Sandra MillerAre you looking for the best cupcakes in Indianapolis to satisfy a sugar craving? I understand the need for a perfectly frosted cake that melts in your mouth.
The Circle City has many talented bakers who make amazing buttercream and fluffy cakes daily. Choosing the right bakery is very important for a party or a small reward after a long week.
I can show you the top spots to visit for your next treat. These local shops will help make your dessert run a success.
How much do cupcakes cost in Indianapolis?
Budgeting for your sweet tooth is easy, as standard bakery treats usually range from $3 to $5 per piece, while a gourmet dozen might set you back up to $40.
| Cupcake Type | Price Range |
| Specialty/Gourmet | $3.50–$4.00 each ($37–$50/dozen) |
| Jumbo | $6.00+ each ($60+/dozen) |
| Budget/Grocery Store | $0.75–$1.00 each ($4.48–$6.00/6-pack) |
| Mini | ~$30.00/dozen |
1. Smallcakes Cupcakery & Creamery
Website: https://www.smallcakescupcakeryindiana.com/
Address: 930 Broad Ripple Ave
Contact: (317) 389-5447
Hours:
- Tuesday – Thursday: 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM
- Friday – Saturday: 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM
Planning a weekend dessert run for your whole family is easy when you visit this Broad Ripple favorite.
Smallcakes Cupcakery and Creamery is great because it offers a wide variety of treats. They have large cupcakes and even DIY decorating kits for kids.
I recently brought home one of their carrot Pupcakes, and my golden retriever loved the peanut butter frosting. Beyond the usual menu, you can find mini cupcakes for smaller appetites and several vegan options.
However, people with serious food allergies should be careful. Their gluten-free and dairy-free items are made in the same kitchen as other products. This means there is a small risk of cross-contamination.
Despite this, it’s a wonderful spot for a family treat if you want something delicious and fun to share together at home.
Customer Reviews:
We will definitely be back.
I am so glad we stopped here. He made our stop extra special, with a candle and a happy birthday tag for the birthday cupcake. Great atmosphere, even with the construction goin on outside the door. Didn’t stop us from coming in. Thanks for making our first visit a memorable one. We will definitely be back
- L Y | Google Review
By far the best balanced cupcake I have ever had.
I was surprised by my roomate when he returned from Indy with this box of cupcakes. My first thought was ugh, that icing is gonna be sickeningly sweet and overtake the taste of the cupcake… NOPE! This is by far the best balanced cupcake I have ever had! I am totally impressed, excited and happy that my roomie thought to introduce me to this! I can’t say enough! Amazing, delicious, balanced, yummy and overall a perfect 10!
- Damon Murray | Google Review
2. The Flying Cupcake
Website: https://www.theflyingcupcakebakery.com/
Address: 4026 E 82nd St
Contact: (317) 396-2696 | [email protected]
Hours:
- Monday – Thursday: 10:00 AM – 7:00 PM
- Friday – Saturday: 10:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Sunday: 12:00 PM – 5:00 PM
Finding a proven local favorite often leads you directly to this beloved bakery. Recognized as the original cupcake shop in Indiana, The Flying Cupcake has served award-winning desserts for over a decade.
They have grown to include several locations and even mobile dessert trucks. Their commitment to high-quality ingredients is clear because they use rich buttercream instead of fondant.
You can also walk in any day to grab vegan options without needing a preorder. If you are planning to visit one of the local fine dining restaurants, picking up a cupcake as a quick snack is a fun idea.
Just remember that their vegan products are prepared on shared equipment. This could be a concern for anyone dealing with severe health issues like Celiac disease.
Still, overall, it’s a fantastic spot for a reliable and tasty treat.
Customer Reviews:
We obviously left with more!
Nice little cupcake shop. We came here for gluten free cupcakes for a friend and obviously left with more! Friendly lady helped us out and even did a little modification to the cupcake decorations for us.
- James Hall | Google Review
The black bottom cupcake is life changing.
The original Indy cupcake spot (IMO). Love ❤ their red velvet cupcake (classic). But the black bottom cupcake is life changing, lol! They also do cakes! Expect to spend about $4/cupcake, flavor selection changes daily with a few constants. You wont be disappointed 😋😍 * parking lot out front for easy parking
- Tabitha | Google Review
3. Taylor’s Bakery
Website: https://taylorsbakeryindy.square.site/
Address: 6216 Allisonville Rd
Contact: (317) 251-9575 | [email protected]
Hours: Tuesday – Saturday: 7:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Stepping into a piece of local history makes picking up dessert feel very nostalgic and comforting. Taylor’s Bakery is a historic, fourth-generation business with over a century of experience.
