Andre TaylorFinding the perfect present often feels like a daunting task.
Event planners putting together corporate gifts, visitors looking for meaningful local souvenirs, and anyone trying to find something thoughtful all run into the same problem: too many options, not enough direction.
That’s why we explored the local retail scene to find the best gift shops in Indianapolis that are actually worth your time. We visited gift shops, assessed their offerings, and compared pricing.
Instead of sorting through endless big-box stores, this guide focuses on local spots that make gift shopping easier, more personal, and a lot more enjoyable.
1. Silver In The City
Website: silverinthecity.com
Address: 434 Massachusetts Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Contact: 317-955-9925
Hours: Monday to Saturday 10:00AM–8:00PM | Sunday 10:00AM–6:00PM
Hunting for unique gifts is pretty easy at Silver In The City, thanks to their eclectic mix of jewelry, quirky finds, and home goods.
They’ve been around since 2000 and are known for curating items that feel more personal and unusual than typical retail offerings.
It’s the kind of place where you can easily find something gift-worthy, especially if you’re pairing it with bouquets from local flower shops.
They also offer some convenient services, including in-store drop-offs for online returns. If you’re looking for something more specific, you can place custom orders by phone or email.
The main drawback is their return policy. Items need to be in perfect condition to be accepted, and mailed returns don’t get the original shipping fee refunded.
Even so, the unique product selection tends to make the shopping experience feel worth it for most visitors.
Adorable trinket shop perfect for getting a gift or just browsing items relevant to the season and the current day. Solid collection of jewelry both showy and more laid back. Definitely recommend if you’re queer and looking for a shop to feel at home in.
- clyde “the” fox | Google Reviews
My favorite queer little gift shop in the world! I come here whenever I’m in town just for the immaculate vibes. A little cramped, but there’s a wonderful sense of community and acceptance you won’t find anywhere else.
- Alexis B | Google Reviews
2. Circle City Souvenirs
Website: circlecitysouvenirs.com
Address: 115 W Washington St Suite 150, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Contact: 317-841-8251 | [email protected]
Hours: Monday to Saturday 9:00AM–7:00PM | Sunday 10:00AM–6:00PM
Circle City Souvenirs offers an incredibly comprehensive collection of state-themed merchandise, so it’s one of the top spots if you’re looking for some local mementos.
It’s located inside the downtown indoor walkway system, so you can browse without worrying about the weather. Parking is also conveniently located nearby, making quick stops or short visits easy.
I recently picked up a few Indianapolis magnets for visiting family, and the whole trip felt very smooth.
The current owners bring a lot of retail experience, and the staff keeps an eye on local trends so the merchandise stays relevant to the city. Online orders also come with a flat-rate shipping fee, which keeps costs predictable.
That said, their apparel selection is quite small, since they focus more on souvenirs and small items.
Their dual role as a wholesale distributor for competing stores may also dilute the direct retail experience slightly.
Even so, the rotating selection and occasional discounts make it a worthwhile stop.
This amazing gift and souvenir shop is located inside the Hyatt Regency hotel, in the lobby area. This shop has a vast collection of local made goods. They also have items for some of Indiana’s favorite brands like IU, Colts, Perdue. Among the products they have apparels, accessories, home goods, posters, magnets, stickers, cups, mugs, stationary, key rings and so much more. They take online orders too and ship all over the country.
- Nehal | Google Reviews
If you did not have enough of Indy, Circle City Souvenirs is there for your Indiana and Indianapolis souvenir needs. The shop is located on the third floor of Circle Centre Mall in downtown Indianapolis, next to the Sunglass Hut.
Circle City Souvenirs offers assorted postcards and souvenirs as well as Indiana and Indianapolis T shirts and Hoodies, various food and gift items made in Indiana, including a selection of Vera Bradley items!
- Eleodor Sotropa | Google Reviews
3. Twisted Sisters
Website: twistedsistersindy.com
Address: 3937 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46240
Contact: 317-841-7177 | [email protected]
Hours: Monday to Friday 10:00AM–6:00PM | Saturday 10:00AM–5:00PM
Shoppers who prefer unique, locally made items will probably enjoy Twisted Sisters, since most of their inventory comes from regional makers. Instead of mass-produced products, they focus on handmade goods and regularly rotate new items into the shop.
