Sandra MillerThere’s nothing quite like the clinking of glasses and the rich, savory aroma of a shared meal to bring people together.
Whether you’re orchestrating a corporate holiday party or planning a dream rehearsal dinner, finding the perfect venue is everything.
I scoured the city to find the absolute best private dining spots Indianapolis has to offer, from historic warehouses serving up farm-fresh plates to swanky supper clubs dripping in nostalgia. Get ready to drool over some seriously mouthwatering group menus.
How much does private dining cost in Indianapolis?
Private dining in Indianapolis ranges from casual group packages to upscale minimum room spends, depending heavily on your guest count and chosen venue.
| Experience Type | Average Cost |
| Casual Group Packages | $47 per person |
| Upscale Set Menus | $85 – $150 per person |
| Fine Dining Minimum Spend | $1,000 – $3,000+ per room |
1. Bluebeard
Website: https://bluebeardindy.com/private-dining/
Address: 653 Virginia Ave
Contact: (317) 686-1580
Hours:
Lunch: Monday – Saturday: 11 am to 3 pm
Dinner: Monday – Thursday: 5 to 10 pm, Friday – Saturday: 5 to 11 pm, Sunday: 5 to 10 pm
Stepping into this historic 1924 factory warehouse instantly sets the mood for an unforgettable feast. Bluebeard offers two distinct private spaces that dish out curated farm-to-table menus bursting with local ingredients.
Their in-house sommelier helps you pick out the perfect wine pairing for your meal. They even have a private patio for a breezy cocktail hour, making this spot a dream for intimate celebrations.
I actually helped my sister plan her rehearsal dinner here last fall, and the dedicated event coordinators made the entire process stress-free. They even connected us with a stellar local bakery for take-home treats.
While the food is undeniably mouthwatering, you should know that their cozy Second Story event space is only accessible via a 21-step staircase. This might pose mobility challenges for some guests.
Bluebeard is our favorite restaurant in Indy. We got engaged here and even had our wedding in their private events room. Service is always a 10/10. Our favorite meal includes the grilled bread, chop salad, spaghetti and alpine fizz. Honorable mention is the masaman from this past winter. You can’t go wrong with any order and nothing we love more than a date night on the patio.
Maddie Bryan | Google Review
It was a Game of Thrones kick off for the final season. The restaurant was closed for the private event of about 20-30 people. Staff were in themed attire- unlimited wine & beer included. Food included shrimp, turkey legs, roasted chicken, and an “out of this world” pot pie (I still dream of it!). It was more food than you could eat and we even got to take home leftovers! They really take care of you!
Lauren Martinez | Google Review
2. The Fountain Room
Website: https://www.thefountainroom.com/private-events/
Address: 830 Massachusetts Ave, Suite 1480
Contact: 463-238-3800, [email protected]
Hours:
Monday – Thursday: 4 pm – 10 pm
Friday: 4 pm – 11 pm
Saturday: 10 am – 11 pm
Sunday: 10 am – 9 pm
The Fountain Room is a stylish supper club in the historic Bottleworks district. They blend an upscale dining atmosphere with thoughtfully tailored group gathering spaces.
The private dining rooms here are complete with plush velvet banquettes and glowing chandeliers. They also provide a dedicated Event Sales Manager who makes planning a full venue buyout for up to 160 seated guests an absolute breeze.
Food-wise, they serve nostalgia served alongside classic American fare. Your mouth will water just reading over their traditional supper club selections like the juicy salt-crusted prime rib and crisp signature pickled relish trays.
Keep in mind that the venue doesn’t open its doors until 4:00 PM on weekdays, completely ruling out the possibility of hosting a corporate lunch. But the curated cocktails and swanky ambiance still make it an irresistible choice for evening revelry.
Wow! Start to finish wow! I don’t even know how to articulate the experience, but I’ll try. We had a reservation and were seated immediately. Our water glasses were never empty. The server, Meg, was just the right amount of attentive and gave us alone time too. She had great recommendations! I had the French dip and it was so delicious! My dude had the pork tenderloin and the way the chef married the apples was next level. The detail in the decor was stunning and the care they took in the bathrooms was wonderful. Highly recommend!
Bree | Google Review
Went here for my boyfriend’s birthday. Absolutely loved it! Our waitress was so friendly and knowledgeable about the menu, and offered great wine selections and different menu options. Beef Tartare was delicious, and I would recommend the sea bass and duck confit. Great drinks, great dinner, very welcoming staff and ambience was exactly what i was looking for. I will definitely be a repeat patron.
M K | Google Review
3. Culinary Dropout
Website: https://www.culinarydropout.com/locations/indianapolis-in/
Address: 1320 E. 86th Street
Contact: (463) 231-8050
Hours:
Monday to Thursday: 11 AM – 11 PM
Friday: 11 AM – 12 AM
Saturday: 10 AM – 12 AM
Sunday: 10 AM – 10 PM
Throwing a high-energy bash is effortless at this rebellious American Bistro. Culinary Dropout is where structured group gathering spaces meet an eclectic menu and expertly crafted cocktails to create an electric, crowd-pleasing vibe.
