Lucas BrennanIf you’re tired of constant staining and fading wood, exploring the best shops for composite decking in Indianapolis is a smart next step. These materials deliver a polished, modern look without the ongoing maintenance traditional wood requires.
Whether you plan to tackle the build yourself or collaborate with experienced deck builders, sourcing premium supplies makes a huge difference.
To make the search easier, we’ve taken the time to review local suppliers and compare what they offer in terms of quality, style, and reliability.
Here’s a closer look at the best places to find the right foundation for your outdoor project.
How Much Does Composite Decking Cost in Indianapolis?
Composite decking in Indianapolis generally costs between $40 and $80 per square foot for both materials and professional installation.
| Project Component | Estimated Cost |
| Materials Only | $5 – $15 per square foot |
| Professional Labor | $9 – $15 per square foot |
| 10×10 Standard Deck (Total Cost) | $3,500 – $5,000 |
| 16×20 or 20×20 Premium Deck (Total Cost) | $11,200 – $24,000 |
1. Decks & Docks
Website: https://www.decks-docks.com/locations/indianapolis-in
Address: 4322 W 96TH ST. INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46268
Contact: (317) 471-0400
Hours: 8:00am-5:00pm Mon-Fri
Tackling a major backyard renovation is much easier when you can source all your decking and marine construction materials in a single location. Decks & Docks acts as a true one-stop shop, carrying premium brands like Trex and Fiberon for a highly durable finish. Their team brings over two decades of focused expertise to the table, helping both homeowners and contractors choose the right high-density polyethylene (HDPE) or polyvinyl chloride (PVC) boards.
Decks & Docks serves as a convenient sourcing point for decking and marine construction materials. They’re especially reliable for projects that require durable, weather-resistant products.
They stock well-known brands like Trex and Fiberon. Their inventory also typically includes composite options such as HDPE and PVC boards, which are commonly used for long-lasting outdoor builds.
When a close friend of mine bought materials here for a backyard patio, what stood out first was the staff’s product knowledge. Their 20-year experience in this niche was very apparent.
They were able to explain the differences between composite options clearly and helped narrow down choices based on durability and intended use, which made the decision process much easier.
The downside came later in the project. Delivery delays pushed the timeline back more than expected.
Some customers also mentioned a few frustrating moments with incomplete initial shipments. They had to do repeated follow-ups with staff just to get basic updates on order status.
Very accommodating
Bill & Scott built our deck and we are thrilled with the results. They really know their carpentry. We used the Diamond Pier Footers system due to our flat yard with poor drainage and they installed them without hitch. Mike was very accommodating with customizations and additions. Thanks guys!
Gary Wilcox, Google Review
2. 84 Lumber
Website: https://www.84lumber.com/projects-plans/deck-packages/
Address: 9084 CORPORATION DR INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46256
Contact: 317-849-4584
Hours: Mon – Fri: 7:00AM – 6:00PM, Sat: 8:00AM – 12:00PM
84 Lumber is one of the larger privately held building materials suppliers in the U.S. This makes it a reliable option for full-scale construction or deck projects where having access to a wide inventory matters.
They carry well-known composite brands like TimberTech and AZEK. These are practical options if you’re aiming for durable, low-maintenance outdoor builds.
What’s even better is you can bring your blueprints directly into their local store to receive accurate material estimates and custom design support.
The main frustration tends to come after the planning stage. Some customers have reported order processing errors that delay fulfillment beyond initial timelines, slowing construction schedules.
Refunds or corrections can also be inconvenient, sometimes requiring in-person visits instead of being handled smoothly online or over the phone.
Very impressed
Went to several big box stores to look for composite decking materials. One didn’t have anyone in that knew anything about them, another had people that claimed to be experts but were clearly uninformed. I was happy when I visited Von Tobel – Denise helped me and was able to answer ALL of my questions and even provided information that I didn’t know that I needed. I have been very impressed with her personally, if she reflects what Von Tobel is then I want to shop there more.
Jeff Gray, Google Review
3. Von Tobel
Website: https://vontobels.com/timbertech-composite-decking/
Address: 319 N Earl Ave Lafayette, IN 47904
Contact: 765-448-1525
Hours: MON – FRI 7:00AM-6:00PM, SAT 7:00AM-4:00PM
Visualizing how different board textures and colors will look against your home is a vital step before making a major financial commitment. That’s why we appreciate that Von Tobel makes this process easy.
They offer an interactive physical showroom and specialized 3D deck planning services, making it easier to visualize how products might look once installed.
They focus heavily on premium TimberTech products, giving remodelers access to incredibly realistic wood finishes backed by robust warranties.
We actually visited their Lafayette location to browse their low-maintenance samples and found their design consultation very helpful.
That said, their initial material estimations can sometimes be inaccurate, leaving you short on crucial supplies mid-project.
When those issues come up, resolving them isn’t always smooth, as communication gaps can slow down corrections or inventory fixes.
A large selection
This place is great for your DIY project. The employees in there are very helpful with getting your project going. They also seem to have a large selection and a lot of products available in store
Curt x, Google Review
4. Menards
Address: 7701 E 42ND ST, INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46226
Contact: 317-549-2696
Hours: Mon – Saturday 6:00 AM to 10:00 PM, Sunday 8:00 AM to 8:00 PM
Sourcing materials for an outdoor upgrade should not automatically force you to drain your entire renovation budget. Menards provides a fantastic, budget-conscious alternative through their exclusive in-house UltraDeck composite line.
These eco-friendly boards are manufactured from recycled wood fibers and plastics, offering an affordable entry point without sacrificing long-term durability.
Handy DIY enthusiasts will also appreciate their accessible installation guides and manageable price tiers.
The trade-off for these savings is a distinct lack of on-floor staff assistance when you actually need expert advice. You might also run into frustrating roadblocks with their clunky online order placement system and unexpected in-store stock limitations.
A wonderful experience
Had a wonderful experience with Menards Delivery for a large deck project I’m doing. Worth every penny and I could NOT have moved this much lumber on my own. Scheduling was easy and you could tell they’ve got a good process in place. Text messaging on arrival time and what to expect was spot on. Shout out to P&T Transport LLC. This guy was a pro and really knew how to move that truck around!
Ray Lawson, Google Review
5. Musselman
Website: https://musselmanlandscape.com/composite-decking-deckorators/
Address: 17505 Durbin Road, Noblesville, IN 46060
Contact: (317) 773-5399
Hours: Hours vary seasonally
Coordinating separate deliveries for structural lumber and decorative garden elements often turns simple yard upgrades into logistical nightmares.
Musselman eliminates this headache by operating as an integrated supplier for both landscape materials and premium Deckorators composite decking.
The advantage here is local expertise. As a long-running, family-owned business established in 1989, they tend to be familiar with regional installation needs and can also connect customers with deck installer.
Their composite boards are also positioned for durability, with slip-resistant and moisture-repellent properties suited for outdoor conditions.
On the practical side, deliveries are not always perfectly tidy. Some customers have noted that shipments can arrive with a lot of excess packaging and leftover debris, which means additional cleanup work after drop-off
Brought exactly what they said they would
Could not have been easier. Placed my order online on Friday for delivery on Saturday. They called me before they left to deliver, and brought exactly what they said they would. Delivery driver was super friendly. Will definitely order here again!
Amy Lintern, Google Review