I stopped by recently while looking for a housewarming gift, and the staff was very helpful in narrowing down a few good options.
You’ll find a mix of product types, including clothing, accessories, and home décor. The store clearly leans into supporting small businesses and independent artists, which gives the space a more personal, local feel.
If you enjoy hunting for unique treasures at local markets, the setup here feels pretty similar.
It’s just a bummer that they don’t offer online shopping, so you’ll need to visit in person to see what’s available. The store is also closed on Sundays, which can limit scheduling for some shoppers.
Still, the friendly service and unique selection make the trip worthwhile.
The best Northside boutique for trinkets, seasonal clothing, and gift wrapping! Yes, gift wrapping! Julie is a joy! She’s inviting, honest, and gives you an opportunity to shop without pressure!
- Brandon Brown | Google Reviews
Twisted Sisters has been my favorite gift shop since I first wandered in. Everyone there is always happy and helpful and FUN! I’m always able to find a unique gift or something a little more traditional if needed. They always wrap everything free of charge. My friends’ eyes all light up when they see I’ve bought them something from this cute shop. The location they’ve moved to is so easy to get to. If you haven’t walked into Twisted Sisters yet, you are long overdue for this treat.
- Laura Howie-Walters | Google Reviews
4. Global Gifts
Website: globalgiftsft.com
Address: 873 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Contact: 317-423-3148
Hours: Monday to Sunday: 11:00AM–5:00PM
Ethical shopping is a big focus here, since Global Gifts works directly with certified fair trade artisans.
Their mission centers on supporting disadvantaged creators, and that purpose is evident in the products they carry.
The store has been part of the community for several decades and continues to build on those relationships. They also offer subscription-style deliveries for certain product categories, which is a convenient option for repeat purchases.
Customers generally benefit from a fairly generous return window, which offers more flexibility than many retail stores.
Online orders can also be returned in person at the physical shop, helping avoid return shipping costs. If there’s a shipping mistake, they typically cover the cost of sending the correct item.
That said, the store is very clear that they’re not responsible for packages lost in transit, which is something to keep in mind when ordering online.
In some cases, local pickup orders may also involve unexpected shipping charges if the item isn’t immediately available in-store.
A wide variety of different items from around the world. I enjoyed the staff’s knowledge of the different items – it was cool to learn while looking at these awesome things. Prices aren’t too outrageous for the type of things there are, and the fact that it’s all fair trade makes this a place I’ll likely return to for gift ideas.
- Pamela Scott | Google Reviews
5. Black Sheep Gifts
Website: blacksheepgiftshop.com
Address: 5626 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46219
Contact: 317-602-5442
Hours: Monday to Thursday 11:00AM–7:00PM | Friday to Saturday 11:00AM–8:00PM | Sunday 12:00PM–5:00PM
Operating under strong female leadership, Black Sheep Gifts focuses on supporting regional creators across its two storefronts. The brand’s identity is shaped by the owner’s family background, which gives the shop a warm, welcoming feel.
The staff also helps put together custom gift assortments on demand, which is useful when you want something more personalized.
Shoppers get complimentary packaging materials, which takes the stress out of wrapping gifts. They also offer vehicle-side service for customers in a hurry, so you can pick up items without going inside.
When you do go inside, though, the employees provide hands-on help to make sure you leave with something that fits your needs
The shop keeps its digital presence minimal, though. Many items aren’t available online.
Sunday hours are also shorter than on weekdays, which can limit weekend visits.
I went to this adorable quaint shop after work today to get a unique gift for my dear friend at work. I wasn’t sure what she liked, collected, etc. So I wanted to get something different and unique. OMG y’all. They had the wind chimes that will “play” Amazing Grace. Great price. Lady, maybe owner, was super helpful, kind and patient. I was there a very short time and found exactly what I was SO HAPPY with. One errand ran on a week night. Good for me! I’m leaving for vacation Saturday. Short on time. THANK YOU.
- Diana Hoke | Google Reviews
Whenever I need something special for my wife or family and friends- this is my go-to gift shop!! Lisa, Scott and entire staff always pick out the perfect items! Plus they sale this amazing pancake & waffle mix!
- JOHN BRITAIN | Google Reviews