I recently attended a friend’s rowdy birthday dinner here, and we couldn’t get enough of the vibrant live music.
They serve endless rounds of crave-worthy appetizers ranging from delicate sushi to crispy Detroit-style pizza. They also have fantastic options for catering in Indianapolis if you want to take their delicious eats off-site.
The only catch is that this lively atmosphere can get quite loud. It might not be the best fit for a formal corporate presentation, but for kicking back with a huge group of friends, the bold flavors and killer tunes are totally unbeatable.
A perfect brunch spot for groups. The food is genuinely great (I recommend starting with the pretzels!) but the vibe is what really makes it! Welcoming and easy to settle into with friends. Our server Coba was a huge part of that experience. He was attentive without hovering, incredibly kind, and did an amazing job guiding us through the menu and pacing everything so the table stayed relaxed and fun. We even ate dessert!!! Can’t wait to come back 🙂
Mad Sciarra | Google Review
This place was perfect for a girls night! We were celebrating a friends birthday and they were very accommodating. They had a birthday sign and brought out dessert at the end of our meal. The food was delicious! The only downside was it was pretty loud and kind of hard to hear each other.
Lindsay Bean | Google Review
4. Commission Row
Website: https://www.commissionrow.com/about/
Address: 110 S Delaware St
Contact: (317) 550-2500, [email protected]
Hours:
Monday – Thursday: 4:00 – 10:00 PM
Friday – Saturday: 4:00 – 11:00 PM
Sunday: 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Towering near the Gainbridge Fieldhouse, Commission Row is a multi-level entertainment venue with a massive upper event center.
The sheer scale of their “Above” event space is jaw-dropping, easily swallowing up over 200 guests for extravagant wedding receptions.
It’s also undeniably cool that your party can seamlessly transition down into their adjoining public speakeasy for a moody nightcap.
They boast an expert culinary team serving up prime steaks and an incredibly fresh raw bar. You can treat your guests to luxurious seasonal ingredients and flawlessly paired spirits here.
The cuisine is top-tier, easily rivaling fine dining Restaurants in Indianapolis.
On the flip side, because the venue features such a sprawling layout, it can feel slightly cavernous and might lack the cozy intimacy you would want for a secluded family dinner.
Had a fantastic experience here to celebrate my birthday! Melia was a kind and informative server and made sure we were taken care of. I think this was the best crab cake and Chilean sea bass I had ever had, melt in your mouth. I loved the steak and mushrooms. They made me a custom mocktail. Desserts were great too. Melia got us a tour of the downstairs speakeasy, Mel’s, which is a super well designed space with live music.
Madeline Garcia | Google Review
Food was amazing! We ordered the 6oz filet, cesar salad, wedge salad and the dessert where to die for! Pastry chef Nicole brought us our dessert and explained in detail what it was! Colby was our server and he was very nice, fun and knowledgeable. Everyone made us feel welcomed! 10/10
Natalie | Google Review
5. Dean’s Steak & Seafood Indianapolis
Website: https://www.deanssteakhouseindy.com/private-dining-indianapolis
Address: 10 S. West Street
Contact: (317) 860-5777
Hours:
Monday to Thursday: 5:00 PM – 10:00 PM
Friday to Saturday: 5:00 PM – 11:00 PM
Sunday: 5:00 PM – 9:00 PM
Slicing into a perfectly seared premium hand-cut steak is the ultimate way to celebrate. That’s what you get at Dean’s Steak & Seafood Indianapolis.
This upscale destination delivers distinguished private gatherings with impeccable flair. They feature a breathtaking signature Grand Plateau seafood tower that’s enough to make any seafood lover weak in the knees.
A dedicated events team works tirelessly behind the scenes to coordinate large party reservations. They ensure that the cellar wines flow freely, and every crafted libation is chilled to perfection.
There’s even complimentary valet parking, which saves your downtown guests from the usual headache.
You do need to plan your event around their schedule, though. They exclusively operate for evening service starting at 5:00 PM, making lunchtime corporate meetings an absolute no-go.
But for an unforgettable decadent affair, this plush steakhouse is a surefire way to dazzle your dinner guests.
I can’t recommend Dean’s enough! Truly exceptional steakhouse in Indianapolis. Started off with an oyster martini at the bar, then headed to the table for the meal of a lifetime. The Salmon Wellington was a delicious option for the non-beef eaters. My bone-in strip was impeccable. 10/10 experience and the atmosphere cannot be beat. Can’t wait to come back!
Sidenote: I asked the manager for a tour and got to see the private dining room. WOW! I will be having my next private event there if I can.
Conner White | Google Review
WOW is all that can be said! The space itself is gorgeous and makes for such a fun night out. The service, food, drinks, and design were all impeccable! I can’t wait to go back 🙂 I also got to take a look at their private dining room – so beautiful. Would be the perfect space to host an event!
Erica Sibley | Google Review