They specialize in traditional recipes that locals have loved for decades. Their classic whipped buttercream pairs perfectly with the soft, fresh cake texture they have perfected over the years.
You will find a very large menu that allows you to order custom wedding cakes and fresh doughnuts at the same time. They’re also very efficient and can finish custom orders with just a one-day notice.
On the downside, because they’re a full-scale traditional bakery focused on larger requests, their daily variety of cupcake flavors might seem smaller than that of a boutique shop.
However, the quality and history make every visit feel special and reliable for any occasion.
Customer Reviews:
Perfect for any celebration or sweet craving!
Taylor Bakery delivers a delightful cupcake experience—moist, flavorful cake paired with smooth, rich frosting that’s just the right amount of sweet. Whether you’re into classic vanilla or bold red velvet, each bite tastes homemade with love. Perfect for any celebration or sweet craving!
- Natalie Perry | Google Review
The cupcake box was a hit!
The IU game cookie and cupcake box was a hit! I bought some for my clients and saved the box for my sister in law, but she wasn’t home and we ate them! Delicious 🤤
- Jessica Arviso | Google Review
4. Goody2Treats
Website: https://www.goody2treats.store/
Address: 5450 E. Fall Creek Parkway N. Drive, Suite 106
Contact: (317) 389-8564 | [email protected]
Hours:
- Tuesday – Thursday: 12:00 PM – 7:00 PM
- Friday – Saturday: 12:00 PM – 8:00 PM
- Sunday: 12:00 PM – 6:00 PM
Indulging in a giant and rich dessert is easy when you head over to Goody2Treats. They specialize in extravagant jumbo treats with fun flavors such as Banana Pudding and Strawberry Cheesecake.
I recently picked up a Biscoff Cookie Butter version for a birthday, and the weight of the frosted pastry was really impressive. These substantial portions use high-quality ingredients like real fruit and actual cheesecake pieces hidden in the middle.
If you’re hosting a large gathering, adding these massive treats to your catering plan will surely impress your guests.
Just keep in mind that each piece costs around seven dollars. Because of the cost, these are more of a luxury splurge than an affordable daily snack.
The price is a bit high, but the quality and size offer a truly unique dessert experience.
Customer Reviews:
Will definitely return.
Very unique and different flavors of cupcakes. The chicken and waffle cupcake and the biscoff cupcakes were 10/10. My wife loved the strawberry banana pudding also. Prices are really good also. Will definitely return. Staff was very patient, kind, and took the time to explain all the different offerings.
- smileythegreat03 s | Google Review
Great price point, and great taste!
Great service, Great price point, and Great taste! I was in a crunch and needed a dessert platter at the last minute. The owner kindly accommodated my last min order with superb quality. Thank you!!
- Mandy Gonzalez | Google Review
5. Vanilla Bean Bakery
Website: https://www.vanillabean-bakery.com/
Address: 1510 W. 86th Street
Contact: (317) 337-9470 | [email protected]
Hours:
- Monday: By appointment only
- Tuesday – Friday: 11:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Saturday: 10:00 AM – 2:00 PM
- Sunday: 11:00 AM – 2:00 PM
Corporate gatherings and elegant weddings always need a personalized touch to truly impress your guests. Vanilla Bean Bakery specializes in custom dessert catering and offers beautiful spreads for all kinds of major events.
They even provide customized edible image branding, so local businesses can print their company logos directly onto the icing.
You can easily order different sizes, from small miniature bites to standard portions. This makes it very simple to scale your dessert table for any guest list.
However, planning a last-minute party with their menu is quite difficult because of their strict notice rules. Special requests like vegan cakes or sugar-free pastries require at least two full days for preorders.
You also have to meet specific minimum quantity limits for these items. While you need to plan ahead, the high level of customization makes it worth the wait.
Customer Reviews:
We loved every bite.
Amazing cupcakes!! I emailed and asked for a dozen assorted cupcakes for my wife’s birthday. We were not disappointed not only did we love the way they looked but we loved every bite. If you are looking for cupcakes or delicious sweet treats I would highly recommend Vanilla Bean Bakery even in these trying times.
- Brian Lohroff | Google Review
Can’t wait to visit in person. 🙂
I sent my best friend surprise birthday cupcakes (under quarantine)! Little did I know she ordered herself some cupcakes from Vanilla Bean too. They were happy to refund her after MY cupcakes were delivered earlier than scheduled. Thanks VB for making the two of us super happy on a special day and in the middle of some trying times! Can’t wait to visit in person. 🙂
- Maha Kamal | Google Review
