience and expertise to mitigate all of our issues. Communication was excellent. The project was completed on time and budget. Highly recommend.
- Chad Budreau| Google Review
5. City Wide Paving
Website: https://www.cwpaving.com/
Address: 4440 S. High School Rd.
Contact: (317) 244-2000 | [email protected]
Hours: Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday: 8 AM – 5 PM; Saturday, Sunday: Closed
Maintaining an outdoor surface means preparing for the harsh winter months and the hot summers.
City Wide Paving delivers year-round property maintenance support by combining robust asphalt services with extensive winter snow plowing and ice management.
They even carefully adjust drainage structures during paving to prevent standing water issues from developing later.
It’s also notable that this fully licensed team has been heavily involved in the community since 1988.
Plus, they provide a comprehensive suite of resurfacing services, showing the same dedication to quality as a trusted cabinet painting service or a reliable stucco contractor in Indianapolis.
On the downside, some internal reports note that management and site foremen occasionally lack coordination on active job sites.
